<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<?xml-stylesheet type="text/xsl" href="https://www.makatilawfirm.com/sitemaps.xsl" ?>
<urlset xmlns="http://www.sitemaps.org/schemas/sitemap/0.9" xmlns:image="http://www.google.com/schemas/sitemap-image/1.1">	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1995/12/01/metro-manila-joint-assessment-why-pasig-tax-hikes-were-voided/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T23:26:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1995/04/06/public-utility-ownership-divide-sc-upholds-edsa-lrt-iii-contract/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T23:21:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1996/03/29/res-judicata-flexibility-when-property-claims-may-still-proceed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T23:17:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1997/06/19/implied-trust-in-property-disputes-why-proof-matters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T23:13:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1997/06/05/estate-tax-collection-doctrine-probate-cannot-stop-the-bir/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T23:10:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1997/12/03/anti-competition-deregulation-doctrine-why-ra-8180-fell/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T23:06:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1998/09/17/actual-possession-notice-why-land-buyers-must-investigate/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T23:01:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1998/12/09/ill-gotten-wealth-disclosure-sc-opens-pcgg-deals-to-public/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T22:57:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1998/09/25/foreign-judgment-service-doctrine-when-ph-courts-refuse-enforcement/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T22:53:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1999/12/17/public-land-control-doctrine-why-denr-findings-can-defeat-titles/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T22:48:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1999/02/19/tax-assessment-exhaustion-doctrine-when-court-challenges-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T22:45:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1999/07/19/domicile-requirement-doctrine-when-votes-cannot-cure-ineligibility/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T22:41:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2000/04/28/actual-possession-notice-when-torrens-title-does-not-protect-banks/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T22:33:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2000/02/03/land-registration-priority-when-a-later-title-defeats-an-earlier-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T22:30:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2000/08/22/muslim-estate-settlement-when-sharia-courts-must-hear-more-evidence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T22:27:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2002/01/31/civil-law-land-registration-doctrine-sc-upholds-fraud-standards-in-reconstituted-titles/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T22:18:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/06/08/hierarchy-of-courts-and-land-reclassification-sc-clarifies-redemption-rights/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T22:02:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/10/18/pleadings-scope-doctrine-relief-limited-to-filed-claims-in-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:56:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/11/25/eminent-domain-writ-ministerial-issuance-upon-compliance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:53:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/09/09/co-ownership-and-torrens-title-doctrine-supreme-court-upholds-indefeasible-ownership/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:50:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/09/27/real-estate-contract-interpretation-supreme-court-clarifies-validity-of-partial-payments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:47:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/01/14/coa-audit-jurisdiction-doctrine-limits-on-charging-lwds-fees/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:44:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/09/07/homestead-patent-nullity-doctrine-sc-confirms-limits-on-private-reversion-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:41:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/09/13/estate-sale-approval-doctrine-court-affirms-requirement-for-probate-court-consent/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:39:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/05/25/agricultural-land-conversion-and-tenancy-doctrine-sc-upholds-dar-authority/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:36:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/01/29/co-ownership-sale-doctrine-supreme-court-clarifies-property-rights-and-laches/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:33:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/09/24/deed-of-absolute-sale-doctrine-sc-clarifies-contract-validity-and-performance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:27:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/07/02/no-extrajudicial-closure-lgus-cannot-shut-down-taxpayers-at-will/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:20:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/07/07/labor-reinstatement-doctrine-sc-affirms-return-to-work-orders-in-maritime-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:17:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/07/02/vat-exemption-limits-supreme-court-clarifies-input-tax-refunds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:11:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/09/30/equitable-mortgage-presumption-when-a-deed-of-sale-secures-a-loan/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:06:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/08/09/eminent-domain-compliance-doctrine-sc-invalidates-pasig-expropriation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T21:04:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/10/14/mutual-life-insurance-cooperative-doctrine-sc-upholds-tax-exemption/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T20:59:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/08/31/civil-ownership-dispute-sc-rules-on-lawful-vehicle-ownership-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T20:56:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/08/31/laches-and-registered-land-supreme-court-upholds-owners-rights/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T20:53:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/02/11/peza-vat-refund-doctrine-sc-upholds-zero-rating-for-export-zone-enterprises/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T20:50:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/10/11/eminent-domain-compensation-doctrine-sc-affirms-nia-claims-and-time-bars-for-landowners/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T20:47:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/07/08/non-retroactive-vat-rulings-protecting-taxpayer-rights-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T20:44:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2006/11/29/ancestral-domain-and-ifma-conversion-sc-upholds-picops-compliance-requirements/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T20:36:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2006/06/08/laches-and-acquisitive-prescription-sc-upholds-dicman-heirs-property-rights/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T20:31:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2006/02/28/private-vs-public-corporation-sc-rules-vfp-not-government-controlled/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T20:24:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2006/09/26/eminent-domain-just-compensation-supreme-court-clarifies-valuation-limits/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T20:15:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2006/12/06/non-impairment-doctrine-supreme-court-affirms-picop-timber-rights/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T20:13:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2006/08/31/equitable-mortgage-doctrine-sc-upholds-contractual-intent-in-property-repurchase/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T20:09:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/03/22/quieting-of-title-doctrine-sc-affirms-ownership-amid-conflicting-sales-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T20:05:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/09/25/torrens-registration-doctrine-protecting-good-faith-buyers-in-double-sale-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:59:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/07/31/national-government-instrumentality-tax-doctrine-pfda-and-real-property-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:57:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/08/03/tax-refund-claims-supreme-court-upholds-strict-filing-requirements/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:54:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/03/22/eminent-domain-limits-sc-rules-private-benefit-cannot-justify-expropriation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:52:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/07/06/ejectment-and-possession-doctrine-upholding-stipulated-property-rights-in-forcible-entry-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:46:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/04/27/zero-rated-vat-refund-doctrine-when-invoice-defects-do-not-defeat-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:41:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/11/23/constructive-trust-and-prescription-sc-upholds-ownership-through-adverse-possession/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:38:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/01/31/public-interest-litigation-doctrine-sc-clarifies-legal-standing-for-taxpayers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:35:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/10/15/eminent-domain-doctrine-supreme-court-upholds-expropriation-for-socialized-housing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:32:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/03/02/prescription-and-land-registration-doctrine-sc-upholds-private-title-over-public-land/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:29:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/04/04/fixed-savings-deposit-dst-liability-sc-upholds-tax-on-bank-passbooks/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:20:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/03/30/eminent-domain-in-agrarian-reform-supreme-court-upholds-dar-procedures/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:17:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/11/22/constructive-receipt-doctrine-sc-clarifies-local-business-tax-base-for-contractors/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:14:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/04/27/forgery-in-mortgage-documents-sc-rules-on-bank-liability-and-property-rights/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:11:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/03/06/customs-collection-doctrine-finality-of-liquidation-and-rtc-jurisdiction/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:06:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/02/13/parol-partition-doctrine-sc-confirms-oral-co-ownership-agreements-in-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T19:04:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/04/14/fraudulent-loan-doctrine-banks-can-demand-immediate-payment-from-dishonest-borrowers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:59:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/04/30/estate-tax-deduction-doctrine-claims-fixed-at-decedents-death-matter/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:56:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/03/28/special-allowance-conversion-doctrine-e-o-611s-10-increase-on-judiciary-pay/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:53:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/06/30/tax-assessment-prescription-doctrine-sc-upholds-time-barred-waivers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:49:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/06/17/forum-shopping-doctrine-sc-dismisses-out-of-time-civil-petition/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:47:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/06/18/corporate-veil-piercing-in-agrarian-reform-when-sale-schemes-fail-under-philippine-law/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:44:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/08/06/res-judicata-in-property-disputes-supreme-court-bars-reconstitution-of-forged-titles/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:41:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/08/11/quitclaim-ratification-doctrine-upholding-notarized-land-transfers-in-philippine-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:39:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/09/08/real-party-in-interest-doctrine-limits-on-collateral-attacks-to-land-titles/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:36:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/09/17/corporate-veil-shredding-in-tax-fraud-supreme-court-upholds-unified-tax-liability/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:29:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/09/17/judicial-confirmation-of-imperfect-title-sc-upholds-state-ownership-presumption/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:26:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/10/08/full-compensation-for-aerial-easements-supreme-court-upholds-landowner-rights/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:24:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/11/27/judicial-confirmation-of-imperfect-title-sc-upholds-strict-proof-requirements/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:21:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/12/08/prior-sanggunian-approval-doctrine-when-lgu-contracts-require-authorization/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:18:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/12/24/declaratory-relief-and-tax-assessment-limits-supreme-court-upholds-ca-no-55/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:15:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/07/03/tax-sale-jurisdiction-doctrine-court-affirms-mandatory-deposit-requirement/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:09:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/01/14/imprescriptibility-of-actions-for-null-contracts-supreme-court-upholds-heirs-land-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:06:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/09/03/forged-deed-no-title-rule-recovering-fraudulent-land-titles/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:03:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/12/03/eviction-rescission-deadline-when-property-buyers-sue-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T18:01:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/02/18/donation-acceptance-rule-invalid-waivers-in-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:58:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/06/23/flawed-prior-title-rule-when-an-older-land-title-loses-in-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:56:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/09/11/actual-occupation-rule-why-possession-alone-cannot-register-land/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:53:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/12/04/mandatory-return-to-work-orders-why-employers-must-readmit-strikers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:50:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/04/24/homestead-patent-quitclaims-why-mere-waivers-cannot-transfer-land/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:48:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/06/16/ripeness-in-judicial-review-when-courts-reject-premature-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:45:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/06/30/torrens-cancellation-due-process-why-ex-parte-attacks-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:43:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/10/16/agrarian-foreclosure-bar-why-banks-cannot-seize-farmer-lands/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:40:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/10/09/osg-appellate-counsel-rule-criminal-appeals-need-state-due-process/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:37:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/09/18/possession-by-tolerance-rule-file-ejectment-in-the-proper-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:35:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/12/03/forest-license-mandamus-rule-why-denr-discretion-matters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:32:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/04/07/ample-opportunity-rule-due-process-in-philippine-dismissals/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:30:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/09/11/property-prescription-rule-when-delay-defeats-heirs-land-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:27:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/06/22/alien-land-ownership-bar-why-foreign-buyers-cannot-control-philippine-land/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:24:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/08/25/free-patent-fraud-rule-when-a-torrens-title-cannot-be-cancelled/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:22:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/03/13/judicial-just-compensation-rule-fair-value-in-agrarian-takings/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:19:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/04/02/prior-restraint-by-permit-denial-lgu-closure-of-media-businesses/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:16:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/07/31/agrarian-retention-disclosure-rule-why-incomplete-land-claims-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:13:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/10/16/third-party-mortgage-priority-when-labor-execution-cannot-reach-assets/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:11:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/07/22/indispensable-property-party-rule-why-land-cases-can-be-voided/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:08:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/07/15/legal-interest-tax-protest-rule-who-may-challenge-realty-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:05:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/12/08/well-nigh-proof-rule-why-land-title-claims-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:03:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/10/02/transitional-input-tax-credit-rule-vat-refunds-for-real-estate-dealers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T17:00:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/02/04/arrastre-burden-rule-cargo-loss-liability-in-philippine-ports/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:58:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/02/26/clear-tax-imposition-rule-cinema-vat-assessments-rejected/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:55:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/02/16/off-line-carrier-tax-rule-philippine-income-tax-on-ticket-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:52:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/02/16/bank-secrecy-evidence-rule-when-bank-records-stay-out-of-trial/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:50:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/04/20/real-party-in-interest-rule-why-property-appeals-can-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:47:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/02/17/genuine-issue-trial-rule-quieting-title-requires-evidence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:44:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/01/21/pawn-ticket-dst-rule-when-pawnshops-owe-tax-and-penalties-fall/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:42:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/09/29/refund-doubt-rule-when-tax-errors-defeat-a-refund-claim/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:37:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/08/25/withholding-agent-refund-rule-smarts-tax-credit-win/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:34:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/07/29/assessed-value-jurisdiction-where-to-file-possession-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:32:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/10/18/alienable-land-possession-rule-when-occupants-beat-paper-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:29:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/08/24/clear-proof-land-registration-why-possession-alone-is-not-title/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:26:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/08/08/land-identity-rule-why-reconveyance-claims-fail-without-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:24:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/05/30/concrete-evidence-tenancy-rule-proving-agrarian-rights-in-land-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:21:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/03/16/clear-proof-land-registration-rule-why-tax-declarations-are-not-enough/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:19:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/04/05/delayed-just-compensation-when-landowners-can-claim-interest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:16:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/09/07/taxpayer-liability-rule-withholding-failures-cannot-erase-tax-due/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:14:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/01/19/statutory-taxpayer-refund-rule-who-can-claim-excise-tax-refunds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:11:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/06/01/void-partition-by-simulation-recovering-land-taken-by-fraud/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:08:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/01/10/irrevocable-carry-over-rule-tax-refund-lost-after-credit-election/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:06:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/07/25/joinder-jurisdiction-rule-why-property-cases-may-belong-in-rtc/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:03:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/12/06/revenue-target-due-process-boc-attrition-upheld/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T16:01:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/06/15/boundary-first-tax-rule-when-lgus-must-wait-before-collecting-rpt/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:58:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/03/28/lost-customs-shipment-rule-when-boc-must-pay-importers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:55:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/11/12/non-extendible-mr-rule-lost-appeals-cannot-be-revived/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:53:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/09/13/carp-lease-improvements-rule-who-owns-crops-and-improvements/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:48:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/07/03/exclusive-calling-out-powers-why-local-emergency-orders-can-be-void/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:45:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/10/11/co-owner-recovery-rule-one-heir-can-sue-to-recover-possession/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:43:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/11/12/dried-river-bed-rule-why-riparian-owners-cannot-register-state-land/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:40:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/02/07/coa-pre-audit-discretion-why-taxpayers-cannot-compel-pre-audit/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:38:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/06/20/adjudicator-non-appeal-rule-why-the-ombudsman-could-not-appeal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:35:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/07/02/patrimonial-declaration-rule-why-tax-declarations-do-not-prove-land-title/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:33:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/08/22/voluntary-surrender-of-tenancy-rights-when-farm-sales-are-void/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:30:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/04/25/emancipation-patent-proof-rule-how-agrarian-titles-stand/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:27:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/02/29/mandatory-dar-formula-rule-agrarian-just-compensation-must-follow-law/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:25:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/01/25/just-compensation-proof-rule-who-gets-paid-in-expropriation-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:16:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/02/13/co-owner-partition-rights-when-a-land-sale-cannot-defeat-an-heir/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:13:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/11/25/clear-tax-exemption-rule-why-franchise-assets-still-face-realty-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:11:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/11/20/principal-relief-jurisdiction-when-land-cases-belong-in-the-rtc/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:08:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/08/07/free-patent-fraud-proof-rule-when-reversion-fails-in-land-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:05:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/03/06/open-possession-title-rule-proving-land-ownership-in-ph/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:03:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/11/13/asset-sale-non-merger-rule-tax-liability-after-bank-acquisitions/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T15:01:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/12/10/vehicle-clamping-due-process-when-lgus-may-immobilize-cars/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:58:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/07/29/just-compensation-objection