Environmental Writs Require Evidence, Not Alarm: What Mining Protesters Must Prove Before Stopping Operations

The Supreme Court dismissed a writ of kalikasan petition against Manicani mining operations for lack of concrete evidence of large-scale environmental harm. Communities opposing mining, reclamation, or other environmentally sensitive projects cannot obtain a writ of kalikasan by relying on broad fears of ecological harm alone; they must file the case with concrete evidence showing […]

COMELEC Cannot Cancel a Candidacy Through Generalized Nuisance-Candidate Labels

COMELEC must give specific factual and legal reasons before cancelling a candidacy as nuisance; generalized labels violate due process. Candidates who are branded as nuisance candidates must be told exactly what they did, what evidence proves it, and why those facts legally justify cancellation of their certificate of candidacy. The ruling in Diaz makes clear […]

Nestlรฉ MILOยฎ Products Exempt from Sweetened Beverage Tax: CTA Upholds Refund Rights

CTA En Banc affirms MILOยฎ products as milk products exempt from SBT; Nestlรฉ Philippines entitled to P253M+ refund. FDA classification and milk content determine exemption. Taxpayers manufacturing milk-based beverages now have clarity on Sweetened Beverage Tax (SBT) compliance. Companies producing flavored milk drinks that meet FDA-defined milk product criteria are not subject to the excise […]

How Taxpayers Can Rely on CTA Jurisdiction to Secure Tax Credits

The CTA En Banc denied the Commissioner of Internal Revenue’s Motion for Reconsideration, affirming jurisdiction and supporting timely tax credit claims for taxpayers. Businesses claiming tax refunds or credits must ensure their petitions are timely and properly filed, as improper filings can be denied outright. The recent En Banc decision involving ED & F Man […]

Partial Win for Taxpayer on 2017 Deficiency Assessments: Key Takeaways for Corporations

The CTA partially granted Retiro Golden Foods’ petition: deficiency income tax, VAT, and penalties canceled due to valid protest; EWT and WTC upheld. Corporate taxpayers should carefully track both the form and content of deficiency tax assessments and administrative protests, as failure to properly contest specific items can result in partial liability. In a recent […]

Party-List Groups Can Lose Registration for Defying Final Seat Allocations

COMELEC may cancel a party-list groupโ€™s registration for defying final seat allocations, and HRET jurisdiction does not bar registration cases. A party-list organization may be removed from the ballot years after an election if it continues to benefit from a congressional seat that the final party-list allocation no longer allows. The practical consequence is blunt: […]

Direct Contracting Is Not a Shortcut: Public Buyers Must Prove Exclusivity, No Cheaper Substitute, and Real Market Need

Direct contracting in government procurement must be proven with exclusivity, market survey, and no cheaper substitute, or officials risk dismissal. Government officials who choose direct contracting over public bidding must be ready to prove why only one supplier can lawfully and economically serve the public need. The ruling matters not only to procurement officers, but […]

Central Bank Reserves Survive the GOCC Dividend Rule: Why COA Cannot Freeze Future Tax and Audit Positions by Fiat

The Supreme Court held BSP is outside RA 7656โ€™s GOCC dividend regime, limiting COAโ€™s power to bind future audits and preserving BSP Charter reserve rules. Government auditors may resolve legal issues in the course of audit, but they cannot turn an unresolved future tax or dividend issue into binding precedent before the transaction even happens. […]

Late SEC Reports Can Cost a Company Its Right to Sell Securities

Repeated SEC filing defaults may justify revocation of securities registration when the issuer had notice, warning, and a chance to explain. Companies that repeatedly fail to file required SEC reports cannot rely on a missing second hearing to undo the revocation of their securities registration, so long as they were warned, given a meaningful chance […]

Government Employees May Protest at Work Unless They Disrupt Public Service

Government employees may air workplace grievances unless their collective action is intended to stop work or disrupt public service. Government employees do not lose their constitutional right to speak, assemble, and air workplace grievances merely because they work in public service. A collective act becomes a prohibited mass action only when it is intended to […]