<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<?xml-stylesheet type="text/xsl" href="https://www.makatilawfirm.com/sitemaps.xsl" ?>
<urlset xmlns="http://www.sitemaps.org/schemas/sitemap/0.9" xmlns:image="http://www.google.com/schemas/sitemap-image/1.1">	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/05/30/excess-cwt-refund-claims-remain-timely-when-filed-within-two-years-from-the-annual-income-tax-return/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T18:04:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/05/30/five-year-prescription-in-criminal-tax-cases-clarified-for-preliminary-investigations/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T18:01:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/05/30/tax-criminal-cases-can-survive-prescription-but-still-fall-to-prosecutorial-delay/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:59:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/02/reinsurance-firm-upheld-on-excess-input-vat-dispute-for-2016/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:56:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/03/customs-criminal-cases-can-be-dismissed-when-prosecutors-fail-to-submit-complete-supporting-evidence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:54:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/03/customs-criminal-cases-can-be-dismissed-when-probable-cause-evidence-is-incomplete/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:51:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/03/local-business-tax-dispute-makati-denial-of-takenaka-branch-protest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:49:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/03/vat-refunds-for-zero-rated-services-need-clear-proof-of-foreign-currency-payment-or-valid-offsetting/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:46:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/03/excess-cwt-refunds-require-traceable-income-records-not-proof-of-bir-remittance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:44:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/03/local-tax-refund-appeals-can-fail-on-procedure-even-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:41:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/03/key-takeaways-on-tax-refund-claims-after-cta-decision-on-mr-mindanao-container-corporation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:39:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/01/birs-civil-tax-claims-upheld-through-certiorari-after-rtc-errors/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:37:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/09/tax-criminal-acquittals-are-hard-to-undo-without-osg-authority-and-true-grave-abuse/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:34:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/09/invalid-tax-assessments-nullify-criminal-liability-for-willful-non-payment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:32:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/09/late-tax-appeal-results-in-dismissal-for-lack-of-jurisdiction/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:29:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/06/customs-smuggling-case-dismissed-after-prosecution-failed-to-submit-complete-evidence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:27:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/17/vat-refund-claims-can-still-be-proven-in-court-despite-bir-denial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:25:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/10/premature-final-assessment-notices-can-void-bir-tax-assessments-despite-later-service/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:22:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/10/vat-refund-claims-by-direct-exporters-can-fail-when-filed-with-the-wrong-bir-office/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:19:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/11/bir-assessment-voided-after-ignoring-taxpayers-pan-reply/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:17:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/24/excise-tax-refunds-on-lpg-sales-to-tax-exempt-entities-need-exact-tracing-not-just-exemption-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:14:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/13/tax-refunds-cannot-revive-a-final-deficiency-assessment-after-compromise-settlement/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:10:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/13/bir-cannot-revive-expired-tax-assessments-without-proof-of-a-willful-false-return/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:07:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/13/quezon-city-tax-assessment-overturned-dkt-health-secures-refund/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:05:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/17/old-vat-refund-judgments-can-still-be-enforced-through-revival-before-the-10-year-deadline/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T17:02:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/11/conflicting-tax-payment-deadlines-can-void-a-bir-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:59:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/17/late-bir-appeal-locks-in-cancellation-of-deficiency-income-tax-and-vat-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:56:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/17/petron-denied-excise-tax-refund-for-lubricating-oils-sold-to-exempt-entities/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:54:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/17/understanding-customs-case-delays-and-rights-to-speedy-disposition-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:51:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/11/missed-customs-appeal-deadlines-can-end-a-seizure-case-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:49:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/19/invalid-tax-assessments-halt-collection-efforts-against-diageo-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:46:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/20/deficiency-tax-assessment-voided-for-lack-of-valid-loa/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:43:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/20/unauthorized-revenue-officer-voids-tax-assessment-and-forces-refund-of-garnished-amount/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:41:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/01/vat-refund-denied-when-intercompany-offsetting-was-not-proven-by-separate-evidence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:38:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/01/how-philippine-airlines-secured-a-tax-refund-after-jurisdiction-dispute/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:36:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/23/how-importers-can-redeem-seized-shipments-without-fraud-liability/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:33:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/23/stefanini-philippines-vat-refund-denial-highlights-filing-deadlines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:31:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/24/vat-refund-denied-after-airline-catering-company-failed-to-prove-zero-rated-sales-with-compliant-receipts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:29:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/24/condominium-corporations-exempt-from-local-business-tax-key-en-banc-cta-ruling/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:25:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/24/bir-collection-case-dismissed-after-government-failed-to-prove-taxpayer-received-assessment-notices/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:23:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/24/cooperatives-cannot-rely-on-bir-certificates-alone-to-defeat-vat-ewt-and-dst-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:20:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/24/tax-assessment-voided-when-bir-cannot-prove-receipt-of-final-assessment-notice/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:15:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/25/vat-refund-survives-challenge-despite-zero-rated-invoice-imprint-objection/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:13:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/25/holcim-denied-local-business-tax-refund-in-manila/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:10:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/26/jet-fuel-excise-tax-refunds-court-allows-p207-8m-tax-credit-for-sales-to-qualified-international-carriers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:08:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/26/cwt-refunds-can-survive-bir-inaction-but-carried-over-credits-reduce-the-claim/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:05:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/26/tax-refund-appeals-can-be-lost-by-missing-the-cta-electronic-filing-requirement/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T16:01:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/17/indoor-playgrounds-beat-quezon-city-amusement-tax-assessment-after-cta-rejects-overbroad-local-tax-theory/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:59:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/01/bayer-philippines-secures-refund-for-erroneously-paid-excise-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:56:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/27/how-zero-rated-vat-refunds-are-secured-for-philippine-exporters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:54:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/30/how-to-secure-zero-rated-vat-refunds-for-rohqs-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:51:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/30/carrying-over-excess-cwts-can-defeat-a-cash-refund-claim-before-the-tax-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:49:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/06/30/bir-tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-taxpayers-protest-is-ignored/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:47:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/07/vat-refund-claimants-cannot-rely-on-icpa-reports-alone-to-prove-zero-rated-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:44:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/11/wrong-taxable-period-in-a-tax-assessment-notice-will-not-always-void-a-bir-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:40:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/10/exporters-need-traceable-remittances-to-win-vat-refunds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:37:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/02/monarch-agricultural-vat-refund-denial-highlights-key-compliance-gaps/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:33:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/01/renewable-energy-contractors-can-recover-input-vat-only-with-complete-zero-rating-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:31:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/08/government-agencies-cannot-bring-bir-assessment-disputes-directly-to-the-tax-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:28:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/01/filing-deadlines-are-jurisdictional-one-day-delay-costs-lbc-express-its-tax-appeal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:25:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/04/criminal-tax-evasion-case-dismissed-after-prosecutors-failed-to-allege-the-basic-tax-amount/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:23:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/04/finality-of-tax-assessments-and-prescription-periods-in-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:20:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/04/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-taxpayers-pan-reply-is-ignored-2/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:18:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/01/due-process-violation-voids-electric-cooperative-tax-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:14:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/07/one-day-delay-in-challenging-bir-collection-defeats-taxpayers-assessment-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:12:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/07/zero-rated-vat-refund-denied-for-non-registered-branches/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:09:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/08/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-notices-are-improperly-served-or-prematurely-issued/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:06:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/08/bir-tax-assessments-without-a-payment-due-date-may-be-void/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:04:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/01/tax-assessments-void-when-due-process-ignored-in-philippine-bir-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T15:01:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/08/tax-liability-case-highlights-limits-on-corporate-officer-accountability/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:59:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/09/taxpayers-can-defeat-final-assessments-when-due-process-defects-make-the-assessment-void/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:57:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/10/missed-deadlines-can-end-a-tax-refund-fight-even-before-the-merits-are-reached/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:54:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/10/bsp-secures-refund-for-erroneously-paid-capital-gains-tax-on-land-sale/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:52:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/10/acquittal-upheld-drivers-not-liable-for-excise-tax-on-untaxed-cigarettes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:49:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/10/defective-bir-demand-notice-cancels-p88-3-million-tax-assessment-against-gaming-operator/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:46:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/11/missed-24-hour-efiling-requirement-can-defeat-a-tax-appeal-before-the-court-of-tax-appeals/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:44:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/11/vat-refund-appeals-may-be-dismissed-when-the-denial-comes-from-the-wrong-bir-official/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:42:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/11/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-substitute-revenue-officers-audit-without-a-proper-loa/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:39:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/11/unauthorized-revenue-officers-can-void-a-bir-tax-assessment-2/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:36:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/11/failure-to-comply-with-efiling-rules-deems-tax-petition-not-filed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:34:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/11/city-cannot-inflate-local-business-tax-base-using-older-gross-sales-when-current-sworn-sales-are-declared/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:32:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/14/missed-electronic-filing-can-defeat-a-tax-appeal-before-the-court-of-tax-appeals/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:29:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/14/missed-filing-deadline-results-in-dismissal-of-tax-petition-for-waste-management-corp/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:27:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/01/taxpayer-denied-relief-over-missed-formal-letter-of-demand-protest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:24:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/17/vat-refunds-can-still-fail-when-official-receipts-do-not-state-the-nature-of-services/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:22:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/15/delayed-tax-prosecutions-can-be-dismissed-when-the-five-year-prescriptive-period-has-lapsed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:19:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/17/vat-refund-denied-zero-rated-sales-receipts-must-describe-the-services-rendered/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:16:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/16/bir-assessment-voided-after-ignoring-taxpayers-pan-reply-and-using-unauthorized-revenue-officer/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:13:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/16/bir-assessment-cancelled-after-premature-final-notice-and-defective-denial-of-protest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:10:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/16/tax-collection-barred-by-prescription-in-construction-firm-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:07:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/16/prolonged-tax-case-delay-leads-to-dismissal-under-right-to-speedy-trial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:05:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/17/late-government-appeal-ends-tax-code-criminal-case-on-jurisdictional-grounds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T14:02:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/17/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-nic-and-pan-are-not-validly-served/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:59:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/17/fuel-suppliers-can-recover-excise-tax-on-peza-bound-petroleum-but-only-with-delivery-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:57:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/02/vat-refunds-can-fail-without-clear-proof-of-foreign-currency-remittance-or-valid-offsetting/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:54:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/01/timely-protest-essential-to-contest-tax-assessments-in-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:52:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/28/foreign-sellers-may-claim-cgt-refund-on-philippine-share-sales-covered-by-tax-treaty/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:50:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/01/taxpayer-victory-on-motion-for-reconsideration-denial-reinforces-assessment-procedures/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:47:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/bir-tax-assessment-voided-when-final-demand-lacks-a-clear-payment-due-date/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:45:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/01/late-filing-of-motion-for-reconsideration-leads-to-dismissal-in-customs-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:42:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/29/late-motions-can-end-a-customs-criminal-case-before-warrants-are-issued/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:40:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/17/late-reconsideration-keeps-customs-criminal-case-dismissed-without-prejudice/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:38:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/29/taguig-city-local-business-tax-refund-upheld-for-union-cement-holdings/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:35:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/01/commercial-invoices-alone-cannot-win-a-vat-refund-for-export-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:33:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/07/01/navigating-vat-refunds-key-lessons-from-british-american-tobacco-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:30:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/01/mindanao-container-secures-partial-vat-refund-for-zero-rated-exports/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:28:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/01/due-process-violation-voids-tax-assessment-and-levy-on-apex-5678-rockwell-inc/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:25:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/19/bpo-exporters-can-still-recover-input-vat-but-only-with-strict-invoice-compliance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:23:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/19/wrong-zonal-value-can-support-a-capital-gains-tax-refund-tax-court-says/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:21:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/21/timely-vs-late-tax-appeals-key-cta-guidance-for-philippine-taxpayers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:18:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/20/tax-evasion-case-dismissed-after-government-filed-criminal-information-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:16:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/01/court-dismisses-tax-case-due-to-jurisdictional-limits-under-p1m-rule/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:13:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/20/late-tax-protest-leads-to-dismissal-of-petition-against-cir-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:11:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/21/pdr-tax-prosecution-fails-without-proof-of-dealer-status-or-taxable-gain/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:08:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/21/timely-protest-crucial-for-security-service-tax-assessments-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:05:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/deficiency-tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-bir-demand-letters-give-conflicting-due-dates/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:03:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/24/oceanagold-secures-full-input-vat-refund-after-cta-en-banc-review/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T13:00:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/24/customs-seizure-denial-upheld-importers-must-verify-duty-payments-and-procedural-compliance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:58:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/25/how-businesses-can-secure-refunds-for-excess-creditable-withholding-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:56:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/25/how-boehringer-ingelheim-secured-php-89m-vat-refund-on-imported-medicines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:53:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/25/expired-assessment-periods-can-void-deficiency-tax-assessments-despite-bir-quarantine-extensions/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:51:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/26/bir-audit-assessments-void-when-revenue-officers-lack-proper-authority/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:49:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/26/vat-refund-appeals-can-be-lost-when-the-taxpayer-ignores-a-bir-denial-letter/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:46:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/26/rohq-wins-partial-vat-refund-for-services-to-foreign-ultimate-parent/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:43:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/27/tax-collection-warrants-can-be-voided-when-the-bir-acts-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:41:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/27/late-e-filing-did-not-automatically-kill-a-local-business-tax-appeal-filed-during-the-transition-period/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:38:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/27/bir-tax-assessments-may-be-voided-when-an-unauthorized-group-supervisor-continues-the-audit/