-waiver-why-delay-can-defeat-expropriation-appeals/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:56:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/10/17/vat-refund-12030-rule-when-timing-decides-tax-recovery/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:53:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/07/16/bound-presidential-discretion-in-national-awards-why-process-matters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:51:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/01/16/inalienable-park-land-why-void-titles-must-be-cancelled/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:48:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/03/20/assessed-value-jurisdiction-where-property-title-cases-must-be-filed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:45:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/10/08/vat-refund-12030-rule-why-early-cta-appeals-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:43:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/07/29/tax-deduction-substantiation-rule-why-receipts-decide-tax-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:40:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/10/09/land-registration-proof-rule-why-tax-declarations-are-not-enough-4/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:38:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/02/18/regulatory-fee-vs-local-tax-when-lgu-charges-are-not-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:35:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/12/03/tax-waiver-prescription-rule-when-bir-collection-comes-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:33:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/10/13/nemo-dat-co-ownership-rule-when-land-buyers-get-only-what-sellers-own/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:30:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/11/10/imperfect-title-proof-rule-land-registration-evidence-matters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:28:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/06/09/two-year-tax-refund-rule-when-valid-claims-still-prescribe/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:25:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/06/04/mutual-insurance-tax-exemption-when-cda-registration-is-not-required/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:23:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/03/31/possession-follows-ownership-sc-rule-on-land-execution/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:20:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/07/02/tax-assessment-due-process-rule-when-bir-assessments-become-void/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:17:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/06/02/torrens-title-collateral-attack-rule-in-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:15:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/08/05/unincorporated-association-standing-who-can-sue-in-philippine-courts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:12:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/03/10/free-patent-redemption-rule-rtc-jurisdiction-over-land-repurchase/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:10:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/09/29/assessed-value-rule-why-property-recovery-cases-get-dismissed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:07:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/10/22/agricultural-activity-coverage-rule-when-carp-does-not-apply/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:05:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/12/10/false-return-tax-assessment-rule-when-bir-gets-10-years-to-assess/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T14:02:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/09/10/established-heirship-rule-when-reconveyance-need-not-wait/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:59:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/07/01/tax-refund-evidence-rule-why-proof-decides-refund-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:57:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/04/22/pacto-de-retro-sales-when-redemption-rights-expire-in-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:54:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/07/15/cta-jurisdiction-in-tax-appeals-why-procedure-can-defeat-a-tax-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:52:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/01/28/bad-faith-closure-dismissal-when-business-losses-cannot-hide-illegal-termination/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:49:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/07/15/tax-sale-redemption-deadline-when-forfeiture-becomes-final/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:47:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/06/17/prior-possession-rule-why-forcible-entry-claims-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:44:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/09/22/dual-citizenship-residency-rule-reacquired-filipinos-must-prove-domicile/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:42:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/04/22/procurement-funding-rule-why-budget-must-come-before-bidding/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:39:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/07/06/cadt-mootness-rule-when-ancestral-domain-title-ends-eviction/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:36:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/07/15/merger-dst-exemption-why-corporate-transfers-are-not-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:33:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/12/09/ftaa-contract-jurisdiction-rule-why-forum-matters-in-mining-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:27:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/09/13/election-residency-rule-temporary-absence-does-not-void-candidacy/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:24:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/04/18/void-fdda-rule-when-a-tax-decision-fails-due-process/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:22:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/11/28/public-land-compensation-rule-when-long-possession-must-be-paid/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:19:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/06/22/relocation-survey-rule-proving-boundaries-in-land-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:17:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/11/09/pagcor-tax-exemption-rule-vat-exempt-but-withholding-still-applies/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:14:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/07/27/connections-fraud-rule-fake-bir-contacts-can-mean-estafa/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:10:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/02/01/real-action-valuation-rule-property-cases-need-correct-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:07:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/09/21/mangrove-conversion-rule-when-fishpond-work-becomes-a-crime/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:05:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/08/17/invalid-levy-rule-why-creditors-cannot-seize-another-persons-land/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T13:02:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/11/09/land-registration-proof-rule-why-tax-declarations-are-not-enough-3/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:57:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/06/15/assessed-value-jurisdiction-rule-where-land-recovery-cases-belong/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:55:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/11/28/assessed-value-jurisdiction-rule-property-cases-can-be-voided/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:52:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/06/20/tax-bond-jeopardy-rule-when-cta-bonds-become-oppressive/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:49:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/07/04/personal-action-damages-rule-venue-in-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:46:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/06/06/tax-exemption-proof-rule-when-unsupported-tax-free-claims-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:44:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/06/15/caretaker-possession-rule-land-ownership-without-occupancy/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:41:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/05/30/whole-evidence-land-registration-rule-proving-land-ownership/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:39:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/01/13/ppp-bid-deference-rule-courts-wont-rebid-airport-projects/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:36:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/07/11/strict-dst-rule-when-interbank-call-loans-are-not-taxable/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:33:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/03/22/strict-waiver-rule-defective-bir-waivers-void-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:31:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/08/01/actual-taking-rule-just-compensation-in-eminent-domain-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:28:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/02/08/vat-refund-proof-rule-when-zero-rated-claims-fail-in-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:25:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/09/27/unregistered-land-buyer-peril-rule-banks-lose-bad-mortgages/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:23:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/09/11/due-process-tax-sale-rule-when-property-auctions-can-be-reopened/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:20:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/01/18/material-evidence-remand-rule-in-philippine-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:18:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/08/08/coco-levy-public-fund-rule-why-congress-must-authorize-use/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:14:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/07/12/loa-scope-rule-void-tax-assessments-beyond-audit-authority/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:09:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/11/20/clear-proof-rule-reconstituting-lost-land-titles-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:06:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/04/05/loa-due-process-rule-when-bir-vat-assessments-become-void/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T12:04:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/06/05/land-recovery-proof-rule-why-tax-declarations-are-not-enough/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:52:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/11/21/stock-transfer-disposition-rule-tax-on-share-loans-in-ph/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:48:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/03/07/void-ordinance-rule-when-lgu-franchise-taxes-cannot-be-collected/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:44:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/06/06/public-land-priority-rule-first-valid-applicant-beats-possession/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:42:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/07/23/tax-assessment-appeal-separation-cta-remedies-in-tax-evasion-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:40:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/01/11/sham-redundancy-rule-when-retrenchment-becomes-illegal-dismissal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:36:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/07/23/input-vat-cost-exclusion-sc-limits-construction-cost-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:34:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/02/19/vat-refund-strict-proof-rule-when-input-vat-cannot-be-refunded/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:31:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/11/28/no-interest-levy-rule-why-prior-buyers-beat-execution-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:28:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/06/06/ombudsman-exoneration-finality-when-dismissal-ends-the-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:25:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/09/26/quieting-title-best-evidence-rule-why-original-deeds-matter/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:23:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/01/24/donee-not-innocent-buyer-when-land-titles-fail-in-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:20:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/09/05/rpt-owner-liability-rule-when-property-owners-must-pay-local-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:17:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/03/12/torrens-title-possession-rule-why-cities-must-vacate-private-land/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:15:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/08/22/free-patent-right-of-way-when-road-projects-still-require-payment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:12:