When a Stock Trading Dispute Belongs in Regular Court, Not a Special Commercial Court

The Supreme Court held that an investor’s unauthorized-trading claim against a broker is an ordinary civil action, not automatically an intra-corporate case. Investors who sue a securities broker for unauthorized trades, missing funds, or the return of shares are not automatically dragged into special commercial court procedure simply because the dispute involves stocks. If the […]

When a Stock Broker Fails to Deliver Shares, Clients Can Demand Their Money Back

Brokerage clients may rescind and recover payment when stock certificates are not delivered; pledged assets cannot be sold before the debt is liquidated. A brokerage client who pays for shares but never receives the stock certificates is not trapped waiting indefinitely for delivery: the client may rescind the transaction and recover the purchase price with […]

You Cannot File a Derivative Suit Unless You First Prove You Are a Stockholder

A derivative suit fails if the claimant cannot prove stockholder status at the time of the disputed corporate acts, even where fraud is alleged. Serious accusations of fraud, mismanagement, and dissipation of corporate assets will not be heard through a derivative suit unless the person suing first proves the most basic requirement: that he or […]