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:36:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/27/bir-collection-by-distraint-and-levy-fails-when-a-tax-protest-is-still-validly-pending/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:33:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/27/due-process-in-tax-audits-why-unauthorized-revenue-officers-invalidate-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:29:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/27/timely-appeal-crucial-in-customs-seizure-cases-lessons-for-importers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:27:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/07/local-franchise-tax-assessments-can-still-be-cancelled-when-lgus-tax-outside-their-jurisdiction-or-use-arbitrary-computations/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:25:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/27/vat-refund-denied-for-failure-to-prove-zero-rated-sales-through-proper-official-receipts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:22:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/27/tax-refund-denials-require-the-right-remedy-mandamus-will-not-force-a-discretionary-bir-refund-decision/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:19:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/28/meat-importers-lose-tariff-challenge-as-higher-duty-rate-on-mdm-is-upheld/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:17:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/28/tax-refund-judgments-can-be-revived-when-the-bir-fails-to-pay/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:14:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/28/electric-cooperatives-registered-with-nea-can-defeat-income-tax-assessments-under-pd-269/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:11:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/28/fuel-companies-can-recover-excise-tax-on-sales-to-international-carriers-and-tax-exempt-entities/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:08:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/28/beer-excise-tax-refunds-taxpayers-can-challenge-invalid-bir-rules-before-the-tax-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:06:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/06/customs-criminal-case-dismissed-after-prosecution-failed-to-prove-probable-cause/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:03:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/28/customs-criminal-cases-can-collapse-when-the-prosecution-fails-to-prove-probable-cause/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T12:01:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/28/environmental-fees-may-fall-outside-tax-court-review-when-they-are-primarily-regulatory/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:58:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/28/cash-bond-releases-in-tax-criminal-cases-require-proof-of-who-paid/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:55:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/28/prosecution-dismissed-for-failure-to-file-tax-case-on-time/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:53:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/28/failure-to-protest-tax-assessment-leads-to-dismissal-of-criminal-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:50:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/03/green-cross-tax-refund-denial-clarified-excise-and-vat-on-colognes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:48:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/03/missed-filing-deadline-dismisses-bir-motion-for-reconsideration/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:46:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/03/how-taxpayers-can-rely-on-cta-jurisdiction-to-secure-tax-credits/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:43:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/03/invalid-loa-and-unproven-assessment-notices-can-defeat-bir-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:41:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/03/taxpayers-can-lose-their-day-in-tax-court-by-filing-an-incomplete-reinvestigation-protest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:39:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/04/bir-criminal-case-dismissed-due-to-prescription-against-taxpayer/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:36:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/04/bir-garnishment-challenges-must-be-filed-within-30-days-tax-court-en-banc-says/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:34:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/04/late-tax-court-filings-can-defeat-mandamus-relief-before-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:31:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/05/bir-garnishment-lifted-after-failure-to-prove-receipt-of-final-tax-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:29:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/05/tax-crime-cases-can-be-dismissed-when-the-government-files-the-information-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:19:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/06/tax-prosecution-fails-when-bir-cannot-prove-proper-service-of-final-assessment-notice/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:10:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/06/nonprofit-associations-can-beat-income-tax-assessments-but-still-face-vat-on-paid-events-and-sponsorships/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T11:07:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/07/due-process-violations-void-delsan-transport-tax-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:58:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/07/unauthorized-tax-audit-renders-assessment-void-key-lessons-for-businesses/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:55:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/07/how-businesses-can-secure-zero-rated-vat-refunds-on-renewable-energy-services/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:53:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/11/bir-collection-efforts-can-still-prescribe-even-after-a-tax-assessment-becomes-final/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:51:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/11/taxpayers-can-cut-bir-assessments-based-on-unverified-preprocessed-data/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:48:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/11/petron-denied-partial-excise-tax-refund-on-diesel-sales-to-exempt-entity/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:45:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/11/excise-tax-refunds-require-traceable-proof-of-payment-even-after-a-partial-taxpayer-victory/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:42:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/11/excise-tax-refunds-require-exact-proof-of-payment-and-traceable-records/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:39:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/11/tax-evasion-charges-can-prescribe-if-prosecutors-file-the-information-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:37:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/11/bir-garnishment-set-aside-after-defective-service-of-tax-assessment-notices/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:35:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/12/taxpayers-can-end-bir-vat-assessment-cases-through-court-approved-compromise-settlements/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:32:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/12/folares-pharmaceuticals-prevails-as-court-cancels-deficiency-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:29:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/13/customs-seizure-appeals-can-be-dismissed-when-importers-miss-pre-trial-requirements/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:27:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/13/nestle-milo-products-exempt-from-sweetened-beverage-tax-cta-upholds-refund-rights/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:24:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/13/deficiency-vat-assessment-canceled-after-bir-ignored-taxpayers-protest-arguments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:22:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/13/late-tax-credit-appeals-remain-jurisdictionally-fatal-despite-train-law-changes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:20:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/01/vat-exemption-upheld-for-roasted-bangus-amid-invalid-bir-notices/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:17:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/11/unsigned-tax-protests-can-still-defeat-bir-assessments-when-legal-and-factual-grounds-are-clear/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:15:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/01/tax-payment-voluntariness-upheld-key-takeaways-for-filipino-businesses/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:11:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/17/tax-acquittals-are-hard-to-undo-court-of-tax-appeals-rejects-certiorari-challenge-in-tax-evasion-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:09:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/17/tax-assessments-can-be-cancelled-when-bir-revenue-officers-lack-proper-authority/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:03:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/18/hewlett-packard-ph-secures-iaet-relief-for-fy-2019/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T10:01:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/18/condominium-vat-refunds-still-require-proof-of-actual-erroneous-payment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:58:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/18/unauthorized-bir-audit-voids-deficiency-income-tax-and-vat-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:56:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/19/bank-secures-partial-refund-of-capital-gains-tax-on-membership-sale/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:54:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/20/tax-refund-denial-upheld-for-rohq-service-export-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:51:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/20/casino-vat-refund-claims-require-the-right-legal-basis-not-just-proof-of-input-tax-payment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:49:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/20/rice-importers-need-valid-import-permits-before-arrival-or-risk-seizure-and-forfeiture/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:46:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/20/customs-import-case-dismissed-over-jurisdiction-technicality/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:43:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/21/excise-tax-refund-granted-for-distilled-spirits-after-premature-ra-11467-implementation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:41:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/24/rice-import-seizures-upheld-amid-wto-and-nfa-compliance-dispute/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:39:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/01/vat-refund-survives-reconsideration-despite-timing-and-documentation-objections/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:36:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/24/tax-refund-claims-can-fail-even-when-filed-on-time-if-bir-receipt-is-not-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:33:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/24/deficiency-tax-assessments-nullified-for-due-process-violations-in-2018-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:31:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/25/vat-refund-denied-commercial-invoices-are-not-enough-to-prove-zero-rated-export-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:28:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/25/mandaluyong-property-transfer-tax-refund-upheld-under-lgc-section-196/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:25:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/25/late-motions-can-end-tax-criminal-appeals-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:23:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/25/air-drilling-associates-denied-vat-refund-after-court-confirms-evidence-insufficient/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:20:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/25/tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-bir-notices-are-served-on-unauthorized-personnel/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:18:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/25/drug-importers-can-defend-vat-refunds-despite-bir-format-objections/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:15:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/25/vat-refunds-for-export-services-require-proof-that-the-work-was-performed-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:12:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/05/vat-refund-claims-require-exact-invoice-proof-and-proper-timing-for-zero-rated-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:09:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/05/taxpayers-cannot-appeal-every-bir-protest-reply-as-a-final-decision/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:06:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/25/bpo-vat-refunds-can-fail-when-zero-rated-receipts-do-not-describe-the-services-rendered/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:04:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/26/late-government-appeals-can-make-tax-refund-victories-final/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T09:01:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/26/airlines-seeking-excise-tax-refunds-must-prove-local-non-availability-with-reliable-market-evidence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:58:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/26/kuwait-airways-secures-income-tax-refund-on-gross-philippine-billings/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:56:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/26/local-business-tax-refunds-when-business-permit-statements-are-not-final-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:54:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/26/tax-case-dismissed-for-lack-of-due-process-in-smallville-it-enterprise-matter/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:51:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/26/tax-evasion-charges-can-be-dismissed-when-the-accused-was-never-properly-notified/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:48:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/27/oceanagold-wins-partial-vat-refund-for-2018-zero-rated-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:46:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/27/missed-cta-e-filing-deadlines-can-defeat-a-taxpayers-assessment-appeal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:44:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/05/excise-tax-refunds-on-jet-a-1-fuel-petroleum-importers-can-claim-when-sales-are-made-to-tax-exempt-international-carriers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:41:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/27/vat-cannot-be-added-back-to-gross-receipts-for-local-business-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:38:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/07/valenzuela-cannot-tax-signage-receipts-without-a-branch-or-sales-office-in-the-city/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:36:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/01/tax-assessments-issued-before-the-15-day-pan-period-can-be-voided-for-denial-of-due-process/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:33:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/31/vat-refund-claims-cannot-be-defeated-by-delinquency-verification-issues-alone/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:31:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/31/premature-final-assessment-can-void-a-bir-deficiency-tax-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:28:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/31/tax-assessment-nullified-due-to-lack-of-pan-and-fan-receipt/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:25:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/31/supreme-court-upholds-capital-gains-and-dst-assessments-for-non-listed-shares/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:23:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/31/court-clarifies-taxpayer-rights-amid-pending-administrative-appeals/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:21:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/31/dismissal-of-tax-credit-petition-over-forum-shopping-defects-highlights-compliance-risk/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:18:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/03/invalid-tax-protests-can-cost-taxpayers-their-day-in-tax-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:16:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/01/tax-collection-deadline-enforced-despite-covid-19-extensions-for-alphalnd-balesin-resort/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:13:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/07/late-appeals-from-bir-assessment-decisions-can-lose-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:11:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/02/vat-refund-claims-can-fail-when-foreign-client-status-is-not-proven-at-trial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:09:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/07/makati-local-business-tax-assessment-fails-without-proof-of-actual-business-operations/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:06:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/03/bir-cannot-revive-a-dismissed-criminal-tax-case-without-proper-osg-authority/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:04:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/03/vat-refunds-for-export-service-providers-can-fail-on-filing-venue-and-foreign-client-status/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T08:01:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/03/taxpayers-seeking-refunds-cannot-reopen-trial-after-judgment-without-compelling-grounds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:58:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/03/vat-refund-appeals-can-be-lost-even-before-the-evidence-is-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:55:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/03/invalid-bir-assessment-service-can-defeat-a-tax-collection-warrant/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:53:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/vat-refund-claimants-must-get-the-evidence-right-before-judgment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:50:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/04/vat-zero-rating-refunds-survive-reconsideration-when-evidence-and-invoicing-hold-up/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:46:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/04/court-dismisses-tax-credit-petition-for-improper-verification/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:44:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/04/billion-peso-tax-assessment-voided-after-unauthorized-bir-audit-and-due-process-lapses/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:42:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/01/ecozone-automobile-sales-can-qualify-for-vat-zero-rating-when-tied-to-registered-activities/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:39:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/07/condominium-associations-win-key-local-business-tax-refund-ruling-in-taguig/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:36:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/07/taxpayer-successfully-challenges-bir-vat-assessment-on-procedural-grounds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:34:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/07/bir-withdrawal-of-warrant-ends-vat-assessment-case-after-due-process-challenge/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:31:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/07/customs-forfeiture-appeals-can-end-once-the-commissioner-orders-release-of-the-seized-vessel/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:29:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/08/willful-failure-to-pay-tax-cases-require-proof-of-both-notice-and-tax-liability/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:27:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/08/late-tax-appeals-can-defeat-even-substantive-bir-assessment-challenges/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:24:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/08/late-certiorari-filings-can-sink-challenges-to-bir-garnishment-orders/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:22:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/08/tax-criminal-cases-can-be-lost-on-e-copy-compliance-not-only-on-the-merits/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:19:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/08/deficiency-vat-criminal-case-fails-when-the-final-assessment-notice-has-no-definite-due-date/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:16:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/08/a-missed-24-hour-electronic-filing-requirement-can-defeat-a-tax-criminal-information/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:14:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/08/excise-tax-refunds-fail-without-originals-what-fuel-importers-must-prove-in-tax-credit-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:11:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/08/missed-appeal-deadlines-can-make-tax-refund-and-tax-credit-victories-final/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:09:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/08/u-freight-phils-settles-tax-liability-via-judicial-compromise-agreement/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:07:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/01/vat-refund-claims-can-still-be-proven-in-the-court-of-tax-appeals-even-after-bir-denial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:04:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/10/tax-criminal-cases-can-end-permanently-when-the-prosecution-fails-to-prove-valid-assessment-service/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T07:02:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/11/sun-life-grepa-financial-prevails-in-tax-assessment-dispute/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:59:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/11/vat-refund-claims-fail-when-zero-rated-sales-are-not-proven-at-the-correct-site/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:57:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/14/due-process-key-in-tax-assessments-united-international-pictures-case-outcome/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:54:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/14/due-process-violations-nullify-bir-deficiency-assessment-for-ty-2010/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:51:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/14/importation-records-alone-cannot-sustain-deficiency-income-tax-and-vat-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:48:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/14/taxpayers-can-end-assessment-litigation-through-a-court-approved-compromise-settlement/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:46:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/14/petroleum-sellers-may-recover-excise-tax-on-lpg-sold-to-tax-exempt-buyers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:43:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/15/renewable-energy-developers-can-recover-input-vat-on-purchases-outside-plant-development/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:40:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/15/paranaque-city-lbt-refund-upheld-soa-not-a-valid-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:38:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/15/vat-refund-appeals-can-be-lost-when-bir-refusal-is-treated-as-an-immediate-denial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:35:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/15/court-denies-bir-reconsideration-in-gb-bem-cigarette-tax-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:33:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/15/first-telecom-tax-assessments-void-due-to-unauthorized-audit-officers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:30:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/15/late-reconsideration-motion-dismissed-in-tax-assessment-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:28:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/15/cwt-refund-claims-can-fail-without-detailed-revenue-tracing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:26:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/15/jet-fuel-excise-tax-refunds-court-grants-over-p1-billion-for-sales-to-international-carriers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:22:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/15/bir-assessment-voided-for-ignoring-taxpayers-reply-to-preliminary-assessment-notice/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:19:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/15/how-mining-companies-can-secure-vat-refunds-for-zero-rated-sales-in-2025/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:16:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/15/cwt-refunds-still-depend-on-matching-bir-form-2307-to-declared-income/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:13:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/15/vat-refunds-for-peza-sales-can-fail-without-properly-marked-receipts-and-evidence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:10:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/08/criminal-tax-cases-can-fail-when-the-government-files-too-late-or-contradicts-its-own-records/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:08:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/04/16/import-misdeclaration-case-dismissed-for-lack-of-probable-cause/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:05:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/partial-win-for-taxpayer-on-2017-deficiency-assessments-key-takeaways-for-corporations/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:03:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/oceanagold-excise-tax-refund-denial-upheld-key-takeaways-for-philippine-mining-companies/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T06:00:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/03/tax-prosecutors-must-prove-assessment-receipt-before-criminal-tax-charges-can-survive/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:58:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/03/golden-donuts-tax-assessment-partially-upheld-key-compliance-implications-for-2010/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:55:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/03/taxpayer-partially-wins-challenge-to-2015-income-tax-and-ewt-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:53:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/06/missed-pre-trial-and-late-reconsideration-can-end-a-tax-assessment-appeal-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:50:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/06/medicine-importers-can-recover-vat-paid-despite-later-bir-effectivity-dates/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:48:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/06/criminal-tax-case-dismissed-for-prescription-despite-doj-filing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:45:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/06/prescriptive-period-limits-criminal-tax-prosecution-for-importer-in-quezon-city/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:43:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/07/taxpayer-prevails-cta-denies-reconsideration-of-2010-deficiency-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:41:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/07/taxpayers-seeking-cwt-refunds-must-trace-withheld-taxes-to-actual-income-records/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:38:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/07/taxpayers-seeking-excise-tax-refunds-gain-finality-advantage-after-higher-court-ruling/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:36:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/07/vat-refund-denied-when-zero-rated-sales-and-official-receipts-do-not-match/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:34:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/08/halliburton-ph-branch-secures-php-1-76m-vat-refund-after-cta-review/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:31:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/08/taxpayers-risk-losing-assessment-appeals-when-protest-letters-do-not-meet-bir-rules/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:29:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/08/tax-case-dismissal-highlights-importance-of-valid-final-assessment-notices/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:26:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/08/late-tax-prosecution-fails-when-information-is-filed-after-five-years/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:24:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/08/criminal-tax-case-dismissed-due-to-expired-prescriptive-period/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:21:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/08/late-certiorari-filing-ends-government-challenge-in-criminal-tax-prosecution/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:19:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/08/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-taxpayer-defenses-are-ignored/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:17:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/criminal-tax-case-dismissed-due-to-prescription-for-deficiency-vat/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:14:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/09/us-based-seller-wins-refund-on-philippine-capital-gains-tax-under-rp-us-tax-treaty/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:12:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/09/bpo-export-service-providers-can-still-recover-zero-rated-vat-input-taxes-despite-partial-disallowances/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:10:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/09/court-upholds-customs-forfeiture-of-undeclared-foreign-currency-at-naia/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:06:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/10/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-new-revenue-officers-act-without-a-new-loa/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T05:01:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/15/tax-refund-rights-upheld-for-ppd-pharmaceutical-in-affiliate-services-dispute/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:58:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/15/qualfon-philippines-real-property-tax-assessment-finality-explained/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:56:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/15/bir-criminal-tax-case-dismissed-after-five-year-prescription-period-lapsed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:54:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/criminal-tax-liability-dismissed-due-to-prescription-in-2014-deficiency-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:50:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/15/zero-rated-service-providers-must-prove-where-services-were-performed-to-defeat-vat-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:48:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/15/tax-court-voids-p138-8-million-bir-assessment-for-ignoring-taxpayers-pan-reply/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:45:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/15/invalid-bir-service-can-defeat-criminal-tax-charges-and-civil-collection-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:42:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/15/illegal-cigarette-excise-tax-case-fails-after-invalid-vehicle-search/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:39:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/16/tax-refund-orders-become-final-when-the-government-misses-rule-38-deadlines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:36:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/16/tax-refund-claims-can-survive-branch-tin-issues-when-bir-form-2307-identifies-the-same-taxpayer/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:34:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/16/bir-tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-notices-are-improperly-served-and-taxpayer-replies-are-ignored/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:32:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/16/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-pan-is-served-on-an-unauthorized-person/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:29:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/17/vat-refunds-can-fail-when-operating-sites-are-not-properly-registered/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:26:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/17/vat-refund-claims-for-export-services-need-strong-foreign-client-proof-tax-court-says/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:24:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/17/luxury-vehicle-importers-risk-forfeiture-for-missing-sworn-statements-and-undervaluation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:20:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/17/renewable-energy-vat-refunds-may-still-succeed-without-doe-registration-when-the-tax-code-independently-zero-rates-the-sale/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:17:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/17/fuel-importers-lose-excise-tax-refunds-without-complete-inventory-tracing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:14:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/17/vat-refund-claimants-may-present-their-full-evidence-in-court-not-just-what-the-bir-reviewed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:11:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/17/vat-refunds-for-exporters-can-fail-when-foreign-currency-payments-cannot-be-traced-to-export-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:09:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/taxpayers-cannot-extend-the-30-day-deadline-to-appeal-a-bir-assessment-to-the-tax-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:06:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/17/late-reconsideration-can-end-a-criminal-tax-case-before-the-merits-are-reached/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:04:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/07/late-motions-can-end-tax-criminal-cases-before-trial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T04:01:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/17/late-reconsideration-cannot-revive-a-prescribed-criminal-tax-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:59:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/20/bir-assessments-cancelled-for-issuing-final-assessment-too-early-after-pan/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:57:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/20/bir-collection-defeated-when-taxpayer-proves-defective-service-of-final-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:54:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/20/tax-assessment-settlement-ends-court-dispute-after-withdrawal-of-petition-for-review/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:51:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/20/missed-soft-copy-filing-can-end-a-tax-assessment-appeal-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:49:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/20/bir-assessment-settlements-need-court-approval-valid-authority-and-proper-compromise-rates/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:46:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/20/tax-evasion-cases-can-be-lost-before-trial-when-the-information-is-filed-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:43:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/20/tax-evasion-cases-can-be-dismissed-when-prosecutors-miss-the-prescriptive-period/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:41:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/20/vat-refunds-require-clean-invoices-data-services-taxpayer-wins-only-what-it-proved/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:38:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/20/vat-refund-denied-rohq-must-prove-valid-foreign-currency-offsetting-for-zero-rated-service-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:35:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/20/invalid-bir-audit-authority-can-defeat-criminal-tax-charges-for-willful-failure-to-pay/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:32:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/21/vat-refund-appeals-can-fail-when-the-denial-comes-from-the-wrong-bir-official/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:29:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/21/unauthorized-revenue-officers-can-void-a-bir-tax-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:26:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/21/criminal-tax-cases-can-fail-when-the-bir-files-too-late-or-builds-on-a-defective-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:24:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/24/taxpayers-can-end-bir-assessment-cases-through-court-approved-compromise-agreements/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:21:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/22/vat-refunds-for-rohq-services-can-survive-rehashed-bir-objections/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:19:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/22/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-revenue-officers-lack-proper-authority-or-the-notice-has-no-due-date/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:16:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/22/wrong-appeal-mode-can-end-a-tax-code-prosecution-before-review/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:13:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/23/taxpayers-can-end-vat-assessment-litigation-through-a-court-approved-compromise/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:10:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/23/bir-tax-compromise-below-40-approved-after-taxpayer-shows-doubtful-validity-of-vat-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:08:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/23/taxpayers-can-still-win-cwt-refunds-even-when-the-bir-claims-the-court-case-was-filed-too-soon/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:05:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/24/airlines-seeking-excise-tax-refunds-must-prove-local-unavailability-with-more-than-price-lists/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:03:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/24/tax-assessments-survive-reconsideration-when-service-and-due-process-objections-are-rehashed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T03:00:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/24/missed-appeal-deadlines-can-defeat-challenges-to-bir-garnishment-and-distraint/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:57:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/24/vat-refund-appeals-can-be-lost-even-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:55:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/24/local-tax-appeals-fail-when-cities-merely-rehash-arguments-on-reconsideration/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:52:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/27/vat-refund-claims-can-survive-reconsideration-when-evidence-and-zero-rated-sales-are-properly-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:50:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/27/professional-partnerships-can-recover-erroneous-local-business-taxes-when-the-proper-refund-remedy-is-timely-filed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:47:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/28/late-appeals-from-final-tax-assessments-can-doom-collection-challenges/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:44:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/28/technical-smuggling-charges-cannot-be-split-into-multiple-customs-cases-for-the-same-importation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:42:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/28/taxpayers-with-net-losses-can-defeat-deficiency-income-tax-assessments-built-on-a-zero-taxable-base/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:39:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/28/excise-tax-refunds-for-jet-fuel-sales-to-international-carriers-still-require-strict-proof-of-foreign-consumption/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:36:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/28/proof-of-receipt-can-save-a-local-tax-appeal-from-dismissal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:34:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/30/unsigned-motions-can-cost-the-bir-a-vat-refund-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:31:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/03/vat-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-bir-ignores-a-taxpayers-protest-arguments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:28:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/03/taxpayers-who-escalate-an-assessment-protest-to-the-commissioner-cannot-use-a-new-180-day-waiting-period-to-go-to-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:25:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/03/cwt-refund-claims-need-more-than-bir-form-2307-taxpayers-must-reconcile-income-books-and-prior-year-credits/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:23:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/03/tax-assessment-appeals-can-be-dismissed-without-a-clear-receipt-date/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:20:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/03/late-formal-offer-of-evidence-can-defeat-a-tax-assessment-appeal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:17:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/03/cwt-tax-credit-claims-survive-reconsideration-when-the-taxpayer-proves-withholding-income-declaration-and-timely-filing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:15:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/03/environmental-charges-labeled-as-taxes-may-fall-outside-tax-court-jurisdiction/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:12:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/03/vat-refunds-for-foreign-affiliate-services-can-fail-without-proof-of-zero-rated-sales-and-payment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:10:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/05/petitions-for-relief-in-tax-cases-must-be-filed-in-the-same-case-not-as-a-new-action/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:06:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/04/vat-refund-claims-need-complete-annual-export-proof-and-strict-invoicing-compliance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:03:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/04/vat-refund-claims-for-peza-sales-taxpayers-can-rely-on-bir-held-peza-certificates/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T02:01:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/05/tax-evasion-case-dismissed-after-government-filed-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:55:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/06/bir-assessments-may-be-voided-when-taxpayers-are-denied-the-full-15-days-to-answer-a-pan/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:53:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/06/bir-tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-substitute-revenue-officers-lack-a-valid-loa/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:50:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/06/invalidly-served-loa-can-void-a-bir-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:47:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/06/vat-refunds-for-export-services-can-fail-without-proof-linking-foreign-remittances-to-actual-services/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:44:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/01/homeowners-association-dues-are-not-subject-to-vat-tax-court-says/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:42:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/06/late-supporting-documents-can-make-a-vat-assessment-final-and-unappealable/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:39:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/07/late-government-motions-can-end-criminal-tax-cases-before-trial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:37:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/10/late-reconsideration-fails-in-tax-criminal-case-after-assessment-related-charges-were-dismissed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:33:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/10/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-taxpayer-replies-to-a-pan-are-ignored/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:30:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/11/bir-collection-letters-can-trigger-tax-appeals-but-taxpayers-must-object-to-service-defects-early/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:28:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/11/tax-refund-appeals-can-be-lost-on-deadlines-when-government-counsel-receives-the-ruling/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:24:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/11/airline-excise-tax-refunds-need-more-than-franchise-exemption-import-cost-proof-matters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:22:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/12/boi-registration-can-shield-pioneer-enterprises-from-local-business-tax-but-phividec-exemptions-alone-may-not/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:19:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-revenue-officers-are-not-properly-named-in-the-loa/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:16:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/12/payment-under-protest-is-not-enough-for-local-business-tax-refunds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:13:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/12/mutual-benefit-associations-can-challenge-local-business-tax-on-member-contributions-and-insurance-type-receipts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:10:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/12/unauthorized-bir-examiners-can-void-a-deficiency-tax-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:07:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/13/tax-collection-orders-can-be-reversed-when-the-bir-acts-too-late-or-relies-only-on-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:04:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/14/taxpayers-can-end-assessment-appeals-through-a-properly-approved-bir-compromise/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