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/04/23/foreclosure-jurisdiction-rule-when-mortgage-cases-belong-in-mtc/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:09:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/07/11/strict-land-classification-proof-rule-when-land-titles-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:07:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/07/30/accion-publiciana-title-rule-possession-is-not-reconveyance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:04:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/02/06/real-action-by-ultimate-relief-property-jurisdiction-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T11:00:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/06/03/tax-appeal-equity-rule-late-cta-appeals-may-still-be-heard/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:58:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/11/11/tax-refund-two-year-rule-when-invalid-bir-taxes-can-still-prescribe/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:55:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/02/27/mcit-direct-cost-rule-insurance-taxes-are-not-service-costs/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:53:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/03/25/reconstituted-title-due-diligence-when-land-buyers-lose-protection/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:50:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/07/10/forest-charges-refund-rule-why-denr-filing-did-not-save-tax-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:48:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/03/11/oral-partition-rule-when-heirs-lose-stale-property-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:45:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/03/18/public-dominion-tax-sale-rule-sc-bars-auction-of-government-property/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:43:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/07/24/tax-matter-jurisdiction-rule-why-labor-arbitrators-cannot-decide-tax-refunds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:40:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/04/10/mandanas-doctrine-lgu-shares-must-come-from-all-national-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:38:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/01/14/withholding-tax-prescription-rule-tax-assessments-can-expire/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:35:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/07/03/mandamus-clear-legal-duty-rule-deped-payroll-deductions-reversed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:33:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/09/16/consultation-creates-counsel-lawyer-ethics-sc-ruling/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:28:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/11/03/operative-fact-cutoff-when-void-tax-incentives-stop-binding-lgus/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:25:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/07/15/vat-refund-reckoning-rule-when-cta-appeals-are-timely/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:23:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/12/09/lgu-boundary-charter-rule-when-local-borders-control-tax-and-power/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:20:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/11/09/ipo-separate-computation-rule-tax-due-on-each-share-sale/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:18:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/01/15/gross-philippine-billings-rule-shipping-tax-exposure-in-ph/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:15:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/02/03/boundary-tax-escrow-doctrine-paying-rpt-during-lgu-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:12:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/07/15/rpt-accrual-ownership-rule-when-tax-sales-become-unlawful/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:09:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/12/09/agrarian-homelot-compensation-finality-when-sc-rulings-must-be-paid/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:07:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/07/28/tax-compromise-finality-when-bir-settlement-ends-a-tax-case/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:04:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/09/16/boi-export-certification-rule-vat-refunds-need-actual-export-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T10:02:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/11/11/pagcor-licensee-tax-exemption-rule-casino-operators-still-pay-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:59:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/02/10/substantial-justice-in-tax-appeals-technical-defects-should-not-end-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:57:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/02/24/timely-just-compensation-sc-protects-owners-in-expropriation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:54:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/07/05/administrative-franchise-tax-rule-catv-permits-are-taxable/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:51:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/01/11/mandatory-commissioners-in-expropriation-just-compensation-must-be-tried/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:48:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/04/26/forcible-entry-by-stealth-when-land-intrusion-must-be-ejected/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:45:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/08/04/void-tax-assessment-rule-when-bir-due-process-failures-defeat-tax-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:43:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/12/06/leviable-equitable-interest-rule-when-labor-awards-reach-property/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:40:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/08/04/tax-declarations-and-possession-when-land-buyers-lose-in-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:36:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/10/06/premature-foreclosure-rule-when-banks-cannot-seize-mortgaged-property/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:33:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/05/12/quiet-title-proof-rule-why-tax-declarations-are-not-enough/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:31:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/10/06/void-local-tax-assessment-rule-due-process-beats-guesswork/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:28:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/01/13/patent-fraud-cancellation-rule-why-private-land-titles-can-still-fall/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:25:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/05/03/cta-local-tax-appeal-rule-wrong-forum-voids-local-tax-appeals/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:23:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/04/28/cta-tax-collection-appeal-rule-wrong-court-voids-tax-appeal/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:20:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/07/26/jurisdiction-laches-rule-when-it-is-too-late-to-object/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:18:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/07/27/two-year-tax-refund-rule-when-taxpayers-may-go-to-cta/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:15:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/03/29/judicial-review-standing-rule-why-abstract-challenges-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:13:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/03/29/direct-recourse-fact-bar-why-sc-dismissed-a-securities-challenge/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:10:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/04/06/quieting-of-title-evidence-rule-why-tax-declarations-are-not-enough/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:08:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/02/28/strict-reconstitution-rule-lost-land-titles-need-clear-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:05:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/04/05/land-title-certification-rule-proving-alienable-land-after-ra-11573/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:03:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/09/20/environmental-mandamus-limit-why-health-claims-failed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T09:00:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/03/21/no-receipt-illegal-recruitment-testimony-can-convict/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:58:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/08/01/proven-tolerance-rule-why-ejectment-failed-in-a-property-dispute/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:54:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/12/07/tolerated-possession-rule-when-landowners-can-recover-property/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:52:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/10/17/notarized-deed-fraud-rule-when-property-claims-beat-bare-denials/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:49:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/03/07/lost-title-jurisdiction-rule-void-reconstitution-in-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:44:23+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/06/14/jurisdiction-estoppel-late-attacks-on-foreclosure-judgments-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:41:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/11/08/short-period-return-rule-tax-refunds-after-dissolution/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:36:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/06/14/assessed-value-jurisdiction-rule-why-real-actions-get-dismissed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:34:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/07/10/assessed-portion-jurisdiction-rule-in-property-recovery-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:31:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/01/10/comelec-plebiscite-deference-when-courts-will-uphold-election-results/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:29:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/02/13/authorized-revenue-officer-rule-void-bir-tax-audits-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:26:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/06/27/suffrage-due-process-rule-when-election-delays-become-unconstitutional/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:24:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/03/08/just-compensation-interest-delayed-expropriation-payments-cost-more/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:20:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/04/12/expropriation-necessity-first-sc-limits-writs-of-possession/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:18:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/02/13/pan-payment-estoppel-when-tax-settlement-bars-a-refund/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:15:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/02/15/zero-rated-vat-refund-rule-input-vat-need-not-be-offset/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:13:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/04/26/tax-ruling-collateral-attack-rule-why-rtcs-cannot-stop-tax-collection/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:11:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/08/23/ra-11573-remand-rule-land-title-proof-after-the-new-titling-law/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:08:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/02/15/reconveyance-trial-rule-why-land-title-disputes-need-evidence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:05:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2024/04/03/seafarer-death-benefits-rule-who-gets-paid-after-bigamy/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T08:02:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2024/05/13/carry-over-irrevocability-rule-why-tax-refund-choices-matter/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:59:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2024/11/26/authorized-receipt-rule-void-bir-tax-assessments-in-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:56:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2024/08/07/zero-rated-sales-proof-why-vat-refunds-fail-in-ph/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:54:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2024/11/05/ofw-oec-restraint-rule-sss-coverage-stays-travel-bar-falls/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:51:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2024/11/04/boundary-dispute-first-rule-when-cities-must-go-to-sanggunian/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:49:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1978/11/20/clergy-office-ban-priests-cannot-be-municipal-mayors/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:46:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2003/07/10/overseas-voting-safeguards-sc-upholds-absentee-voting-law/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:41:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/12/15/subsequent-discrimination-doctrine-equal-pay-for-bsp-employees/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