Drug Convictions Can Fall When the Chain of Custody Breaks After Laboratory Testing

Drug convictions were reversed after gaps in the chain of custody left reasonable doubt on whether the shabu presented in court was the same evidence seized. Accused persons in drug cases may be acquitted even after a buy-bust operation, laboratory confirmation, and prior conviction when the prosecution cannot prove every critical handoff of the seized […]

Cyber Libel Must Be Filed Within One Year From Discovery, Not Fifteen Years

Cyber libel prescribes in one year from discovery, while unsigned Supreme Court resolutions bind only parties and do not create precedent. People accused of cyber libel now have a clearer prescription defense: even if the allegedly defamatory statement was posted online, the criminal case must still be commenced within one year from discovery by the […]

Customs Smuggling Charges Fail When Prosecutors Cannot Prove Importation

The tax court acquitted an importer in a customs smuggling case after prosecutors failed to prove that the alleged cigarette shipment was actually imported. Importers and customs brokers facing criminal smuggling charges should closely examine whether the prosecution can prove the first and most basic fact: that the goods were actually imported into the Philippines. […]

Wrong Appeal Mode Can Still Threaten Criminal Tax Cases Despite a Timely Notice of Appeal

Criminal tax appeals from RTC original jurisdiction require a timely notice of appeal, not a petition for review; the wrong remedy was denied. Parties in criminal tax cases must choose the correct appeal route immediately after an RTC ruling, because a petition for review is not the proper remedy when the RTC acted in its […]

Using Another Name on a Government ID Can Trigger Falsification and Alias Charges

Using another name in a government ID may support falsification and illegal alias charges even without proof of private injury or business use. A person who uses a name different from the name appearing in the civil registry may face criminal prosecution even without proof that someone was financially damaged. The decisive point is not […]

When a Tax Evasion Case Is Dismissed, the Supreme Court Will Not Decide Moot Procedural Battles

Supreme Court held that a dismissed tax evasion case moots pending procedural challenges unless a recognized exception to mootness applies. A taxpayer or corporate officer who already obtained a final dismissal of a tax evasion case generally cannot still ask the Supreme Court to rule on earlier procedural objections in that same criminal case. The […]

Forest Land Cases Still Require Proof Beyond Reasonable Doubt, Even for Special-Law Offenses

The Supreme Court acquitted Isican, holding that malum prohibitum forest land offenses still require proof of voluntary commission beyond reasonable doubt. People accused of unlawfully occupying forest land cannot be convicted merely because the offense is classified as malum prohibitum. The prosecution must still prove, beyond reasonable doubt, that the accused consciously and voluntarily committed […]

Ransom Money Need Not Be Produced in Court to Prove Kidnapping for Ransom

The Supreme Court affirmed kidnapping-for-ransom convictions, holding that ransom demand may be proven even without presenting the actual money in court. Victims of kidnapping for ransom do not lose their case merely because the actual ransom money was not presented in court, lost in custody, or no longer physically available. What matters is whether the […]

When a Lawyerโ€™s Absences Put a Clientโ€™s Liberty at Risk, Neglect Becomes a Serious Professional Offense

A lawyerโ€™s repeated absences in a criminal case amounted to gross negligence, leading to a five-year suspension for putting the clientโ€™s liberty at risk. A client facing a criminal charge is entitled to more than a lawyerโ€™s name on the pleadings; counsel must appear, act, update the client, and protect the defense with real diligence. […]

Cash Shortages Can Convict Accountable Officers Even Without Direct Proof of Pocketing the Money

Accountable officers may be convicted for malversation when public funds are received, audited short, demanded, and left unexplained without direct proof of personal use. Public officers who collect or hold government funds cannot defeat a malversation charge merely by saying there is no direct proof that they personally spent the missing money. Once the prosecution […]