T01:01:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/14/vat-refund-claimants-can-prove-philippine-services-without-a-location-clause/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:58:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/14/tax-refund-wins-can-become-final-when-the-government-misses-its-appeal-deadline/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:56:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/14/cement-businesses-can-claim-preferential-local-business-tax-rates-on-gross-receipts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:53:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/14/late-tax-prosecutions-can-be-dismissed-when-the-information-is-filed-after-prescription/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:51:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/20/customs-smuggling-case-dismissed-after-prosecutors-failed-to-submit-probable-cause-documents/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:48:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/14/bir-capital-gains-tax-assessments-can-be-cancelled-when-issued-after-prescription/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:45:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/17/importers-can-defeat-customs-forfeiture-when-fraud-is-not-clearly-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:42:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/17/davao-environmental-charges-may-fall-outside-cta-review-when-they-are-regulatory-fees/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:40:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/17/late-government-appeals-can-end-tax-crime-cases-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:37:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/18/excise-tax-refunds-on-airline-commissary-imports-survive-reconsideration-challenge/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:34:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/18/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-fld-ignores-the-taxpayers-pan-reply/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:31:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/14/tax-assessments-can-still-fall-when-bir-audit-authority-is-defective/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:29:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/01/taxpayers-can-preserve-assessment-victories-when-reconsideration-merely-rehashes-old-arguments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:26:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/11/late-bir-motion-fails-in-documentary-stamp-tax-refund-dispute/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:22:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/11/environmental-fees-are-not-always-local-taxes-tax-court-dismisses-appeal-over-davao-watershed-charge/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:20:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/19/bir-tax-assessments-without-payment-due-dates-can-be-voided/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:16:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/12/taxpayers-cannot-revive-a-missed-cta-appeal-by-waiting-for-later-bir-collection-letters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:14:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/13/taxpayers-who-appeal-an-fdda-to-the-commissioner-cannot-treat-an-unauthorized-regional-directors-denial-as-a-final-cta-appealable-decision/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:11:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/13/government-tax-prosecutions-face-a-jurisdiction-trap-after-demurrer-based-acquittals/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:07:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/13/tax-evasion-cases-can-be-dismissed-when-the-information-fails-to-show-the-ctas-jurisdiction/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:05:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/13/unauthorized-revenue-officers-can-void-billion-peso-bir-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-29T00:02:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/13/tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-bir-ignores-a-taxpayers-protest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:59:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/13/bir-collection-efforts-fail-when-the-three-year-deadline-has-already-expired/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:56:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/13/lgus-cannot-refuse-local-business-tax-payments-just-because-real-property-tax-is-unpaid/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:53:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/13/bir-collection-warrants-fail-without-proof-of-valid-assessment-receipt/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:50:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/13/unauthorized-bir-audits-can-defeat-tax-collection-and-criminal-tax-charges/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:48:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/16/taxpayers-can-use-new-evidence-in-court-to-prove-cwt-refund-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:45:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/01/missed-electronic-filing-can-end-customs-criminal-cases-before-they-begin/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:42:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/01/bir-cannot-collect-by-warrant-while-an-fdda-appeal-is-still-pending/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:40:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/excise-tax-refunds-survive-rehashed-motions-for-reconsideration-in-court-of-tax-appeals/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:37:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/03/31/vat-refunds-for-renewable-energy-contractors-require-project-level-boi-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:34:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/17/bir-tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-pan-service-and-loa-authority-are-not-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:28:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/17/taxpayers-cannot-restart-the-180-day-appeal-period-by-elevating-an-fdda-to-the-commissioner/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:26:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/17/splash-cologne-sellers-can-face-excise-tax-when-products-qualify-as-toilet-waters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:23:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/17/invalidly-served-bir-assessments-cannot-support-tax-code-criminal-charges/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:19:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/17/local-business-tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-billing-statements-fail-due-process/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:17:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/17/verified-invoice-alterations-can-still-support-vat-refund-claims-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:14:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/17/unauthorized-revenue-officers-can-void-a-bir-assessment-despite-a-taxpayers-earlier-silence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:11:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/18/vat-refund-claims-survive-without-direct-attribution-but-fail-on-defective-receipts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:09:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/18/rehashed-tax-assessment-arguments-will-not-save-a-deficiency-tax-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:05:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/11/bir-collection-stopped-after-taxpayer-denied-receipt-of-assessment-notices/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:03:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/18/unauthorized-revenue-officer-voids-bir-assessment-and-collection-for-income-tax-and-ewt/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T23:00:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/01/past-dated-payment-deadlines-can-void-bir-deficiency-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:57:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/taxpayers-can-face-civil-tax-liability-even-without-a-formal-bir-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:54:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/vat-refund-claims-for-exporters-fail-without-proof-of-actual-shipment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:51:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/19/criminal-tax-evasion-cases-can-still-be-dismissed-when-prosecutors-miss-prescription-and-appeal-rules/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:47:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/19/missed-cta-appeal-deadlines-can-end-a-tax-refund-case-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:45:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/19/bir-assessments-survive-when-taxpayers-fail-to-prove-deductions-input-vat-and-withholding-compliance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:41:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/19/power-generators-can-recover-zero-rated-vat-refunds-only-for-fully-substantiated-sales-and-input-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:37:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/bir-assessments-can-still-be-voided-when-pan-service-is-not-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:34:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/bir-assessments-without-due-dates-can-be-voided-for-denial-of-due-process/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:32:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/01/vat-refund-claims-for-imported-exempt-medicines-need-proof-the-input-vat-was-not-used/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:29:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/19/bir-assessments-can-be-cut-down-when-taxpayer-replies-are-ignored-but-unsupported-expenses-still-create-tax-liability/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:26:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/19/bir-assessments-voided-for-defective-service-and-missing-payment-due-dates/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:22:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/19/unsupported-bir-tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-employee-incentives-are-misclassified/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:19:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/19/missed-bir-assessment-appeal-deadline-makes-tax-deficiency-final-and-demandable/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:15:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/02/defective-tax-assessment-notices-can-still-be-voided-when-the-due-date-and-tax-liability-are-unclear/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:12:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/23/deficiency-tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-bir-auditors-lack-proper-authority/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:09:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/23/excess-cwt-tax-credit-claims-can-prosper-when-income-and-withholding-are-properly-traced/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:06:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/19/vat-refund-claimants-may-still-prove-their-case-in-court-even-after-a-bir-administrative-denial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:03:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/customs-refund-appeals-can-fail-when-importers-skip-the-reconsideration-step/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T22:01:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/23/defective-bir-waivers-can-void-tax-assessments-when-the-revenue-office-caused-the-defects/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:58:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/23/vat-refunds-for-zero-rated-sales-require-more-than-customer-status-and-accounting-schedules/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:55:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/24/vat-refund-denied-exporters-must-match-invoices-shipping-proof-and-inward-remittances/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:51:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/24/vat-refund-claims-fail-when-zero-rated-input-vat-is-fully-absorbed-by-output-vat/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:48:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/24/vat-refund-claims-fail-when-zero-rated-receipts-and-returns-are-incomplete/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:46:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/22/vat-refund-appeals-may-run-from-actual-receipt-when-the-bir-issues-a-written-denial-on-time/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:43:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/26/missed-tax-appeal-deadlines-can-make-bir-assessments-final-and-collectible/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:40:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/27/tax-criminal-case-dismissed-after-prosecution-missed-electronic-filing-order/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:38:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/27/corporate-officers-can-defeat-tax-collection-when-bir-assessment-notices-are-not-properly-served/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:35:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/30/tax-refund-appeals-can-be-lost-by-sending-electronic-filings-to-the-wrong-court-email/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:31:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/31/condominium-corporations-can-recover-local-business-tax-when-dues-are-not-profit-oriented-business-receipts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:28:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/31/excise-tax-refunds-for-jet-fuel-sales-to-international-airlines-taxpayers-can-prove-foreign-use-without-a-carrier-permit/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:26:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/31/missing-payment-due-date-can-void-a-bir-deficiency-tax-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:23:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/31/local-taxpayers-must-use-the-correct-appeal-and-assessment-review-route-in-real-property-tax-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:21:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/31/late-tax-assessment-protests-can-make-bir-deficiency-taxes-final-and-collectible/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:18:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/10/bir-appeals-can-fail-without-osg-authority-in-tax-assessment-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:15:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/06/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-revenue-officers-lack-proper-authority-and-fans-are-premature/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:13:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/06/condominium-associations-can-challenge-local-business-taxes-on-association-dues/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:09:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/06/canceled-real-property-sales-may-still-trigger-dst-but-cwt-can-be-refunded-when-no-sale-remains/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:05:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-fld-ignores-a-taxpayers-pan-protest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:03:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/bir-assessments-voided-when-pan-and-fld-service-rules-are-not-strictly-followed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T21:00:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/01/premature-tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-bir-issues-the-final-demand-too-soon/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:57:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/bir-collection-can-be-voided-when-a-warrant-of-distraint-or-levy-is-issued-before-a-tax-protest-is-resolved/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:55:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/01/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-taxpayers-pan-protest-is-ignored/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:52:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/07/renewable-energy-vat-refunds-hydropower-sales-qualified-ancillary-services-did-not/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:49:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/01/boi-income-tax-holiday-does-not-automatically-exempt-businesses-from-local-business-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:45:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/08/taxpayers-can-recover-compromise-payments-after-final-cancellation-of-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:43:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/08/late-appeals-can-end-criminal-tax-cases-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:40:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/08/excise-tax-refunds-for-jet-a-1-fuel-seller-may-recover-taxes-on-fuel-sold-to-international-carriers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:38:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/08/customs-brokers-are-not-automatically-criminally-liable-for-misdeclared-imports/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:34:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/01/premature-final-assessment-notices-can-void-a-bir-tax-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:29:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/01/local-tax-refund-claims-billing-statements-are-not-always-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:27:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/10/taxpayers-can-still-fight-deficiency-vat-assessments-but-input-vat-carry-over-cannot-be-used-twice/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:24:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/10/tax-evasion-charges-can-collapse-when-bir-cannot-prove-receipt-of-assessment-notices/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:20:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/10/local-franchise-tax-cannot-follow-electricity-delivery-without-proper-tax-situs/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:17:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/13/invalid-loa-coverage-voids-billion-peso-vat-assessment-despite-bir-demand-letters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:14:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/13/vat-refund-appeals-can-be-lost-on-filing-proof-not-just-tax-merits/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:12:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/mining-tax-refund-claims-need-denr-approved-pre-operating-expense-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:08:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/11/tax-refund-claims-can-fail-when-zero-rated-sales-are-not-fully-proven-before-trial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:05:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/14/taxpayers-can-defend-cwt-refund-wins-when-reconsideration-merely-rehashes-old-arguments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T20:01:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/01/excess-cwt-refunds-survive-bir-appeal-when-2307s-and-income-reporting-are-properly-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:57:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/14/excise-tax-refund-upheld-after-bir-applied-beer-tax-increase-too-early/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:53:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/14/government-instrumentalities-can-defeat-local-real-property-tax-assessments-when-their-properties-serve-a-public-function/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:50:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/01/missed-tax-appeal-deadlines-cannot-be-revived-by-petition-for-relief/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:47:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/15/bir-cannot-reopen-a-settled-audit-through-a-new-loa-for-the-same-taxable-period/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:44:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/15/input-vat-claims-fail-without-complete-invoices-and-court-evidence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:41:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/15/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-for-premature-fans-but-refunds-still-require-a-proper-claim/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:37:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/vat-refunds-can-fail-even-when-export-services-are-zero-rated/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:34:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/bir-cannot-revive-a-prescribed-capital-gains-tax-assessment-through-internal-case-handling-lapses/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:32:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/missed-18030-day-assessment-appeal-deadline-leaves-taxpayer-waiting-for-cir-decision/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:29:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/17/tax-refund-claim-denied-after-taxpayer-tried-to-reopen-evidence-on-alleged-double-fwt-payment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:27:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/17/invalid-bir-audit-authority-can-cancel-deficiency-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:24:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/17/tax-appeals-can-be-lost-on-filing-deadlines-even-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:21:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/17/late-motions-can-end-tax-collection-challenges-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:19:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/20/missed-electronic-filing-rules-can-end-a-tax-certiorari-case-before-it-begins/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:16:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/20/vat-refunds-for-zero-rated-sales-court-allows-partial-recovery-despite-bir-denial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:13:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/20/premature-bir-collection-warrants-can-be-stopped-before-a-tax-assessment-becomes-final/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:09:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/20/government-agencies-must-bring-bir-tax-assessment-disputes-to-the-doj-not-the-tax-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:07:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/20/late-tax-appeals-can-leave-bank-garnishments-standing-despite-jurisdiction-over-collection-measures/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:04:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/21/condominium-corporations-can-recover-local-business-tax-paid-for-permit-renewal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T19:01:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/21/excise-tax-refunds-for-peza-sales-tax-court-orders-bir-to-return-imported-fuel-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:58:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/21/petroleum-importers-can-recover-excise-tax-on-fuel-oil-sold-to-peza-enterprises-but-documentation-controls-the-refund/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:55:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/21/peza-fuel-oil-sales-can-support-excise-tax-refunds-when-importers-prove-the-paper-trail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:51:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/21/tax-collection-warrants-can-be-cancelled-when-the-bir-collects-beyond-the-prescriptive-period/