:35:24+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/11/27/public-funds-public-purpose-rule-private-gains-from-levy-funds-voided/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:23:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/07/01/dap-budget-control-doctrine-limits-on-public-fund-realignment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:20:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/03/15/cta-tax-relief-doctrine-challenging-bir-rulings-in-tax-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:16:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/11/09/legal-education-balance-limits-on-leb-power-over-law-schools/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:13:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/08/16/delegated-transport-police-power-valid-fines-for-road-safety/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:08:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/03/28/notice-and-hearing-rule-valid-rail-fare-hikes-in-ph/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:05:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/08/08/tax-assessment-prescription-when-birs-10-year-window-fails/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T07:02:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2024/10/08/hierarchy-of-courts-rule-why-direct-sc-petitions-can-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:59:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2024/08/05/paid-expropriation-rule-when-old-state-payment-defeats-land-title/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:56:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1975/11/28/public-land-proof-rule-why-land-claims-fail-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:46:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1980/01/22/candidate-due-process-rule-charges-cannot-bar-election-runs/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:43:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1982/05/31/judicial-impropriety-doctrine-private-deals-after-litigation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:40:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1988/06/27/inquiry-notice-in-partition-when-fraud-claims-prescribe-in-property-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:34:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1989/07/14/carp-just-compensation-rule-land-reform-upheld-payment-required/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:31:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1991/07/03/collation-before-partition-why-heirs-must-account-for-lifetime-gifts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:26:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1991/07/03/no-greater-title-rule-land-buyers-cannot-claim-excess-areas/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:23:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1991/05/14/pagcor-tax-supremacy-why-local-fees-cannot-block-gaming-operations/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:21:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1991/08/13/full-ownership-transfer-rule-when-land-grants-shift-control/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:18:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1991/08/12/cement-tax-exemption-rule-why-local-business-taxes-still-apply/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:15:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1991/07/18/oil-price-regulation-rule-when-courts-defer-to-erb-decisions/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:13:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1993/03/02/unclassified-public-land-rule-why-possession-cannot-create-title/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:10:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1994/11/09/sheriff-ministerial-duty-when-execution-exceeds-court-authority/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:07:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1996/09/09/recorded-mining-claims-when-land-registration-still-prevails/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T06:05:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1998/11/27/deemed-admissions-in-property-cases-when-silence-defeats-a-claim/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:59:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2001/01/29/small-property-owner-exemption-urban-land-expropriation-limits/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:54:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2001/06/19/express-gambling-franchise-rule-why-pagcor-could-not-run-jai-alai/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:51:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/07/06/pcgg-jurisdiction-limit-corporate-acts-need-proper-standing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:47:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/06/08/1945-possession-rule-why-37-years-was-not-enough-for-land-title/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:45:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/09/20/fraudulent-free-patent-rule-when-torrens-title-can-be-cancelled/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:41:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/05/09/real-property-tax-penalty-cap-when-lgus-must-refund-excess-charges/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:39:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/03/31/best-evidence-tax-rule-when-bir-assessments-need-proof/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:36:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/04/15/senior-citizen-discount-tax-credit-when-a-deduction-is-not-enough/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:33:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/11/25/presidential-reservation-rule-when-public-land-cannot-be-titled/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:31:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/04/27/infrastructure-tro-ban-limits-on-blocking-public-projects/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:29:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2006/09/26/void-duplicate-title-rule-when-torrens-protection-fails/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:26:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2006/05/05/carp-compensation-rule-when-land-reform-titles-can-be-challenged/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:23:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/07/27/prospective-compensation-rule-expropriation-payment-limits/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:18:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/10/18/gross-receipts-tax-rule-why-banks-cannot-deduct-withheld-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:16:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/11/22/torrens-title-possession-rule-winning-ejectment-in-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:13:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/10/26/torrens-title-laches-rule-when-land-titles-survive-reversion/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:11:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/07/06/publication-before-collection-local-tax-ordinance-enforcement-rule/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:09:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/02/12/accrual-deduction-rule-when-tax-expenses-must-be-claimed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:06:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/04/14/expropriation-interest-accession-who-gets-bank-interest/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:04:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/04/18/no-automatic-award-rule-bot-proponents-must-prove-clear-rights/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T05:01:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/07/04/tax-refund-choice-rule-blank-itr-boxes-do-not-defeat-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:58:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/11/18/local-government-code-criteria-rule-cityhood-laws-struck-down/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:55:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/12/23/alienable-land-proof-rule-why-possession-alone-cannot-secure-title/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:53:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/07/30/pawnshop-tax-classification-rule-vat-relief-but-dst-liability/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:50:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/04/16/immediate-payment-rule-in-expropriation-when-possession-is-mandatory/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:48:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/01/20/tax-exemption-finality-rule-real-property-tax-liability-in-ph/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:45:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/08/19/land-registration-evidence-rule-when-possession-defeats-state-opposition/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:43:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/10/27/prior-public-hearing-rule-when-lgu-charges-become-void/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:41:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/07/30/carrier-courtesy-rule-passenger-abuse-creates-airline-liability/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:38:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/05/21/no-assessment-tax-evasion-rule-when-bir-can-prosecute-first/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:36:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/03/13/free-patent-reconveyance-deadline-when-land-claims-come-too-late/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:33:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/08/04/tax-amnesty-for-dst-deficiency-when-tax-liability-is-cancelled/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:31:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/11/15/incontrovertible-land-classification-rule-in-philippine-land-registration/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:28:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/09/15/co-heir-repudiation-rule-when-land-prescription-starts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:26:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/06/23/alluvial-accretion-ownership-when-creekside-land-becomes-private/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:23:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/06/28/beneficial-trust-tax-refund-rule-when-title-is-not-tax-ownership/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:21:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/09/01/dar-valuation-formula-rule-just-compensation-in-carp-land-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:18:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/11/28/alienable-land-proof-rule-why-long-possession-is-not-enough/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:16:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/03/16/insurance-renewal-dst-rule-when-life-policies-trigger-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:13:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/09/07/temperate-advocacy-rule-when-harsh-pleadings-become-contempt/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:11:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/07/25/sheriff-notice-rule-when-execution-errors-delay-property-recovery/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:08:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/03/05/tax-assessment-inaction-rule-taxpayer-appeal-options/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:06:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/03/21/tcc-good-faith-transferee-rule-when-tax-credits-pay-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:03:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/02/20/patrimonial-declaration-rule-why-tax-declarations-alone-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T04:01:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/02/22/revoked-agency-rule-when-property-managers-must-account/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:59:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/10/11/simulated-sale-doctrine-when-a-deed-cannot-defeat-true-ownership/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:56:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/04/10/coco-levy-public-fund-doctrine-why-special-taxes-need-coa-audit/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:53:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/09/19/prospective-tax-rules-why-old-bir-regulations-still-control/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:51:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/06/13/land-registration-proof-rule-why-tax-declarations-are-not-enough-2/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:48:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/04/17/same-evidence-rule-when-ejectment-cases-become-forum-shopping/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:46:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/09/23/void-marriage-co-ownership-property-partition-after-annulment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:43:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/01/22/transitional-input-vat-credit-when-taxpayers-can-claim-without-prior-vat/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:41:