Court Delay Complaints Need Proof, Not Suspicion Alone

Court delay may justify an administrative complaint, but misconduct must be proven and prosecuted. Suspicion and nonappearance can lead to dismissal. A litigant who believes a judge delayed a case or favored the other side may file an administrative complaint, but delay alone will not prove misconduct. The practical lesson from the Espinas ruling is […]

Judicial Delay Complaints Need Proof of Bad Faith, Not Frustration With the Court

A judge is not administratively liable for delay, exhibit management, or encouraging family compromise absent proof of bad faith, coercion, or misconduct. A judge is not administratively liable for delay, strict courtroom management, or efforts to settle a family dispute unless the complainant proves misconduct, bad faith, coercion, or abuse of authority. For litigants, the […]

Crushed Stone Is Not a Mineral Product for Sales Tax Exemption

Crushed rocks used for construction are not exempt mineral products, so quarry operators may owe sales tax and must observe strict refund appeal deadlines. Quarry operators cannot claim a sales tax exemption for crushed rocks merely by calling them mineral products. Where the stone is used for road foundation, cement aggregate, building, or construction purposes, […]

When a City License Fee Becomes an Illegal Tax on Surety Companies

A city may regulate surety companies, but it cannot impose an annual license fee beyond its charter limit. Excess local charges may be challenged and refunded. A local government may require businesses to secure permits, but it cannot disguise an excessive annual tax as a mere license or permit fee when its own charter sets […]

Newly Discovered Evidence Can Reopen a Criminal Conviction When It Casts Serious Doubt on Guilt

Newly discovered evidence may reopen a criminal conviction when it raises serious doubt on guilt and was unavailable at trial without the accusedโ€™s fault. A criminal conviction is not necessarily the final word when later evidence shows that the judgment may have rested on an incomplete record. In People v. Gensola, the Supreme Court applied […]