Angry Gestures Are Not Always Grave Threats: When Fear Is Not Enough for a Criminal Conviction

Supreme Court acquits accused in grave threats case, ruling that threatening gestures may qualify but require proof of intent and persistence. A person cannot be convicted of grave threats merely because another person felt afraid after seeing an angry gesture. The prosecution must still prove, beyond reasonable doubt, that the accused deliberately intended the gesture […]

When a Tax Case Can Be Won or Lost Before Trial

Early procedural choices can decide tax litigation before trial, from motions to dismiss and prescription defenses to default, discovery, and pleading strategy. Tax disputes can be decided long before witnesses are presented: a taxpayer, collecting officer, corporation, or government agency may win or lose the case at the pleading stage if the complaint, answer, discovery […]

When a Club Enforces Its Rules, Hurt Feelings Alone Do Not Create a Damages Case

A valid club suspension caused no compensable injury where members violated rules and failed to prove bad faith, fault, or negligence by the board. Private clubs, associations, and corporations may discipline members who violate valid internal rules, and a suspended member cannot recover millions in moral or exemplary damages merely by showing embarrassment, inconvenience, or […]

When a Settlement Exists, a Lawyer Cannot Let the Court Decide in the Dark

A lawyer was suspended for failing to disclose a settlement to the court, showing that withdrawal or forgiveness cannot erase proven misconduct. Lawyers who obtain a favorable judgment while keeping silent about a prior settlement risk professional discipline, because candor to the court does not end when the opposing party stops appearing or later asks […]

Baseless Complaints Against Judges Can Backfire on Lawyers

Lawyers may be disciplined for groundless complaints against judges when accusations rest on suspicion, hearsay, or conjecture rather than competent proof. Lawyers who accuse judges of bribery or corruption must be prepared to prove it with substantial, competent evidence based on direct knowledge. Suspicion, hearsay, and litigation frustration are not enough. When a lawyer files […]

When a Court Misplaces a Case: The Judge Still Answers for Delay

Judges remain responsible for delayed rulings and misplaced case records, even absent bad faith. The Court reprimanded a judge for an unresolved motion. Litigants whose cases stall because court records are supposedly lost, misplaced, or overlooked are not without remedy: a judge remains personally responsible for managing the docket and resolving pending incidents within the […]

Judges Must Ask for More Time Before Case Delays Become Misconduct

Judges who cannot decide cases on time must seek an extension; illness may reduce penalties but does not erase liability for court delay. Trial judges who become unable to decide cases on time because of illness, personal tragedy, or other serious circumstances are not automatically excused from administrative liability; they must inform the Court and […]

When a Judge Delays a Case for Years, Compassion Has Limits

A judgeโ€™s illness and workload may reduce sanctions, but they do not excuse a five-year delay in deciding a submitted case without seeking more time. Judges may face illness, family emergencies, heavy caseloads, and administrative burdens, but they cannot allow a submitted case to remain undecided for years without asking for more time. The practical […]

When a Court Takes Too Long to Decide: Missing Transcripts Are Not an Excuse

Courts must decide submitted cases on time; missing transcripts, memoranda, or settlement talks do not excuse judicial delay or gross inefficiency. Judges cannot excuse delayed decisions by pointing to missing transcripts, unresolved memoranda, settlement talks, or party inaction when a case is already submitted for resolution. The Supreme Court treated delay itself as a discipline […]

When Court Criticism Becomes Contempt: The Line Between Legitimate Advocacy and Scurrilous Attacks

The Court fined a complainant for indirect contempt after unfounded attacks on justices, clarifying when strong criticism of court delay becomes punishable. Litigants may criticize judges and court decisions, but they cross into contempt when their language stops being a good-faith challenge to legal error and becomes a scurrilous attack on the integrity of the […]