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/07/07/forged-deed-rule-when-a-land-sale-transfers-no-title/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:38:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/11/19/real-property-vat-credit-rule-when-land-counts-as-goods/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:36:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/11/12/torrens-possession-rule-why-registered-owners-win-ejectment-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:33:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/11/24/unlawful-detainer-pleading-rule-faster-recovery-of-property/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:30:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/11/24/real-property-tax-validity-rule-when-taxpayers-may-go-to-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:28:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/02/19/regalian-doctrine-proof-rule-land-registration-denied/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:26:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/06/04/vat-refund-timing-rule-when-early-cta-appeals-still-survive/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:23:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/11/24/tax-evasion-by-expenditure-method-when-wealth-triggers-prosecution/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:21:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/08/05/assurance-fund-claims-when-risky-land-deals-lose-protection/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:18:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/03/11/public-use-withdrawal-rule-when-expropriation-must-stop/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:16:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/08/02/sheriff-ministerial-duty-rule-execution-sales-must-follow-court-orders/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:13:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/11/29/fez-tax-immunity-rule-when-tax-regulations-go-too-far/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:11:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/08/10/bare-tolerance-rule-why-ejectment-requires-proof-of-permission/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:08:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/01/13/no-consideration-no-sale-void-property-deals-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:06:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/03/15/fraudulent-free-patent-reversion-when-land-titles-can-still-fall/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:03:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/12/13/assessed-value-jurisdiction-rule-in-property-recovery-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T03:00:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/06/28/title-location-rule-who-collects-local-taxes-in-boundary-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:58:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/12/14/torrens-title-reliance-rule-why-registered-land-buyers-prevail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:55:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/10/17/local-tax-ordinance-appeals-when-city-tax-hikes-exceed-lgc-limits/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:53:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/02/12/cta-tax-jurisdiction-rule-why-tax-injunctions-belong-in-the-cta/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:50:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/04/24/legitimate-corporate-expense-audit-when-sale-proceeds-are-exhausted/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:48:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/03/14/12030-day-vat-refund-rule-why-timing-can-defeat-tax-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:44:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/10/09/regalian-presumption-rule-public-land-claims-in-philippine-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:42:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/10/02/assessed-value-rule-why-property-cases-get-dismissed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:39:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/07/01/complaint-allegations-rule-rtc-jurisdiction-in-land-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:36:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/02/27/educational-tax-exemption-sc-protects-nonprofit-schools/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:34:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/09/11/boundary-dispute-rule-why-forcible-entry-cannot-decide-land-titles/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:31:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/03/04/bot-tax-exemption-rule-when-lgus-can-collect-real-property-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:29:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/10/15/operative-fact-tax-reliance-when-invalid-tax-laws-still-matter/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:26:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/11/03/notarized-document-presumption-winning-property-disputes-in-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:24:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/09/09/statute-of-frauds-ratification-oral-land-deals-can-bind/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:21:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/07/07/project-office-tax-situs-when-lgus-can-share-business-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:18:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/01/12/tax-garnishment-due-process-when-lgus-cannot-freeze-public-funds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:16:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/07/04/builder-in-bad-faith-rule-when-landowners-must-reimburse-improvements/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:14:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/01/24/good-faith-residency-rule-when-comelec-cannot-cancel-a-coc/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:11:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/04/24/tax-assessment-service-rule-faulty-bir-notices-are-void/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:08:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/02/13/foreclosure-jurisdiction-rule-why-assessed-value-matters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:06:08+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2024/01/22/inverse-condemnation-deposit-rule-why-zonal-value-controls/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T02:03:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2024/02/26/void-local-tax-assessment-when-lgus-must-refund-paid-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:59:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2000/11/29/franchise-non-delegation-pagcor-cannot-expand-jai-alai-powers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:57:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/04/26/tax-compromise-finality-when-bir-settlements-bind-the-government/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:53:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/08/24/friar-land-approval-rule-why-old-possession-cannot-save-a-void-title/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:43:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/03/16/carp-exemption-by-prior-reclassification-when-land-is-beyond-dar/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:41:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1998/04/21/comelec-airtime-rule-when-broadcast-franchises-must-serve-elections/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:38:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/12/21/good-faith-tcc-transferee-rule-when-tax-credits-count-as-paid/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:34:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/03/17/fraudulent-free-patent-reconveyance-when-land-title-can-be-recovered/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:30:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/08/22/tax-declaration-ownership-rule-why-trial-must-come-first/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:27:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1979/10/18/just-compensation-valuation-when-expropriation-value-is-fixed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:23:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1981/09/10/equitable-appeal-perfection-when-one-day-should-not-defeat-justice/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:19:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1990/08/30/public-land-jurisdiction-rule-when-courts-cannot-quiet-title/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:15:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1992/02/25/eminent-domain-possession-rule-when-government-may-enter-land/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:12:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1992/09/02/reserve-deficiency-tax-rule-when-banks-must-pay-both-tax-and-penalty/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:10:03+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1993/06/17/unauthorized-law-practice-why-legal-clinics-need-lawyers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:07:38+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1993/05/13/cadastral-finality-rule-why-old-land-claims-can-be-lost/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:04:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1994/10/26/ancient-document-rule-when-old-deeds-still-lose-land-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T01:01:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1995/03/10/actual-market-value-mineral-tax-how-mining-taxes-are-computed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:58:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2000/10/12/co-owner-no-prescription-rule-partition-rights-survive-delay/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:55:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2000/10/10/vfa-treaty-concurrence-rule-when-foreign-pacts-bind-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:51:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2001/12/18/strict-tax-amnesty-rule-why-pending-tax-cases-bar-relief/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:46:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/09/01/peza-tax-refund-rule-when-zone-supplies-escape-customs-duties/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:42:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/10/13/tax-refund-proof-rule-why-missing-returns-defeat-refund-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:40:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/06/29/zero-rated-services-vat-refunds-for-philippine-export-services/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:37:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/07/29/express-tax-exemption-rule-limits-on-freeport-duty-free-privileges/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:33:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/04/29/assessed-value-jurisdiction-rule-where-land-possession-cases-belong/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:31:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/07/17/universal-charge-police-power-rule-why-epira-fees-survived/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:27:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/03/27/deed-validity-presumption-when-property-sales-defeat-heir-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:25:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/07/21/strict-tax-imposition-when-bir-rules-exceed-the-tax-code/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:22:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/12/23/public-duty-injury-rule-when-taxpayers-cannot-sue-bir-officials/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:19:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/09/25/land-registration-proof-rule-tax-receipts-do-not-prove-ownership/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:17:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/12/14/taxpayer-standing-citizens-may-sue-over-public-contracts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:14:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/09/18/hmo-dst-exemption-rule-when-health-plans-are-not-insurance/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:12:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/02/25/statutory-taxpayer-refund-rule-who-may-claim-excise-tax-refunds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:09:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/12/08/pan-due-process-rule-void-bir-tax-assessments-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:06:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/10/13/tax-evasion-completion-rule-fraudulent-returns-can-trigger-prosecution/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:04:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/07/28/dst-refund-proof-rule-why-tax-refund-claims-need-clear-evidence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-19T00:01:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/08/04/equitable-mortgage-rule-when-a-sale-is-really-a-loan-security/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:59:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/01/26/vat-refund-proof-rule-why-missing-returns-can-defeat-tax-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