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:48:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/21/vat-refund-appeals-can-be-dismissed-if-the-taxpayer-cannot-prove-timely-receipt-of-bir-denial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:45:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/21/bir-assessment-voided-after-taxpayers-pan-reply-was-ignored/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:42:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/21/bir-cannot-revive-prescribed-tax-assessments-without-clear-proof-of-fraud/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:38:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/10/bir-collection-warrants-can-be-voided-when-issued-after-the-prescriptive-period/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:36:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/22/vat-refund-claimants-must-prove-zero-rated-sales-with-correct-receipts-valid-atps-and-actual-vat-remittance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:33:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/02/tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-bir-relies-on-a-defective-waiver-and-ignores-the-taxpayers-protest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:30:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/22/vat-refund-claims-can-fail-on-timing-even-before-substantiation-is-reached/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:27:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/01/tax-refund-claim-fails-after-taxpayer-cannot-prove-excess-and-unutilized-creditable-withholding-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:24:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/01/taxpayers-can-lose-their-tax-appeal-before-the-merits-if-verification-defects-are-not-corrected/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:22:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/23/premature-bir-final-assessment-cancelled-for-violating-taxpayer-due-process/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:19:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/23/vat-refund-partly-granted-for-bunker-fuel-sales-to-international-vessels/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:16:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/23/deficiency-income-tax-assessments-can-be-cancelled-when-the-bir-changes-the-theory-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:10:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/23/electric-cooperatives-must-prove-nea-registration-during-trial-to-sustain-income-tax-exemption/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:07:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/02/tax-crime-appeals-can-fail-without-osg-authority-and-timely-filing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:04:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/24/vat-refund-claims-can-fail-without-clear-proof-of-bir-filing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T18:01:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/10/banana-exporter-loses-vat-refund-for-unmatched-foreign-currency-remittances/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:58:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/10/10/taxpayers-can-recover-excess-creditable-withholding-tax-without-proving-actual-bir-remittance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:54:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/28/tax-criminal-appeals-can-fail-without-osg-authority-and-timely-court-filing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:51:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/28/taxpayers-challenging-bir-collection-measures-must-get-rule-65-procedure-right/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:48:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/28/taxpayers-may-challenge-void-bir-assessments-even-after-property-levy-and-forfeiture/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:45:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/29/vat-refund-claims-fail-when-peza-zero-rating-and-input-vat-documents-are-incomplete/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:42:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/29/taxpayers-get-more-room-to-challenge-collection-when-bir-skips-a-clear-final-decision/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:40:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/20/when-local-environmental-charges-are-fees-not-taxes-why-the-correct-appeal-route-matters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:35:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/30/taxpayers-facing-bir-summons-charges-can-challenge-defective-subpoenas/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:32:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/30/unlawful-search-can-defeat-criminal-excise-tax-charges-over-alleged-counterfeit-cigarettes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:29:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/30/municipalities-outside-metro-manila-cannot-levy-real-property-tax-tax-court-says/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:25:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/30/taxpayers-cannot-immediately-appeal-procedural-setbacks-in-pending-court-of-tax-appeals-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:23:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/30/meat-importers-lose-reconsideration-bid-against-customs-deficiency-demands/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:20:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/30/bir-tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-reassigned-auditors-lack-a-new-letter-of-authority/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:17:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/30/bir-tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-revenue-officers-lack-a-proper-letter-of-authority/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:15:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/30/digital-bank-savings-accounts-without-fixed-maturity-may-be-exempt-from-documentary-stamp-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:12:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/04/30/defective-fdda-can-be-cancelled-without-voiding-the-bir-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:09:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/04/vat-refunds-for-zero-rated-sales-can-fail-without-proof-the-service-contract-covered-the-taxable-quarter/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:06:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/04/bir-cannot-collect-a-vat-assessment-it-cannot-prove-the-taxpayer-received/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:04:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/01/paid-tax-assessments-do-not-automatically-lift-bir-garnishments-when-the-tax-appeal-was-not-perfected/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T17:01:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/04/vat-refund-denied-when-export-sales-are-not-independently-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:58:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/04/local-tax-refunds-for-franchise-holders-when-an-in-lieu-of-all-taxes-clause-protects-against-city-business-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:56:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/04/pending-tax-protest-can-stop-a-bir-warrant-of-distraint-and-levy-but-not-reopen-the-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:53:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/04/casino-operators-can-recover-erroneously-withheld-taxes-on-pagcor-exempt-gaming-revenues/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:50:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/01/late-customs-refund-appeals-can-still-fail-even-when-the-commissioner-does-not-act/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:48:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/05/dst-refund-sustained-when-property-assignment-documents-are-exempt-under-the-tax-code/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:44:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/05/tax-clearance-disputes-may-become-moot-once-the-bir-grants-clearance-and-penalty-abatement/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:41:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/05/missed-cta-compliance-orders-can-end-a-tax-assessment-appeal-before-merits-review/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:38:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/06/head-offices-cannot-be-used-to-tax-branch-sales-without-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:35:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/06/head-office-cities-cannot-automatically-tax-branch-sales-court-says-in-local-business-tax-refund-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:31:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/07/bir-appeals-can-fail-when-filed-without-osg-authority-and-assessments-ignore-taxpayer-defenses/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:25:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/void-bir-assessments-cannot-become-final-despite-protest-defects/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:22:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/07/email-service-does-not-always-start-the-tax-appeal-clock/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:19:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/07/tax-refund-claims-can-survive-prescription-challenges-when-the-bir-merely-rehashes-old-arguments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:16:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/01/taxpayers-cannot-recover-a-cta-cash-bond-while-the-governments-appeal-is-still-pending/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:13:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/08/invalid-bir-audit-authority-can-void-deficiency-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:11:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/08/condominium-dues-are-not-automatically-taxable-profit-tax-court-reaffirms/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:07:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/08/late-customs-refund-appeals-can-cost-importers-their-day-in-tax-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:05:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/08/tax-refund-appeals-can-be-lost-when-petitions-are-sent-by-courier-instead-of-properly-filed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:02:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/08/missed-fdda-appeal-deadlines-can-make-bir-assessments-final-despite-a-timely-warrant-challenge/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T16:00:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/vat-refund-claimants-can-still-prove-their-case-in-court-after-bir-denial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:57:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/12/missed-pre-trial-in-a-tax-assessment-appeal-can-still-sink-a-case-even-before-the-merits/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:54:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/12/holding-companies-can-seek-refunds-for-local-business-tax-paid-on-dividend-income/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:51:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/12/local-business-tax-refunds-survive-when-permit-billing-forms-are-not-valid-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:48:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/12/vat-refunds-for-exempt-prescription-drug-imports-survive-early-court-filing-challenge/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:45:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/01/manila-real-property-tax-refund-appeal-dismissed-over-missing-forum-shopping-certification/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:42:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/14/stale-bir-collection-case-cancelled-taxpayer-defeats-p306-million-assessment-on-prescription/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:40:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/15/tax-appeals-can-be-lost-on-filing-compliance-not-just-assessment-merits/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:36:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/15/cooperatives-must-appeal-bir-tax-exemption-revocations-to-the-secretary-of-finance-before-going-to-tax-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:33:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/18/criminal-tax-cases-for-nonpayment-can-be-dismissed-when-the-government-files-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:30:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/18/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-taxpayer-protests-are-not-meaningfully-addressed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:28:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/18/late-motions-for-reconsideration-can-end-bir-assessment-appeals-before-the-merits-are-reopened/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:25:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/18/importers-must-act-fast-when-customs-fails-to-resolve-a-protest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:22:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/20/withdrawing-a-tax-assessment-appeal-can-make-the-bir-assessment-final/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:20:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/20/missed-fdda-protest-deadlines-can-end-a-tax-assessment-case-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:17:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/22/tax-acquittal-stands-when-the-prosecution-fails-to-prove-both-the-crime-and-the-tax-due/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:14:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/27/manila-local-business-tax-refund-increased-after-presumptive-assessment-was-rejected/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:11:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/22/paying-a-disputed-bir-surcharge-can-end-the-fight-over-abatement/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:09:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/05/26/rohq-vat-refunds-can-fail-without-complete-nrfc-proof-and-clean-invoices/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:06:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/05/vat-refunds-for-export-services-need-more-than-dollar-remittance-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:04:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/05/late-vat-refund-appeals-can-defeat-otherwise-substantive-tax-credit-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T15:01:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/05/capital-gains-tax-refunds-need-clear-payment-proof-to-survive-bir-challenge/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:58:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/05/tax-refund-for-bahay-bonds-interest-upheld-as-asset-backed-securities-were-not-deposit-substitutes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:55:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/05/late-served-bir-assessment-notices-can-void-vat-and-ewt-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:52:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/05/vat-refund-claim-upheld-after-commissioner-repeats-previously-rejected-objections/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:49:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/06/casino-tax-refunds-gaming-cwt-can-be-recovered-but-non-gaming-credits-need-full-tracing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:46:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/01/tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-bir-fails-to-explain-its-decision-in-writing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:43:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/06/taxpayers-can-lose-warrant-challenges-by-filing-petitions-through-licensed-courier/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:41:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/01/vat-refunds-for-exported-services-require-proof-of-inward-remittance-through-philippine-banks/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:38:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/06/taguig-cannot-collect-local-business-tax-on-head-office-with-no-local-sales-tax-court-says/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:35:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/06/head-offices-with-no-local-sales-can-fight-city-business-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:33:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/07/mining-excise-tax-exemptions-fail-without-clear-proof-of-the-ftaa-recovery-period/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:30:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/07/cwt-refund-denied-when-taxpayer-cannot-trace-withheld-income-to-itr-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:26:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/01/missing-bir-assessment-annexes-can-void-vat-deficiency-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:23:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/07/petroleum-importers-can-challenge-excise-tax-on-industrial-aromatic-hydrocarbons/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:20:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/07/franchise-tax-payment-can-defeat-local-contractors-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:16:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/08/late-appeals-can-end-tax-criminal-cases-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:13:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/08/condominium-associations-can-challenge-local-business-tax-on-association-dues/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:10:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/08/cwt-refunds-can-fail-without-detailed-tracing-to-gross-income-in-the-annual-itr/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:08:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/08/bir-assessments-are-void-when-replacement-revenue-officers-audit-without-a-new-loa/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:05:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/08/invalid-bir-assessments-when-failure-to-serve-a-pan-and-late-collection-defeat-a-tax-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:03:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/08/makati-business-tax-refunds-remain-available-when-the-city-reopens-the-same-tax-year/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T14:00:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/08/invalid-tax-assessments-cannot-support-bir-collection-and-seizure-notices/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:57:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/08/taxpayers-may-rely-on-specific-bir-rulings-unless-clearly-revoked/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:54:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/08/taguig-business-tax-refund-upheld-billing-statements-are-not-valid-local-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:52:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/08/improper-loa-service-can-void-a-bir-assessment-despite-taxpayer-cooperation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:49:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/08/bir-garnishment-fails-when-collection-is-filed-years-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:47:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/08/zero-rated-vat-refunds-survive-if-receipts-clearly-show-vat-zero-rated-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:44:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/09/jet-fuel-excise-tax-refunds-require-clear-proof-of-importation-bonded-storage-and-foreign-use/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:41:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/09/bank-garnishment-notice-alone-cannot-save-a-late-or-defective-tax-appeal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:39:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/09/missed-tax-protest-deadlines-can-end-a-taxpayers-cta-appeal-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:37:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/12/defective-tax-information-can-derail-criminal-tax-cases-before-trial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:34:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/12/taxpayers-who-pay-a-disputed-bir-assessment-may-still-control-the-timing-of-case-dismissal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:31:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/12/tax-prosecutors-lose-criminal-withholding-tax-case-over-electronic-filing-defect/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:29:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/12/e-filing-defects-can-stop-tax-criminal-cases-before-arraignment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:26:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/12/pasay-property-owners-win-refund-after-transfer-tax-was-computed-on-full-property-value/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:23:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/01/premature-vat-refund-appeals-can-defeat-even-large-tax-credit-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:19:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/14/five-day-delay-defeats-government-appeal-in-tax-code-criminal-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:17:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/14/vat-refund-claims-cannot-be-denied-solely-for-lack-of-prior-zero-rating-approval/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:14:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/14/bir-collection-warrant-voided-after-defective-service-of-tax-assessment-notices/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:11:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/14/aromatic-hydrocarbon-used-for-tire-manufacturing-may-escape-excise-tax-when-use-is-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:09:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/15/corporate-rehabilitation-does-not-automatically-wipe-out-local-tax-liabilities-after-plan-approval/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:06:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/15/good-faith-tax-protest-defeats-criminal-tax-evasion-charge-but-deficiency-tax-still-must-be-paid/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:03:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/16/tax-criminal-cases-can-be-dismissed-for-prosecutorial-delay-even-when-the-case-has-not-prescribed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T13:01:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/01/tax-credit-claims-survive-bir-challenges-when-cwt-certificates-support-the-refund/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:58:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/16/vat-refunds-for-export-sales-survive-bir-appeal-when-the-taxpayer-proves-administrative-compliance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:55:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/16/bir-assessment-voided-after-improper-service-of-formal-assessment-notice/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:52:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/taxpayers-challenging-bir-assessments-must-prove-loa-and-notice-defects-tax-court-says/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:50:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/16/foreign-vessel-forfeiture-upheld-after-bareboat-charter-conditions-were-breached/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:47:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/16/yearbook-printing-can-be-vat-exempt-tax-court-cancels-deficiency-vat-and-income-tax-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:45:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/19/excise-tax-refunds-for-fuel-sold-to