A Mistaken Death Certificate Does Not Stop a Living Property Owner From Filing Ejectment

A mistaken death certificate does not bar a living owner from filing ejectment when courts can provisionally decide capacity and possession. A person wrongly recorded as dead in the civil registry may still sue to recover possession of property if the court is satisfied, for purposes of the ejectment case, that he is alive and […]

When an Unlisted Witness Cannot Save the Prosecution’s Case

The Supreme Court acquitted an accused after excluding an unlisted substitute eyewitness, stressing that pre-trial orders bind criminal trials. Criminal defendants can now rely more firmly on a practical trial safeguard: if the prosecution fails to list a witness during pre-trial, that witness may be excluded unless the State gives a specific, legally sufficient reason […]

Grenade Evidence Must Survive Chain of Custody: Why a Valid Arrest Still Does Not Guarantee Conviction

A valid hot-pursuit arrest did not save an explosives conviction where police failed to prove chain of custody, but robbery was affirmed on credible eyewitness testimony. A criminal conviction can survive a warrantless hot-pursuit arrest and still fail if the prosecution cannot prove that the seized physical evidence was preserved, identified, and accounted for from […]

Quieting Title Best Evidence Rule: Why Original Deeds Matter

Quieting title requires proof of ownership and original evidence; photocopies cannot defeat a proven deed and better property claim. The Quieting Title Best Evidence Rule is a practical warning for property owners: a Torrens title, photocopied documents, and late-discovered papers will not automatically defeat a buyer who can prove a valid sale, possession of original […]

When Police Skip the Drug Evidence Safeguards, Conviction Cannot Stand

The Supreme Court acquitted an accused in a drug case because police failed to justify serious chain-of-custody lapses under RA 9165. Drug convictions cannot rest on police testimony alone when the prosecution fails to account for the seized drugs through the safeguards required by law. The ruling reinforces a doctrine that matters far beyond narcotics […]

A Notarized Document Is Not Automatically Safe: When Faulty Notarization Can Destroy Trust in Evidence

Faulty notarization can expose a lawyer-notary to suspension and may undermine documents signed without personal appearance, identity proof, or voluntariness. A notarized document carries legal weight because the law treats it as public evidence, but that same power imposes strict duties on the notary. A lawyer-notary who notarizes a document without the personal appearance of […]

Can a Litigant Be Ordered to Produce Income Tax Returns in a Civil Case?

A taxpayer claiming lost income may be ordered to produce ITRs; broad tax confidentiality claims and improper Rule 65 remedies will not stop trial evidence. A taxpayer who puts lost income at issue in a civil case may not automatically defeat a court order to produce personal income tax returns by invoking tax confidentiality. When […]

Corporate Officers Are Not Personally Liable for Company Debts Without Bad Faith

Directors are not personally liable for corporate debts without proof of bad faith, fraud, unlawful assent, or personal participation in the wrongful act. Corporate directors and officers are not automatically personally liable for a corporation’s unpaid obligations merely because they signed, supervised, or were named in a lawsuit involving the company. Personal liability requires a […]

Deed Validity Presumption: When Property Sales Defeat Heir Claims

A notarized property sale stands unless heirs prove simulation with clear, strong evidence; hearsay affidavits and possession alone are insufficient. The Deed Validity Presumption protects buyers and registered owners when heirs later attack a notarized sale as simulated without clear, strong, and convincing proof. For families, property owners, and litigants in a property dispute SC […]