:56:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/09/26/tax-amnesty-qualification-when-deficiency-taxes-are-fully-settled/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:53:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/11/20/military-reservation-land-rule-void-titles-revert-to-the-state/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:51:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/11/26/wrong-address-tax-assessments-when-bir-notices-are-void/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:48:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/09/16/tax-refund-withdrawal-rule-when-cta-appeals-cannot-be-abandoned/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:46:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/04/20/tax-amnesty-for-documentary-stamp-tax-what-banks-can-claim/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:43:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/04/19/tax-abatement-termination-letter-when-bir-relief-becomes-final/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:41:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/01/10/local-tax-ordinance-challenges-why-procedure-can-defeat-tax-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:39:06+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/08/09/free-patent-nullity-when-torrens-title-cannot-defeat-prior-ownership/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:36:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/10/03/tax-due-process-rule-when-bir-assessments-become-void/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:34:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/12/04/benevolent-neutrality-rule-when-state-recognition-is-not-endorsement/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:31:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/08/14/dividend-tax-refund-rule-foreign-investors-can-sue-for-overpaid-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:28:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/07/28/club-dues-tax-rule-when-membership-fees-are-not-income-or-vat/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:26:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/08/26/association-standing-rule-why-multiple-court-challenges-can-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:23:46+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/12/01/constructive-delivery-of-land-when-sale-documents-prove-ownership/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:20:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/07/06/written-stipulation-sale-expenses-rule-sc-on-property-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:17:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/07/06/representative-office-tax-rule-when-foreign-offices-avoid-vat/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:14:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/04/26/capital-goods-vat-amortization-sc-limits-zero-rated-vat-refunds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:12:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/07/11/hierarchy-of-courts-rule-why-direct-supreme-court-petitions-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:09:48+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/08/09/registered-owner-notice-rule-void-tax-sales-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:07:07+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1990/12/26/final-judgment-bar-why-old-property-claims-cannot-be-refiled/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:03:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2000/03/07/possession-first-rule-why-registered-owners-can-win-ejectment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T23:00:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/09/30/unregistered-land-sale-rule-why-recording-protects-property-rights/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:57:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/06/25/good-faith-expropriation-rule-socialized-housing-limits/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:54:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/04/19/torrens-reconstitution-proof-rule-when-lost-title-claims-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:50:13+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1990/12/18/provisional-oil-price-hikes-when-erb-may-act-without-prior-hearing/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:46:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1992/05/21/patent-ambiguity-rule-when-land-sale-papers-fail-in-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:44:32+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1992/05/08/private-land-exhaustion-rule-courts-may-hear-ownership-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:42:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1992/12/11/accretion-boundary-rule-riverfront-land-wins-in-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:39:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1994/06/17/tax-declarations-plus-possession-winning-land-claims-in-ph/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:37:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2001/06/20/public-land-standing-rule-when-private-reconveyance-fails/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:33:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2002/10/04/watershed-reservation-rule-why-possession-cannot-ripen-into-title/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:28:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2003/10/24/tax-exemption-non-delegation-rule-why-john-hay-incentives-fell/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:24:56+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2007/08/09/tax-refund-fairness-rule-when-bir-must-return-excess-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:19:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/06/27/actual-possession-reconveyance-rule-when-land-claims-do-not-expire/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:17:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/07/28/nemo-dat-in-property-sales-why-bad-title-defeats-buyer-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:14:54+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/02/12/possession-plus-tax-declaration-winning-philippine-land-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:12:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/07/27/tolerated-occupancy-rule-why-possession-alone-may-not-win-land/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:09:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/10/23/public-land-prescription-rule-why-tax-declarations-are-not-enough/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:07:01+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/11/19/tax-refund-against-bir-why-employers-are-not-the-proper-target/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:04:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/02/04/cta-certiorari-power-where-local-tax-disputes-must-be-fought/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T22:01:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/01/14/tax-treaty-refund-rule-bir-prior-filing-cannot-defeat-relief/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:59:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/03/25/land-registration-proof-rule-why-tax-declarations-are-not-enough/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:56:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/08/03/share-redemption-tax-rule-when-preferred-shares-are-not-dividends/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:54:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/04/04/void-free-patent-rule-when-torrens-title-does-not-prove-ownership/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:51:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/08/09/foreclosure-possession-rule-when-buyers-can-recover-property/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:48:58+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/12/01/tax-regulation-ultra-vires-rule-when-bir-rules-go-too-far/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:46:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/07/20/tax-mootness-rule-repealed-vat-rules-can-end-tax-litigation/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:43:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/07/13/holding-company-tax-rule-passive-dividends-are-not-local-business-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:40:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1975/08/29/bar-exam-integrity-rule-unauthorized-rechecks-can-cost-a-law-license/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:37:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1992/01/27/agrarian-ejectment-non-retroactivity-tenant-rights-and-landowner-risk/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:33:21+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/12/08/mortgage-lien-survival-rule-when-foreclosure-still-proceeds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:30:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/11/29/denr-land-remedy-rule-why-courts-dismiss-premature-land-cases/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:26:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/08/02/public-land-registration-proof-rule-why-cenro-papers-are-not-enough/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:23:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1995/12/01/tax-exemption-rule-when-pioneer-firms-still-owe-philippine-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:20:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1992/08/06/prior-possession-rule-winning-ejectment-despite-ownership-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:11:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/07/14/business-tax-timing-rule-when-makati-must-refund-overpaid-local-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:09:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2006/04/18/possessory-ownership-rule-when-long-possession-defeats-torrens-title/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:06:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/11/27/corrected-cenro-certification-rule-saving-land-title-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:03:17+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/12/23/beneficial-use-tax-rule-who-pays-real-property-tax-in-ph/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T21:00:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2011/03/16/oral-partition-rule-when-family-land-division-prevails/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:58:09+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/09/05/local-franchise-tax-rule-why-nonprofit-utilities-may-still-pay/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:55:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/07/31/darab-jurisdiction-rule-cloa-cancellation-belongs-to-dar/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:53:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/03/24/patrimonial-land-rule-why-possession-alone-may-not-secure-title/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:50:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/02/26/accretion-registration-rule-when-claimed-river-land-stays-public/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:48:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/04/28/tax-injunction-bar-why-rtcs-cannot-stop-bir-tax-collection/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:45:18+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/11/15/title-specific-tax-exemption-rule-when-refund-claims-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:42:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/06/21/land-registration-renewal-rule-when-a-failed-title-case-can-be-refiled/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:40:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2003/03/05/unapproved-homestead-rule-no-title-no-partition-rights/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:36:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/09/08/void-reconstitution-rule-when-land-titles-cannot-defeat-prior-ownership/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:33:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/08/09/agrarian-security-of-tenure-when-farm-tenants-cannot-be-ejected/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:30:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/02/22/alienable-land-proof-rule-why-land-registration-can-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:28:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/04/15/co-owner-ejectment-rule-when-one-heir-can-recover-property/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:25:35+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/06/28/1945-possession-rule-why-land-title-claims-fail-in-court/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:23:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/02/18/tolerance-by-positive-acts-when-ejectment-claims-fail/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:20:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1993/06/08/npc-indirect-tax-exemption-rule-when-tax-benefits-shield-consumers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:08:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/09/01/excise-tax-refund-rule-when-importers-can-recover-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:05:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