-international-carriers-and-tax-exempt-buyers-survive-reconsideration/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:42:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/19/fuel-sellers-can-recover-excise-tax-on-petroleum-sold-to-tax-exempt-service-contractors/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:39:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/19/taxpayer-cuts-bir-assessment-from-php24-6-million-to-php3-12-million-after-challenging-deficiency-tax-findings/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:36:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/19/donors-tax-refund-denied-specific-allocation-of-estate-properties-can-defeat-a-claimed-general-renunciation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:33:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/20/vat-refund-denied-despite-zero-rated-sales-exporters-must-prove-unutilized-input-vat-was-not-applied-against-output-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:30:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/20/excise-tax-refunds-gain-stronger-ground-when-bir-issuances-exceed-the-tax-code/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:27:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/02/alkylate-excise-tax-refund-upheld-after-late-government-appeal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:24:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/20/fuel-excise-tax-refunds-need-foreign-air-carrier-permits-for-jet-fuel-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:21:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/20/cwt-refund-denied-taxpayers-must-trace-withheld-income-to-reported-gross-revenue/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:19:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/20/criminal-tax-cases-with-no-claimed-tax-amount-may-proceed-in-the-rtc/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:16:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/20/bir-cannot-collect-a-new-income-tax-assessment-first-raised-in-the-final-demand/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:14:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/20/customs-protest-inaction-cannot-automatically-bring-a-bond-assessment-dispute-to-the-tax-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:11:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/20/invalid-service-of-tax-assessments-can-defeat-bir-garnishment-and-collection/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:08:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/02/taxpayers-can-cut-bir-assessments-when-third-party-data-and-imputed-sales-are-not-properly-verified/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:06:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/21/tax-appeals-can-be-lost-before-the-merits-if-filing-rules-are-not-strictly-followed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:02:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/21/local-business-tax-assessments-must-state-clear-factual-and-legal-bases-tax-court-reaffirms/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T12:00:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/21/tax-assessments-can-fail-when-demand-letters-merely-request-payment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:57:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/01/export-vat-refunds-can-fail-without-proof-of-actual-foreign-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:55:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/01/vat-refund-claims-for-zero-rated-sales-still-rise-or-fall-on-complete-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:52:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/22/tax-appeals-can-be-lost-by-filing-through-the-wrong-mode-even-when-the-assessment-issues-may-be-substantial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:48:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/22/late-tax-appeals-can-forfeit-government-challenges-to-refund-and-tax-credit-decisions/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:46:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/22/tax-treaty-relief-can-survive-without-prior-ttra-but-appeals-can-fail-on-procedure/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:43:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/22/bir-summons-cannot-be-ignored-merely-because-an-loa-was-not-revalidated/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:40:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/22/cwt-refund-claims-can-fail-without-a-clear-audit-trail-from-withholding-certificates-to-reported-income/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:37:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/23/condominium-associations-can-challenge-local-business-tax-on-dues-and-common-area-charges/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:35:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/23/electric-cooperatives-with-city-principal-offices-may-face-franchise-tax-from-the-city-not-the-province/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:31:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/02/vat-refund-claims-fail-when-zero-rated-sales-and-input-taxes-are-not-fully-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:29:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/26/corrected-vat-invoices-can-preserve-input-tax-credits-in-deficiency-vat-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:25:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/07/late-or-defective-tax-protests-can-make-bir-assessments-final-and-unappealable/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:21:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/27/pagcor-licensees-can-defeat-dst-assessments-but-not-withholding-vat-on-foreign-suppliers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:17:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/27/bir-collection-warrants-can-be-cancelled-when-assessment-notices-are-not-properly-served/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:14:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/01/vat-refunds-for-bpos-can-fail-when-service-sites-are-not-properly-registered-as-branches/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:11:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/generic-objections-will-not-undo-a-tax-refund-win-in-the-court-of-tax-appeals/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:09:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/27/invalid-bir-audit-authority-can-void-a-deficiency-tax-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:06:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/28/alkylate-importers-may-claim-excise-tax-refunds-when-the-product-is-not-taxable-under-section-148e/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:03:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/28/cwt-refunds-can-be-denied-in-full-without-traceable-proof-of-reported-income/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T11:00:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/01/invalid-tax-assessments-can-defeat-criminal-tax-evasion-charges-for-failure-to-pay/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:57:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/30/tax-criminal-appeals-can-fail-on-proof-of-service-and-late-motions/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:54:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/30/tax-treaty-refunds-survive-technical-attacks-when-foreign-taxpayers-show-substantial-compliance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:51:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/30/milk-based-powdered-drinks-can-qualify-for-sweetened-beverage-tax-refunds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:49:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/30/late-government-appeals-can-end-tax-collection-cases-even-before-the-merits-are-reached/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:45:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/01/01/tax-evasion-case-dismissed-after-late-filing-what-prescription-means-for-bir-criminal-prosecutions/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:43:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/02/excise-tax-refunds-on-petroleum-sales-require-proof-linking-imported-fuel-to-tax-exempt-buyers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:38:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/02/tax-assessment-appeals-can-be-dismissed-when-proof-of-authority-is-not-filed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:36:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/02/medical-supply-retailers-can-lose-imported-goods-if-customs-duties-cannot-be-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:33:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/02/real-property-tax-protests-must-follow-local-assessment-remedies-before-going-to-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:31:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/01/duplicate-documentary-stamp-tax-on-bank-loans-may-be-refunded-if-taxpayer-proves-double-payment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:28:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/04/renewable-energy-vat-refund-denied-for-incomplete-official-receipts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:25:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/03/bir-cannot-revive-prescribed-vat-and-withholding-tax-assessments-without-proper-notice/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:22:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/03/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-taxpayers-do-not-receive-the-pan-and-fan/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:18:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/02/customs-smuggling-charges-can-proceed-when-prosecutors-cure-documentary-gaps-on-reconsideration/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:15:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/03/foreign-affiliate-loan-agreements-may-escape-documentary-stamp-tax-when-proceeds-are-released-and-used-abroad/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:11:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/03/tax-refund-claims-may-proceed-when-an-administrative-claim-was-filed-first/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:08:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/03/airline-excise-tax-refunds-upheld-when-imported-flight-supplies-are-cheaper-than-local-purchases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:06:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/03/improper-service-of-a-preliminary-assessment-notice-can-void-a-bir-tax-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:03:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/03/vat-refund-appeals-can-be-lost-on-procedure-even-when-the-refund-award-survives/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T10:01:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/03/foreign-royalty-refunds-can-fail-when-the-underlying-agreement-is-not-properly-authenticated/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:58:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/04/late-tax-protest-leaves-2018-bir-assessment-final-and-unappealable/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:55:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/01/electric-cooperatives-can-defeat-bir-income-tax-assessments-when-audits-lack-proper-authority/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:52:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/03/mutual-benefit-associations-may-challenge-local-business-tax-assessments-imposed-as-insurance-company-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:49:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/04/criminal-tax-charges-can-be-dismissed-when-prosecutors-wait-too-long/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:46:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/04/business-permit-statements-of-account-are-not-automatically-valid-local-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:43:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/04/tollway-operators-may-face-real-property-tax-on-government-owned-roads-they-operate-for-profit/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:41:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/04/cwt-refunds-can-be-denied-when-taxpayers-cannot-trace-withheld-income-to-gross-income/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:38:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/04/customs-smuggling-charges-can-be-dismissed-when-commissioner-approval-is-missing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:35:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/04/holding-companies-can-challenge-local-business-tax-on-dividends-when-city-billings-are-not-valid-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:33:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/04/local-business-tax-refund-claims-survive-when-payment-orders-are-not-deficiency-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:30:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/04/vat-refund-claims-fail-when-group-netting-arrangements-are-not-clearly-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:27:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/05/late-tax-appeals-can-end-criminal-tax-cases-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:25:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/10/07/bir-tax-audit-voided-when-letter-notice-replaced-letter-of-authority/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:22:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/05/criminal-tax-cases-can-be-dismissed-when-the-government-files-the-information-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:19:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/05/foreign-government-investors-can-recover-final-withholding-tax-on-philippine-treasury-bond-interest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:17:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/05/customs-protest-appeals-can-be-lost-by-missing-the-30-day-petition-deadline/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:14:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/20/cwt-refund-claims-need-more-than-bir-form-2307-court-allows-only-amounts-traced-to-gross-income/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:11:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/bir-assessment-voided-for-lack-of-due-date-and-failure-to-consider-taxpayers-pan-reply/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:08:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/25/vat-refund-denied-after-zero-rated-sales-and-input-tax-fail-substantiation-tests/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:05:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/06/late-criminal-tax-cases-can-be-dismissed-when-the-five-year-prescription-period-has-already-run/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:02:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/06/bir-assessments-can-still-fall-when-the-final-demand-ignores-the-taxpayers-pan-reply/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T09:00:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/06/input-vat-carryovers-cannot-automatically-offset-deficiency-vat-assessments-tax-court-says/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:56:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/06/missed-collection-deadlines-can-void-bir-assessments-despite-pending-administrative-appeals/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:54:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/06/late-tax-appeals-can-save-or-sink-collection-cases-why-service-on-the-osg-matters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:51:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/06/bir-accreditation-for-tax-agents-upheld-what-cpas-and-tax-representatives-must-know/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:48:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/06/vat-refund-claims-fail-when-zero-rated-sales-are-not-fully-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:45:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/06/late-motions-cannot-revive-void-tax-assessments-after-a-taxpayer-wins-in-the-tax-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:43:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/06/dst-refund-allowed-for-central-bank-property-assignments-related-to-bank-liquidation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:41:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/06/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-taxpayers-pan-reply-is-ignored/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:38:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/01/vat-refund-claimants-can-present-trial-evidence-but-refunds-still-depend-on-proving-truly-excess-input-vat/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:35:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/01/underdeclaration-alone-does-not-save-a-prescribed-bir-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:33:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/10/late-vat-refund-appeals-can-defeat-even-large-input-tax-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:30:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/10/bir-assessments-may-be-voided-when-taxpayer-defenses-are-ignored-before-final-demand/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:27:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/10/late-government-appeals-can-end-tax-assessment-cases-before-the-merits-are-reached/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:25:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/10/renewable-energy-vat-refunds-denied-without-timely-proof-of-doe-registration-and-zero-rated-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:22:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/01/subic-freeport-taxpayers-can-defeat-rcit-and-vat-assessments-when-income-is-earned-inside-the-zone/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:20:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/10/premature-bir-collection-warrants-can-be-cancelled-when-tax-protests-remain-pending/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:17:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/11/invalid-fdda-service-does-not-automatically-stop-bir-collection-tax-court-warns/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:14:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/11/bir-collection-fails-when-tax-assessments-are-void-prescribed-or-still-under-appeal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:11:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/late-petition-for-relief-leaves-tax-refund-judgment-final-against-the-bir/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:08:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/11/missed-tax-appeal-deadlines-can-defeat-challenges-to-bir-collection-warrants/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:05:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/11/withdrawing-a-tax-refund-case-can-end-the-cta-dispute-but-taxpayers-must-treat-it-as-a-strategic-litigation-decision/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:03:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/11/missed-appeal-deadlines-can-end-a-tax-case-before-due-process-issues-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T08:00:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/12/blank-payment-due-dates-can-void-bir-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:57:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/12/real-property-tax-refunds-for-power-projects-when-lgus-must-return-excess-rpt-after-condonation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:55:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/12/foreign-branches-can-defeat-bprt-assessments-when-the-bir-cannot-prove-profit-remittance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:52:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/13/taxpayers-can-defeat-bir-assessments-when-pan-replies-are-ignored/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:50:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/13/tax-evasion-charges-can-fail-before-trial-when-the-information-is-defective/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:47:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/13/late-bir-appeals-can-end-tax-assessment-cases-before-the-merits-are-reached/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:44:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/01/cooperatives-can-defeat-bir-assessments-when-the-final-demand-ignores-their-protest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:42:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/17/excess-input-vat-carryovers-may-not-defeat-a-deficiency-vat-assessment-when-disallowed-credits-were-carried-forward/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:39:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/01/vat-assessments-can-survive-multiple-loas-but-unsupported-bir-findings-may-still-be-cut-down/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:36:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/01/bir-vat-assessment-cut-from-p28-99-million-to-p1-2-million-after-taxpayer-proves-valid-protest-and-weak-third-party-matching/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:31:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/13/tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-bir-ignores-a-taxpayers-protest-evidence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:28:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/13/missed-bir-protest-deadlines-can-make-deficiency-tax-assessments-immediately-collectible/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:25:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/13/wrong-appeal-mode-can-still-threaten-criminal-tax-cases-despite-a-timely-notice-of-appeal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:22:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/16/excess-cwt-refund-upheld-despite-bir-objections-on-timing-exhaustion-and-documentation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:20:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/rohq-vat-refund-claims-need-client-by-client-proof-of-foreign-status/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:17:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/excess-cwt-refunds-why-bir-form-2307-and-gross-income-tracing-can-make-or-break-a-tax-refund-claim/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:14:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/18/local-business-tax-refund-claims-cannot-be-dismissed-as-late-protests-when-no-deficiency-assessment-was-issued/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:11:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/01/deficiency-vat-assessments-can-fail-when-the-bir-misses-quarterly-prescription-and-ignores-taxpayer-defenses/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:08:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/18/excess-cwt-refunds-can-survive-timing-differences-if-taxpayers-prove-withholding-income-reporting-and-timely-filing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:04:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/18/outdated-share-valuation-can-defeat-a-donors-tax-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T07:02:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/late-tax-appeals-can-defeat-an-assessment-challenge-before-the-case-is-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:59:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/19/vat-refund-claimants-must-prove-where-export-services-were-performed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:57:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/19/bir-appeal-dismissed-after-refund-order-became-final-for-lack-of-osg-authority/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:55:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/20/vat-refund-win-photocopies-and-zero-rated-invoice-breakdowns-can-support-tax-credit-