DOJ Prosecutors May Use a Higher Screening Standard Before Filing Criminal Cases

The Supreme Court upheld the DOJ’s 2024 preliminary investigation rules, allowing prosecutors to require prima facie evidence with reasonable certainty of conviction. People facing criminal complaints before prosecutors may now invoke a more demanding screening standard at the preliminary investigation stage: the DOJ’s 2024 rules requiring prima facie evidence with reasonable certainty of conviction remain […]

Private Complainants Can Challenge Acquittals Only Through the State β€” and Even Then, Double Jeopardy Sets a High Wall

Private complainants may challenge the criminal aspect with prosecutor conformity, but acquittals after demurrer stand absent grave abuse or denial of due process. A private complainant who loses a criminal case after a demurrer to evidence cannot simply relitigate the acquittal by arguing that the trial court weighed the evidence incorrectly. The practical rule is […]

Taxpayers Need Not Post a Billion-Peso Bond to Stop an Illegal Tax Collection

The Supreme Court held that the CTA may stop an illegal BIR collection without requiring a bond when the assessment or collection remedy is void. A taxpayer facing a disputed BIR assessment may ask the Court of Tax Appeals to stop collection without posting a cash deposit or surety bond when the assessment or the […]

Tax Refunds Cannot Be Defeated by Unappealed Deficiency Assessments Alone

A taxpayer’s proven income tax refund cannot be defeated by separate deficiency assessments unless the BIR proves them through proper evidence and procedure. A taxpayer who proves that an income tax refund is due cannot be denied that refund merely because the BIR points to separate deficiency tax assessments that were not properly appealed or […]

When BIR Changes Its Mind, Taxpayers Who Relied in Good Faith Cannot Be Punished Retroactively

The Supreme Court held that a later BIR VAT ruling could not retroactively prejudice a taxpayer that relied in good faith on prior official rulings. Taxpayers who followed an existing BIR ruling in good faith may invoke the rule against retroactive tax prejudice when the government later changes its interpretation. For businesses, the ruling matters […]