An Acquittal Cannot Be Repackaged as Certiorari: Why the State Usually Gets No Second Chance After a Criminal Dismissal

A merits-based acquittal cannot be revived through certiorari when review would place the accused in double jeopardy, even if the trial court may have erred. A criminal case that has already ended in an acquittal generally cannot be revived by calling the government’s challenge a petition for certiorari. When a trial court dismisses a charge […]

When a Regulatory Appeal Goes Dormant: Why Courts Will Not Decide Business Disputes After the Issue Has Disappeared

A dormant challenge to PAL’s provisional authority was dismissed after operations ceased and the petitioner failed to oppose dismissal, leaving no live controversy. A party challenging a government permit or provisional operating authority must actively preserve a live controversy. When the disputed business operation has already ended, years have passed without action, and the challenger […]

When a Tax Assessment Comes Too Late: Prescription Can Defeat the BIR’s 25% Surtax on Accumulated Profits

A late BIR assessment for accumulated surplus was cancelled because prescription had set in, and fraud could not be presumed to extend the assessment period. A corporation may defeat a tax assessment when the BIR acts beyond the legally allowed assessment period, even if the government later insists that the corporation improperly accumulated profits to […]

When Stock Certificates Are Frozen by the SEC, Documentary Stamp Tax May Have to Wait

The Supreme Court held that SEC-restricted stock certificates are not yet subject to documentary stamp tax until shareholders can exercise ownership rights. Corporations do not automatically owe documentary stamp tax on every stock certificate merely because it has been printed or deposited with a regulator. For documentary stamp tax on an original issue of stock […]

Not Every Postponement Is Legal Malpractice: Why Proof Still Matters in Complaints Against Lawyers

Lawyer discipline for case delay requires proof. The Court dismissed a malpractice complaint where postponements were explained, corroborated, and court-approved. Clients and opposing parties may complain when a lawyer appears to delay a case, but delay alone is not professional misconduct. The controlling lesson is the evidence-based discipline doctrine: a lawyer cannot be sanctioned for […]

A Complaint Against a Judge Can Collapse When the Complainant Takes Back the Charge

A judicial misconduct complaint may fail when the complainant’s own testimony retracts the charge and leaves no factual basis for discipline. Judicial misconduct complaints must stand on proof, not suspicion, anger, or later-withdrawn accusations. For ordinary litigants, the doctrine is practical and sobering: a complaint against a judge may be dismissed when the complainant’s own […]