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:49:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/20/vat-refunds-survive-reconsideration-when-the-record-supports-zero-rated-sales-and-input-tax-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:47:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/20/tax-assessments-received-after-the-stated-due-date-may-be-voided/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:44:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/20/deficiency-vat-assessment-cancelled-after-reconsideration-fails-to-cure-due-process-and-factual-defects/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:42:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/23/clark-freeport-pagcor-licensees-remain-under-5-gross-income-tax-not-franchise-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:39:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/23/invalid-tax-waivers-can-still-defeat-bir-assessments-but-lease-dst-may-survive/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:36:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/23/tax-refund-appeals-can-be-lost-by-skipping-the-required-motion-for-reconsideration/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:33:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/23/customs-smuggling-charges-fail-when-prosecutors-cannot-prove-importation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:30:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/24/criminal-tax-cases-can-still-be-dismissed-when-the-government-files-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:28:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/19/improper-bir-service-can-defeat-criminal-tax-charges/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:25:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/24/late-bir-reconsideration-fails-as-deficiency-tax-assessment-cancellation-stands/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:21:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/25/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-final-demand-ignores-the-taxpayers-pan-reply/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:15:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/06/bir-bank-garnishment-voided-after-defective-service-of-tax-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:10:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/26/tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-taxpayer-did-not-actually-receive-the-preliminary-assessment-notice/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:07:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/26/foreign-government-owned-financing-institutions-can-recover-withheld-dividend-taxes-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:03:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/27/renewable-energy-developers-cannot-refund-vat-mistakenly-passed-on-by-suppliers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T06:00:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/27/invalid-tax-protests-can-make-bir-assessments-final-and-collectible/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:58:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/27/bir-assessments-can-be-voided-when-tax-notices-are-not-properly-served/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:55:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/02/27/fuel-suppliers-can-recover-excise-tax-on-jet-fuel-sold-to-international-airlines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:52:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/02/vat-refund-claimants-can-still-prove-their-case-in-court-with-properly-offered-evidence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:49:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/02/vat-refund-claims-cannot-be-defeated-by-returning-a-filed-application/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:47:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/02/tax-refund-appeals-can-be-lost-by-choosing-the-wrong-remedy-after-an-amended-decision/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:44:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/02/refund-claims-can-survive-reconsideration-when-the-tax-authority-merely-repeats-rejected-arguments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:42:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/02/tax-refund-claims-can-survive-fast-court-filings-when-the-two-year-deadline-is-met/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:39:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/missed-tax-appeal-deadlines-cannot-be-repackaged-as-certiorari/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:36:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/02/tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-bir-issues-the-final-demand-too-early/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:34:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/02/bank-garnishment-notices-are-not-tax-appeal-decisions-taxpayers-must-challenge-the-bir-warrant-itself/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:31:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/04/vat-refunds-can-survive-evidentiary-objections-when-public-documents-are-already-in-the-record/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:29:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/04/tax-assessment-appeals-can-fail-when-reconsideration-motions-ignore-procedural-dismissals/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:26:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/04/late-government-appeals-can-end-tax-criminal-cases-before-the-merits-are-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:24:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/04/income-tax-refunds-can-fail-when-the-wrong-year-starts-the-two-year-deadline/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:21:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/holding-companies-can-challenge-local-business-tax-on-dividend-income/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:18:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/vat-refunds-can-fail-when-zero-rated-receipts-do-not-describe-the-services/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:15:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/09/expired-tax-collection-can-stop-the-bir-but-late-refund-claims-still-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:13:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/vat-refund-claims-can-still-be-appealed-after-bir-inaction-but-zero-rated-sales-must-be-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:10:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/10/tax-appeals-can-be-lost-by-sending-the-petition-to-the-wrong-court-email/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:07:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/11/jet-fuel-excise-tax-refunds-upheld-for-sales-to-international-airlines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:05:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/11/late-bir-appeals-and-unauthorized-revenue-officers-can-defeat-deficiency-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T05:01:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/11/vat-refund-denied-when-receipts-fail-to-describe-the-services-rendered/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T04:58:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2026/03/11/deficiency-tax-assessments-can-be-voided-when-the-bir-ignores-a-taxpayers-protest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T04:56:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/02/19/no-10-year-tax-assessment-period-without-proof-of-fraudulent-return/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T04:51:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2025/01/01/cta-2nd-division-resolution-on-mr-people-of-the-philippines-v-rizaldy-goloran-chua-purok-gumamela-sta-cruz-rosario-agusan-del-sur-consol-with-o-793-case-no-o-792-violation-of-tax-code-f/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T04:49:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/06/21/when-probate-orders-become-final-why-old-estate-settlements-cannot-be-reopened-by-a-new-lawsuit/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T04:23:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/10/30/when-an-employer-knows-the-worker-is-sick-late-filing-will-not-defeat-compensation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T04:19:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/11/21/when-a-group-attack-becomes-murder-without-a-written-plan/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T04:12:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/08/31/probate-courts-cannot-finally-decide-ownership-of-disputed-property-in-an-estate-inventory/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T04:09:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/10/23/when-a-sudden-stabbing-is-homicide-not-murder-the-proof-needed-for-treachery/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T04:06:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/05/31/registration-is-not-a-shortcut-to-ownership-why-disputed-land-transfers-must-go-to-an-ordinary-civil-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T04:03:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/10/20/void-land-sales-do-not-prescribe-when-heirs-may-still-attack-a-fraudulent-deed-years-later/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T04:00:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/05/11/clients-can-settle-their-case-even-when-their-lawyers-still-have-fee-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:57:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/10/20/habeas-corpus-still-matters-even-after-release-why-temporary-detention-can-trigger-court-review/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:54:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/04/13/when-release-ends-a-habeas-corpus-case-why-courts-dismiss-detention-petitions-after-custody-ends/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:51:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/02/22/when-a-judge-steps-aside-mandamus-will-not-force-him-back-into-the-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:48:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/01/23/when-a-court-hearing-becomes-void-why-notice-to-counsel-is-essential-due-process/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:46:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/10/23/when-a-child-freezes-in-fear-why-failure-to-resist-does-not-defeat-a-rape-prosecution/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:43:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/07/21/when-silence-can-convict-admission-by-silence-conspiracy-and-attempted-murder-in-philippine-criminal-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:40:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/12/29/when-workplace-conditions-aggravate-an-illness-medical-benefits-may-still-be-owed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:37:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/10/30/when-a-deed-says-sale-but-the-facts-show-a-mortgage-why-possession-and-tax-declarations-matter/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:34:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/05/16/when-a-motion-for-reconsideration-saves-an-appeal-deadline/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:31:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/05/19/a-timely-appeal-should-not-be-lost-to-a-curable-record-defect/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:28:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/08/31/brake-failure-is-not-a-free-defense-when-mechanical-defects-still-lead-to-liability/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:25:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/11/10/adverse-claims-can-protect-heirs-before-probate-when-land-title-is-in-dispute/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:22:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/06/30/when-illness-strikes-at-work-the-employer-must-prove-it-was-not-work-connected/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:19:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/11/10/when-a-city-permit-fee-becomes-an-unconstitutional-tax-on-foreign-workers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:16:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/05/31/a-guilty-plea-cannot-shortcut-a-criminal-case-without-prosecutor-notice-and-consent/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:13:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/06/16/a-one-day-notice-cannot-put-a-party-in-default/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:10:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/08/23/a-court-approved-compromise-can-end-a-land-registration-fight-and-fix-co-ownership-shares/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:07:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/06/27/when-a-bond-covers-installment-contracts-the-surety-cannot-escape-by-calling-the-first-payment-ambiguous/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:04:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/09/12/when-local-courts-may-still-investigate-libel-complaints-despite-special-venue-rules/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T03:00:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/08/31/when-a-government-employer-misses-the-appeal-deadline-a-compensation-award-becomes-final/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:57:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/05/12/when-a-government-employees-work-illness-claim-cannot-be-defeated-by-a-filing-technicality/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:54:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/02/28/when-carrying-a-bolo-is-not-illegal-possession-the-incidental-weapon-use-doctrine/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:51:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/02/28/when-tax-declarations-are-wrong-good-faith-judicial-reliance-may-still-defeat-misconduct-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:48:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/08/31/when-judicial-error-is-not-misconduct-why-good-faith-court-action-matters-in-administrative-complaints/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:45:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/10/23/when-alibi-fails-positive-identification-and-unobjected-confessions-in-criminal-trials/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:43:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/03/31/work-related-assaults-after-work-can-still-be-compensable/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:39:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/09/30/when-a-two-sided-attack-becomes-murder-why-superior-strength-can-replace-treachery-in-a-killing-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:36:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/07/25/one-day-appeal-delay-should-not-defeat-substantial-justice/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:34:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/01/31/when-illness-appears-during-employment-the-employer-must-disprove-work-connection-3/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:31:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/10/30/when-cross-examination-is-denied-labor-evidence-can-collapse/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:28:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/05/16/when-a-surety-bond-becomes-immediately-collectible-missed-installments-can-trigger-full-liability/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:25:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/03/31/workers-can-break-away-from-a-union-and-demand-a-certification-election/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:22:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/06/27/caught-red-handed-when-public-officers-can-be-summarily-dismissed-without-a-full-formal-investigation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:19:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/06/22/when-a-land-sale-is-really-a-mortgage-why-courts-may-rewrite-the-deal-and-limit-taxes-interest-and-redemption-costs/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:16:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/10/23/self-defense-fails-when-the-evidence-shows-flight-multiple-gunshots-and-treachery/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:13:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/12/11/when-is-a-court-decision-really-rendered-why-filing-with-the-clerk-can-matter-in-tax-and-civil-litigation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:10:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/10/03/employers-cannot-block-a-union-vote-by-turning-signature-disputes-into-technical-objections/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:07:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/06/22/when-work-aggravates-illness-employees-may-still-recover-compensation-even-if-the-disease-has-personal-causes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:04:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/10/09/workmens-compensation-claims-cannot-be-defeated-by-missing-marriage-papers-alone/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T02:01:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/10/30/when-a-developer-delays-your-land-title-nominal-damages-may-still-be-awarded/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:58:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/11/16/a-union-can-leave-its-federation-without-losing-its-legal-personality/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:55:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/04/05/when-a-salary-law-meets-city-halls-budget-limits-why-local-officials-cannot-be-forced-to-pay-beyond-the-statutory-cap/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:52:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/06/22/when-employers-miss-the-deadline-work-injury-claims-become-much-harder-to-defeat/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:49:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/04/05/retrenchment-cannot-be-used-as-a-cover-for-union-busting/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:46:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/12/29/when-illness-strikes-at-work-compensation-may-be-presumed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:43:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/12/29/when-employers-stay-silent-workers-compensation-defenses-can-be-lost/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:40:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/05/11/illegal-strike-does-not-automatically-mean-workers-can-be-fired/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:37:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/09/30/when-habeas-corpus-fails-why-a-defective-arrest-order-will-not-free-a-detainee-facing-valid-court-charges/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:34:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/11/29/when-employers-miss-the-deadline-work-injury-claims-can-become-much-harder-to-defeat/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:31:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/12/14/a-confession-alone-is-not-enough-but-corroborated-evidence-can-still-convict/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:29:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/06/29/when-a-death-sentence-is-reviewed-automatically-lessons-on-charges-aggravating-circumstances-and-criminal-liability/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:26:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/30/real-property-disputes-must-be-filed-where-the-property-is-located/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:23:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/04/03/when-social-justice-meets-contract-rights-what-regulated-businesses-should-learn-from-the-sugar-sharing-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:20:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/25/disbarment-complaints-require-proof-not-pressure/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:16:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/12/14/when-fraud-turns-a-contract-penalty-into-extra-recoverable-damages/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:13:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/04/30/tax-refunds-without-protest-when-mistaken-real-property-tax-payments-must-be-returned/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:10:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/08/27/probationary-employees-can-still-be-let-go-when-there-is-no-fixed-tenure-or-anti-union-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:07:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/05/eyewitness-testimony-can-convict-even-without-motive-or-perfect-alibi/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:05:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/06/29/when-habitual-absences-become-gross-insubordination-in-public-service/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T01:02:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/31/when-illness-strikes-at-work-employers-must-prove-it-is-not-work-related/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:59:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/03/30/when-government-housing-promises-do-not-create-vested-property-rights/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:56:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/08/20/late-answers-can-still-save-a-property-case-when-default-would-defeat-substantial-justice/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:52:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/04/30/when-an-illness-begins-at-work-employers-must-act-fast-or-lose-key-defenses/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:49:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/18/when-local-ordinances-overreach-why-cities-and-municipalities-cannot-penalize-what-national-law-does-not-allow/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:46:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/18/employers-can-defeat-labor-execution-orders-when-the-worker-was-never-proven-entitled-to-reinstatement/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:43:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/30/workplace-incivility-in-court-offices-can-still-trigger-discipline-even-when-charges-are-dismissed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:40:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/01/15/court-clerks-cannot-act-like-judges-when-court-staff-cross-the-line-into-usurpation-of-judicial-power/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:38:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/04/30/when-family-disputes-become-civil-cases-why-courts-look-at-substance-not-magic-words/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:35:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/28/a-dead-party-cannot-be-bound-by-judgment-without-substitution/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:32:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/28/child-rape-convictions-can-stand-on-credible-testimony-even-without-signs-of-force/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:29:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/03/27/death-of-a-ward-does-not-automatically-kill-a-property-case-substitution-protects-estate-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:26:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/03/30/when-a-worker-gets-sick-on-the-job-silence-can-cost-the-employer/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:23:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/06/29/sheriffs-cannot-charge-winning-litigants-extra-fees-to-enforce-a-court-judgment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:21:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/30/adoption-cannot-be-proven-by-family-reputation-alone-in-estate-proceedings/