Tax Declarations Do Not Prove Ownership: Why Paying Real Property Tax Cannot Privatize Public Land

Paying real property tax does not prove ownership or privatize public land. Tax declarations cannot defeat State ownership of Laguna Lake property. Real property tax declarations can help support a claim of possession, but they do not, by themselves, convert public land into private property. For landowners, developers, and families relying on old tax records, […]

When Creditor-Banks Take Control, They Cannot Strip a Debtorโ€™s Assets to Pay Themselves First

Creditor-banks controlling a debtorโ€™s board may be liable for asset transfers that prefer themselves and prejudice other creditors. Creditors who place their own representatives on a debtor corporationโ€™s board cannot use that control to divert corporate assets, secure their own claims, and leave other creditors unpaid. The controlling doctrine is simple but powerful: a creditor […]

When Unpaid Shares Are Sold, the Forum Matters: Intra-Corporate Stock Disputes Belong in the Special Commercial Court

Unpaid stock subscription and delinquency sale disputes are intra-corporate cases for Special Commercial Courts, with strict certiorari rules still applying. Shareholders contesting the sale of delinquent shares must treat the dispute as an intra-corporate controversy, not as an ordinary collection or damages case. The Suzuki ruling matters because it confirms that fights over unpaid stock […]

Winning Possession Does Not Automatically Cancel a Torrens Title

A property claimant may win possession, but a Torrens title cannot be cancelled through a collateral attack; a direct action for annulment is required. A person may win a property case, recover possession, and prove ownership against an occupant, but that victory does not automatically cancel a Torrens title standing in someone elseโ€™s name. The […]

A Church Cannot Receive Donated Land Before It Legally Exists

A void land donation to a non-existent church entity could not defeat a later Torrens title. The ruling clarifies corporate capacity and de facto corporation limits. A donation of land to a religious group, mission, chapter, association, or nonstock organization is not saved by good intentions if the supposed donee had no juridical personality when […]

When Senior Citizen Discounts Reduce Tax Payable Peso for Peso

Senior citizen discounts under the old law were tax credits, not mere deductions; the BIR could not reduce that statutory benefit by regulation. Businesses that were legally required to give the 20% senior citizen discount under the old Senior Citizens Act could treat that discount as a tax credit, not merely as a deduction from […]

Senior Citizen Discounts Were Tax Credits Before the Law Changed

Businesses could claim old senior citizen discounts as tax credits, not mere deductions, because BIR regulations cannot rewrite the statute. Businesses that granted mandatory senior citizen discounts under the old Senior Citizens Act were entitled to treat those discounts as tax credits, not merely as ordinary deductions, when the governing law still used the term […]

When a Government Board Cannot Perpetuate Itself: The Supreme Courtโ€™s Rule on Appointments in Public Corporations

The Supreme Court held that a government corporation board cannot fill its own trustee vacancies when doing so violates presidential appointment power. Government corporations cannot use their charters to create self-perpetuating boards when the Constitution reserves appointment power to the President or to constitutionally recognized appointing authorities. For public officers, trustees, and regulated entities dealing […]