/12/07/direct-interest-rule-who-may-challenge-land-sale-contracts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:03:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/08/05/local-machinery-tax-rule-utility-assets-need-valid-assessment/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T20:00:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2002/01/31/grave-abuse-costs-rule-when-final-judgments-can-still-be-reopened/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:57:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/10/06/clear-tax-exemption-rule-when-franchise-clauses-fail-local-tax-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:51:25+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/09/26/hospital-tax-exemption-rule-when-charity-income-becomes-taxable/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:48:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/11/28/private-land-free-patent-rule-when-torrens-titles-can-be-cancelled/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:46:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/10/09/government-instrumentality-tax-shield-lrta-real-property-tax-exemption/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:43:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/07/18/pra-real-property-tax-exemption-why-reclaimed-lands-are-tax-free/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:39:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/06/16/local-fiscal-autonomy-rule-when-congress-cannot-divert-lgu-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:36:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/11/07/mwss-tax-exemption-rule-when-lgus-cannot-levy-property-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:33:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1991/05/31/npc-tax-exemption-rule-when-indirect-taxes-may-be-refunded/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:30:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1999/01/20/taxable-dividend-redemption-rule-when-stock-buybacks-become-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:24:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/08/03/safeguard-tariff-review-cta-jurisdiction-in-import-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:21:19+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/06/08/gross-receipts-tax-rule-banks-cannot-deduct-withholding-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:18:27+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/01/25/legal-interest-rule-who-may-protest-real-property-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:15:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/07/31/registration-decree-priority-why-land-titles-beat-tax-receipts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:13:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/06/06/initial-local-tax-implementation-rule-limits-on-city-tax-hikes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:10:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1996/08/29/tax-rulemaking-due-process-when-bir-circulars-become-invalid/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:07:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/11/28/taxable-retirement-benefits-when-labor-claims-meet-withholding-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:03:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/12/14/constructive-trust-in-land-titles-when-torrens-title-must-yield/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T19:01:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/01/22/cooperative-deposit-tax-exemption-sc-shields-member-interest-income/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:58:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/08/26/alienable-land-rule-when-long-possession-still-fails/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:55:47+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2003/04/09/local-franchise-tax-rule-when-lgus-may-tax-government-corporations/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:52:34+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2006/06/26/constructive-receipt-rule-when-bank-interest-becomes-taxable/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:49:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/04/16/petroleum-local-tax-ban-why-lgus-cannot-tax-fuel-sales/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:45:55+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/10/05/cooperative-property-tax-exemption-when-lgus-can-still-tax-machinery/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:43:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1994/01/27/zoning-classification-prevails-when-tax-declarations-lose/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:40:41+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/02/19/statutory-taxpayer-refund-rule-excise-tax-relief-for-fuel-sellers/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:38:10+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/08/24/right-of-way-standing-rule-when-land-possession-is-not-enough/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:35:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2015/06/22/forged-deed-good-title-rule-why-good-faith-buyers-win/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:32:44+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/11/14/regalian-presumption-rule-why-land-registration-failed/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:29:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2024/05/21/government-pocket-rule-why-lgus-cannot-tax-nfa-property/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:27:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1992/11/05/reserved-land-tax-exemption-when-public-land-is-not-taxable/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:24:30+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/06/29/charitable-property-tax-rule-when-nonprofits-still-pay-rpt/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:21:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2012/04/25/buyer-exemption-rule-why-sellers-cannot-claim-excise-tax-refunds/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:18:50+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/12/19/immediate-payment-rule-in-expropriation-why-just-compensation-matters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:15:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2017/01/30/buyer-at-peril-doctrine-buying-unregistered-land-in-the-philippines/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:05:36+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1992/08/05/strength-of-title-rule-winning-philippine-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T18:02:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/11/04/loa-revalidation-rule-when-a-bir-audit-stands-despite-delay/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:55:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2024/08/13/renewable-energy-police-power-why-fit-charges-were-upheld/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:52:43+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2010/03/09/minimum-corporate-income-tax-rule-why-mcit-and-real-estate-cwt-stand/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:48:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2019/06/19/homestead-patent-fraud-when-a-land-title-can-be-voided/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:45:39+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2006/12/20/tax-declaration-alteration-rule-assessment-changes-can-become-graft/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:42:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2003/03/25/strict-tax-exemption-rule-why-pldt-lost-its-local-tax-claim/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:29:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1991/12/02/withholding-agent-refund-rule-when-companies-can-recover-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:25:29+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1998/10/14/rental-income-taxability-rule-when-nonprofits-still-owe-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:22:53+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/08/04/local-business-tax-double-taxation-when-cities-cannot-tax-twice/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:19:40+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/04/30/pollution-control-tax-exemption-actual-use-rule-for-realty-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:17:14+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/11/09/educational-tax-exemption-rule-when-school-revenues-avoid-tax/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:14:49+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/05/03/tax-fraud-assessment-due-process-when-bir-assessments-become-void/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:12:12+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1995/10/30/vat-constitutionality-rule-why-tax-laws-survive-broad-attacks/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:08:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/10/02/pay-under-protest-rule-challenging-realty-tax-assessments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:05:05+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/05/30/submarine-cable-tax-rule-when-lgus-may-tax-network-assets/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:02:33+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/06/30/tax-declarations-as-possession-proof-in-property-disputes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T17:00:02+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2006/09/27/gross-receipts-tax-rule-why-withheld-tax-still-counts/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:57:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/10/11/actual-use-assessment-rule-real-property-tax-limits-in-ph/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:54:28+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/08/17/nunc-pro-tunc-partition-fixing-omitted-property-in-final-judgments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:51:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2023/02/22/business-permit-fee-rule-tax-exemption-is-not-permit-exemption/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:49:04+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1987/04/30/boac-source-of-income-rule-philippine-ticket-sales-are-taxable/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:45:31+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2018/06/27/local-business-tax-double-taxation-when-lgus-must-refund-excess-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:41:45+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2013/07/03/local-business-double-taxation-when-manila-taxes-must-be-refunded/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:39:20+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2008/08/20/tax-classification-freeze-excise-tax-rules-survive-review/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:36:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2005/08/16/tax-compromise-acquittal-rule-why-sc-protected-final-judgments/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:33:11+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2016/01/11/offline-carrier-tax-treaty-rule-air-canada-refund-denied/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:29:59+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2022/06/28/government-instrumentality-tax-immunity-lrta-real-property-tax-rule/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:27:22+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2009/04/15/tax-classification-freeze-rule-when-sin-taxes-survive-challenge/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:24:16+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2003/06/10/gross-receipts-without-deduction-tax-refund-rule-for-banks/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:21:52+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1994/10/03/tax-classification-deference-why-snit-survived-sc-review/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:18:15+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/1997/10/16/prescription-over-succession-how-possession-can-defeat-title-claims/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T16:15:42+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/05/05/real-property-tax-revision-rule-when-lgu-assessments-stand/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T15:44:51+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2020/09/09/most-favored-nation-proof-rule-tax-treaty-refunds-need-evidence/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T15:42:26+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2014/07/30/local-business-tax-double-taxation-when-manila-must-refund-taxes/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T15:39:57+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2021/12/07/no-tax-without-statute-pogo-tax-ruling-and-why-it-matters/</loc>
				<lastmod>2026-05-18T15:37:37+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2004/04/26/rmo-no-27-2004-refund-procedure-for-accredited-agent-banks-over-remittance-of-bir-tax-collections/</loc>
				<lastmod>2004-04-26T10:00:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url>	<url>
				<loc>https://www.makatilawfirm.com/2002/10/28/when-a-child-victims-testimony-is-enough-to-convict-but-the-penalty-must-stay-within-the-charge/</loc>
				<lastmod>2002-10-28T10:00:00+08:00</lastmod>
				
			</url></urlset>