When a Missed Appeal Is Not Enough to Discipline a Lawyer

A missed appeal does not automatically prove lawyer misconduct. Discipline requires convincing evidence, especially where the client consented and appeal appeared futile. A client who loses a case cannot automatically convert that loss into a disciplinary case against counsel merely by saying that an appeal should have been filed. In lawyer discipline, the complainant must […]

When a Strike Ends, the Court May End the Case Too: Mootness in Labor Picketing Disputes

Strike-related injunction challenges may be dismissed as moot once the underlying strike is resolved, leaving picketing and property-rights issues undecided. A labor case can disappear before the court ever decides who was right: when the strike that produced the injunction has already been resolved, a petition questioning that injunction may be dismissed as moot and […]

Minor Pleading Defects Do Not Prove Lawyer Misconduct Without Prejudice or Deceit

A procedural defect in an ejectment complaint did not justify discipline absent proof of deceit, prejudice, or bad faith by counsel. Not every procedural defect in a court filing becomes a disciplinary offense. A party who loses a case cannot convert ordinary pleading objections into a disbarment case unless the record shows actual deceit, bad […]

A Judge Cannot Sign Away Property Rights Without Checking the Record

A judge was fined for deciding a cadastral land case without properly checking the record, showing why diligence matters in property and title disputes. Judges who decide land registration and cadastral claims must personally verify the record before issuing a decision that can affect ownership and title. A judge may not excuse an erroneous or […]

When a Client Withdraws a Complaint, a Lawyer Still Must Answer the Court

A lawyer was reprimanded for ignoring a Supreme Court directive despite personal hardship and possible withdrawal of the complaint by the client. A lawyer cannot ignore a Supreme Court directive merely because the opposing party appears willing to drop the case. Once the Court requires a lawyer to explain or file a comment, that duty […]

When an Appellant Dies and His Heirs Lose Interest, the Appeal Dies Too

An appeal may be dismissed as moot when the appellant dies and heirs no longer wish to pursue it, ending the case without a ruling on the merits. An appeal may be dismissed as moot when the appellant has died and the heirs who would inherit the litigation interest are no longer willing to pursue […]

When Local Governments Can Tax Your Business Without Violating Due Process

The Supreme Court upheld Tanauan’s soft drink tax, confirming broad local taxing power while preserving due process limits against arbitrary or confiscatory taxes. Local governments may impose business taxes within their delegated taxing authority even when the same business activity is already affected by another tax, so long as the ordinance stays within statutory limits, […]