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:18:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/11/16/when-work-aggravates-illness-employees-may-still-recover-compensation-benefits/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:14:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/12/18/mining-contract-disputes-must-first-go-to-the-mines-bureau-not-the-trial-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:11:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/06/29/when-judicial-misconduct-complaints-fail-why-honest-mistake-and-private-conduct-are-not-enough/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:08:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/09/14/when-a-judge-ignores-prescription-withdrawal-of-the-complaint-will-not-erase-the-misconduct/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:05:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/11/21/when-leaving-work-becomes-abandonment-why-reinstatement-is-not-a-safety-net-after-a-failed-job-search/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-28T00:02:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/01/15/when-work-related-illness-claims-are-filed-late-disability-not-first-diagnosis-starts-the-clock/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:59:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/02/judges-must-answer-attacks-with-restraint-not-insults/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:56:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/30/when-a-coordinated-ambush-becomes-murder-conspiracy-treachery-and-group-attacks-in-philippine-criminal-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:53:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/27/when-marital-privilege-cannot-shield-falsified-documents/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:50:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/28/a-quitclaim-cannot-cut-off-workers-compensation-below-what-the-law-guarantees/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:47:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/12/14/a-confession-alone-is-not-enough-how-corpus-delicti-protects-the-accused-in-criminal-trials/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:44:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/11/07/when-an-agencys-internal-review-is-real-and-when-it-is-not/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:41:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/11/21/self-defense-does-not-require-perfect-proportionality-when-the-threat-is-immediate/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:38:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/08/21/a-defective-motion-can-cost-you-the-case-when-missing-hearing-notices-make-judgments-final/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:35:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/12/14/a-guilty-plea-in-a-capital-case-is-not-enough-without-a-real-safeguard-against-mistake/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:32:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/01/when-broken-railroad-crossing-signals-make-the-operator-liable-for-lifetime-injury-damages/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:29:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/06/29/when-acting-in-a-government-job-becomes-a-right-to-appointment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:26:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/06/15/even-a-guilty-plea-cannot-save-an-illegal-sentence-why-courts-must-correct-excessive-penalties/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:23:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/21/a-pending-motion-for-reconsideration-can-stop-execution-when-it-is-not-merely-for-delay/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:20:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/12/18/work-related-illness-claims-cannot-be-defeated-by-silence-why-employers-must-timely-controvert-compensation-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:17:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/19/court-filing-fees-must-follow-the-assessed-value-not-a-partys-market-estimate/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:14:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/08/06/you-cannot-be-convicted-of-murder-when-the-charge-only-says-homicide/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:11:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1977/08/05/when-the-government-misses-its-appeal-deadline-certiorari-cannot-rescue-the-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:08:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/09/04/when-customs-seizes-goods-ordinary-courts-cannot-take-them-back/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:04:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/15/when-work-related-illness-is-presumed-compensable-a-teachers-victory-against-a-late-government-appeal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T23:01:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/09/10/when-a-strike-skips-the-grievance-process-workers-can-lose-their-jobs/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:58:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/30/when-a-good-faith-possessor-can-keep-the-property-until-reimbursed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:55:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/04/30/when-a-river-changes-course-property-rights-cannot-be-decided-by-shortcut/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:51:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/02/reinstatement-does-not-always-mean-backwages-when-labor-tribunals-must-explain-why-pay-is-denied/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:48:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/06/19/foremen-can-vote-in-union-certification-elections-unless-true-managerial-authority-is-proven/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:45:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/20/when-lifetime-transfers-stay-out-of-the-estate-inventory-lessons-for-estate-tax-and-probate-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:42:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/25/wrongful-attachment-and-replevin-bonds-when-a-surety-can-still-be-made-to-pay-damages/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:39:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/31/unpaid-loans-are-not-automatically-estafa-when-debt-collection-must-stay-civil/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:36:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/04/30/heirs-cannot-reopen-a-decades-old-land-sale-by-calling-it-a-mortgage/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:33:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/16/when-a-criminal-case-can-proceed-without-a-preliminary-investigation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:30:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/04/30/when-a-sudden-stab-becomes-murder-treachery-defense-of-a-relative-and-voluntary-surrender-in-philippine-criminal-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:27:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/03/rent-control-can-stop-ejectment-even-when-the-lease-has-expired/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:24:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/27/a-weak-motion-for-reconsideration-can-cost-your-tax-appeal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:20:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/15/when-refiling-the-same-complaint-becomes-misconduct-a-lawyers-duty-of-candor-in-administrative-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:18:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/06/29/when-labor-arbiters-can-award-moral-damages-for-illegal-dismissal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:15:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/03/13/when-a-robbery-turns-deadly-why-all-conspirators-can-be-liable-for-homicide-even-if-the-victim-was-a-bystander/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:12:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/31/influence-fees-are-not-enforceable-business-expenses-when-commissions-for-government-favor-become-void/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:09:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/11/07/fraudulent-land-titles-can-be-challenged-but-timing-and-good-faith-control-the-remedy/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:06:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/09/28/foreign-currency-claims-need-proof-but-admitted-exchange-rates-can-carry-the-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T22:02:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/01/11/when-eyewitnesses-and-dying-declarations-are-enough-to-convict/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:59:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/03/26/missed-appeal-deadlines-can-lock-in-employee-compensation-awards/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:56:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/04/30/when-a-judges-conduct-becomes-the-case-the-rule-on-courtroom-neutrality-and-public-access-to-justice/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:52:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/09/27/when-foreign-currency-claims-survive-in-philippine-courts-interest-shipping-contracts-and-attorneys-fees/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:49:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/25/when-a-notarized-will-is-hard-to-defeat-the-probate-rule-every-heir-should-know/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:46:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/28/demolition-after-ejectment-why-courts-must-give-losing-occupants-time-before-removing-improvements/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:42:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/11/21/a-cash-appeal-bond-filed-on-time-should-not-be-defeated-by-court-inaction/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:39:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/12/27/when-a-confession-can-convict-the-ramos-rule-on-voluntary-admissions-corroboration-and-trial-court-credibility/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:36:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/04/30/when-a-minor-offense-has-already-prescribed-prosecutors-cannot-revive-it-by-bundling-it-with-a-bigger-charge/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:33:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/09/11/registered-land-beats-possession-why-torrens-title-still-controls-property-claims-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:30:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/08/31/a-guilty-plea-is-not-a-shortcut-to-conviction-why-courts-must-still-test-the-evidence-in-capital-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:27:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/08/24/when-a-guilty-plea-can-still-lead-to-the-harshest-penalty/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:23:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/08/20/when-illness-appears-during-employment-the-employer-must-prove-it-is-not-work-related/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:20:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/11/07/a-guilty-plea-can-still-lead-to-the-harshest-penalty-when-the-court-makes-a-searching-inquiry/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:17:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/28/default-judgments-cannot-be-used-as-shortcuts-when-pre-trial-notice-is-defective/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:14:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/12/27/when-a-final-disability-award-becomes-unchangeable-what-workers-can-do-when-compensation-payments-stop/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:11:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/23/suspicion-is-not-proof-why-courts-must-acquit-when-eyewitness-identification-leaves-reasonable-doubt/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:07:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/15/fear-does-not-defeat-eyewitness-identification-when-delayed-reporting-still-convicts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:04:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/20/when-confessions-carry-the-case-why-specific-details-can-defeat-alibi-but-not-automatically-justify-death/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T21:01:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/08/20/when-courts-cannot-avoid-a-case-by-calling-it-political-the-casibang-rule-on-judicial-duty/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:58:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/20/when-a-criminal-appeal-reaches-life-imprisonment-the-appellate-court-must-first-decide-the-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:54:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/03/26/when-death-benefits-fail-disability-compensation-may-still-be-won/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:52:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/30/when-eyewitness-testimony-and-confessions-converge-why-courts-may-uphold-convictions-despite-claims-of-coercion/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:48:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/16/when-government-policy-makes-payment-legally-impossible-the-import-permit-rule-in-contract-enforcement/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:45:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/28/a-payroll-settlement-is-not-a-waiver-of-disability-compensation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:42:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/03/30/when-a-tax-or-utility-case-cannot-be-dismissed-for-delay-the-olongapo-ice-doctrine-on-good-faith-inaction/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:39:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/09/28/when-a-charge-names-the-wrong-law-why-courts-cannot-dismiss-if-the-facts-still-show-a-crime/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:36:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/05/registered-mail-is-not-valid-summons-why-default-judgments-can-be-voided-for-improper-service/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:33:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/28/when-consent-is-legally-impossible-rape-mental-deficiency-and-the-weight-of-victim-testimony/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:30:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/08/06/when-a-life-story-becomes-a-film-privacy-public-figures-and-the-enforceability-of-licensing-agreements/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:27:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/01/a-defective-motion-for-reconsideration-will-not-save-a-late-appeal-in-government-property-and-tax-related-litigation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:23:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/28/when-a-missed-pre-trial-hearing-can-still-cost-you-your-day-in-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:19:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/01/16/when-sharp-pleadings-become-contempt-what-tax-litigants-should-know-about-courtroom-advocacy/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:16:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/13/when-a-confession-sticks-the-robbery-with-homicide-rule-on-corroborated-extrajudicial-admissions/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:13:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/14/property-attached-in-a-damages-suit-why-you-must-first-ask-the-trial-court-to-lift-it/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:10:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/11/when-a-sheriff-levies-the-wrong-property-the-real-owner-can-still-stop-the-sale/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:07:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/11/21/when-a-local-tax-ordinance-has-already-expired-courts-will-not-decide-its-validity-just-for-academic-purposes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:03:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/01/31/when-employers-stay-silent-workers-compensation-claims-can-become-practically-unanswerable/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T20:00:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/27/when-a-government-workers-final-compensation-award-cannot-be-reversed-later/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:57:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/03/27/a-closed-business-may-still-owe-back-wages-when-its-own-records-show-continued-operations/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:54:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/18/paying-real-property-tax-is-not-enough-to-register-land-in-your-name/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:51:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/28/when-court-delay-becomes-personal-liability-clerk-of-court-fined-for-ignoring-summons-return/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:48:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/30/when-courts-cannot-dismiss-your-case-just-because-your-lawyer-moved-too-slowly/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:45:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/28/teachers-forced-to-retire-by-illness-may-still-claim-full-workmens-compensation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:43:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/18/when-a-family-corporation-is-treated-as-an-estate-piercing-the-corporate-veil-in-property-and-tax-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:40:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/04/30/when-a-court-notice-is-ambiguous-a-party-should-not-lose-the-case-by-default/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:37:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/04/30/employers-must-stay-out-of-union-certification-elections-even-during-workplace-unrest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:34:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/06/29/years-worked-before-the-labor-code-still-count-for-retirement-pay/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:31:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/11/21/holding-the-victim-can-make-you-liable-as-a-principal-in-homicide/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:28:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/05/directly-filed-libel-complaints-can-still-move-forward-in-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:25:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/11/07/when-a-confession-can-convict-the-supreme-courts-rule-on-voluntary-admissions-and-re-enactments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:22:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/09/when-illness-strikes-at-work-employers-must-overcome-the-presumption-of-compensability/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:19:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/28/when-a-complaints-facts-matter-more-than-its-label-in-possession-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:16:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/04/30/a-conditional-inheritance-can-fail-if-the-will-does-not-clearly-name-a-qualified-heir/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:13:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/04/18/public-officers-can-be-dismissed-for-letting-government-property-secure-personal-debts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:09:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/06/29/when-cargo-weight-is-grossly-underdeclared-customs-may-impose-the-maximum-fine/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:06:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/20/when-robbery-turns-deadly-why-treachery-can-still-raise-the-penalty-in-robbery-with-homicide/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:03:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/12/18/when-a-workers-illness-appears-during-employment-the-employer-must-disprove-work-connection/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T19:00:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/09/27/a-missed-pre-trial-brief-should-not-automatically-cost-you-the-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:57:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/23/when-public-officers-must-post-an-appeal-bond-after-losing-a-damages-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:55:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/12/27/when-a-sheriff-delays-execution-and-mishandles-money-the-court-can-order-dismissal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:52:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/28/dissolving-a-partnership-does-not-make-its-assets-judgment-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:49:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/07/16/labor-officials-cannot-outsource-union-election-appeals-to-a-private-federation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:46:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/08/31/when-a-robbery-turns-deadly-every-proven-participant-may-face-the-full-penalty/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:42:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/18/tax-declarations-do-not-decide-just-compensation-in-expropriation-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:39:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/06/19/certiorari-is-not-a-shortcut-when-an-ordinary-appeal-is-available/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:36:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/31/a-dollar-payment-clause-may-be-illegal-but-the-debt-itself-can-still-be-collected-in-pesos/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:33:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/01/16/a-renewed-cba-cannot-block-a-certification-election-when-it-was-signed-too-early/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:30:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/02/28/when-non-union-employees-cannot-be-charged-union-lawyers-fees/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:27:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/23/a-defective-levy-notice-will-not-save-an-owner-who-waits-too-long-to-challenge-an-execution-sale/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:24:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/03/30/unpaid-taxes-can-follow-an-estate-beyond-probate-deadlines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:21:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/05/when-government-review-can-revive-a-dismissed-employee-appeal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:17:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/08/06/a-guilty-plea-in-a-capital-case-does-not-end-the-courts-duty-to-prove-guilt/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:14:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/11/07/joining-a-robbery-gang-can-make-every-member-liable-for-the-killing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:11:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/03/30/a-late-appeal-brief-does-not-automatically-kill-your-case-when-substantial-justice-requires-review/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:07:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/12/14/when-a-group-attack-proves-conspiracy-but-not-murder/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:04:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/09/11/coerced-confessions-cannot-convict-why-courts-must-exclude-evidence-obtained-through-force/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T18:01:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/05/31/union-requested-dismissals-still-require-due-process-employers-cannot-fire-workers-blindly/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-27T17:58:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url></urlset>