Drug Case Plea Bargaining Cannot Be Denied Just Because Two Charges Came From One Arrest

The Supreme Court held that two drug charges from one arrest do not automatically disqualify an accused from plea bargaining under the drug case framework. Accused persons in drug cases may not be denied plea bargaining simply because they face both sale and possession charges from the same police operation, when the Supreme Court’s own […]

Nuisance Candidate Rules Cannot Be Used to Remove Unknown or Underfunded Candidates Without Real Evidence

COMELEC cannot cancel a candidacy based on speculative voter confusion, weak machinery, or lack of early campaigning without substantial evidence of bad faith. A candidate cannot be removed from the ballot as a nuisance candidate merely because voters might associate his nickname with a past candidate, or because he is not politically famous, wealthy, media-visible, […]

Prosecutors Cannot Veto Drug Plea Bargains Without a Valid, Timely Reason

Prosecutors cannot block drug plea bargains by blanket DOJ policy alone; objections must be valid, timely, and raised before the trial court. Trial courts may approve plea bargaining in drug cases even over a prosecutor’s objection when the objection rests only on DOJ circulars inconsistent with the Supreme Court’s plea bargaining framework, and prosecutors who […]

Party-List Groups Can Lose Registration for Defying Final Seat Allocations

COMELEC may cancel a party-list group’s registration for defying final seat allocations, and HRET jurisdiction does not bar registration cases. A party-list organization may be removed from the ballot years after an election if it continues to benefit from a congressional seat that the final party-list allocation no longer allows. The practical consequence is blunt: […]

When Age Is Not Properly Proved, Rape Conviction May Stand but the Penalty Can Change

A rape conviction may stand on credible testimony, but statutory rape and harsher penalties require proper proof of the victim’s age. A rape conviction can survive even when the prosecution fails to prove the victim’s exact age, but the highest penalty cannot be imposed unless the qualifying facts are properly alleged and proven. For accused […]

When a Rape Conviction Becomes Acts of Lasciviousness: Proof of Penetration Still Matters

Rape conviction reduced to acts of lasciviousness where sexual abuse was proven but carnal knowledge was not established beyond reasonable doubt. A criminal conviction for rape cannot rest on suspicion, shock, or even a disturbing medical finding alone. When the prosecution proves a sexual assault but fails to prove carnal knowledge beyond reasonable doubt, the […]