Local Business Tax Refunds Survive When Permit Billing Forms Are Not Valid Assessments

Permit renewal billing forms were not valid local tax assessments, but related taxpayers could not aggregate separate refund claims to create jurisdiction. Businesses disputing local business tax collections should not assume that every billing form or business permit order of payment is already a valid local tax assessment that starts protest deadlines. In this ruling, […]

When Local Environmental Charges Are Fees, Not Taxes: Why the Correct Appeal Route Matters

Businesses disputing local environmental charges must classify the exaction correctly; the court dismissed the appeal after finding the charge was a regulatory fee, not a tax. Businesses paying local environmental charges under protest must first determine whether the exaction is truly a tax or merely a regulatory fee, because choosing the wrong appellate forum can […]

Government Instrumentalities Can Defeat Local Real Property Tax Assessments When Their Properties Serve a Public Function

Government instrumentalities performing public functions may be exempt from local real property tax, making assessments and delinquency notices void. Government agencies and public-purpose entities facing local real property tax assessments should examine whether they are truly taxable corporations or government instrumentalities performing essential public functions, because that classification can determine whether the assessment is void, […]

Local Franchise Tax Cannot Follow Electricity Delivery Without Proper Tax Situs

Power-sector franchise tax assessments require proper tax situs. The Court denied reconsideration and rejected local franchise tax based on delivery or facilities alone. Government entities and power-sector taxpayers facing local franchise tax assessments should examine where the taxable franchise privilege is legally exercised, not merely where electricity, facilities, or downstream services may physically pass. In […]

BOI Income Tax Holiday Does Not Automatically Exempt Businesses From Local Business Tax

BOI income tax holidays do not automatically exempt enterprises from local business tax; old exemptions may be withdrawn under the Local Government Code. Businesses operating inside special economic zones or industrial estates should not assume that a BOI income tax holiday automatically shields them from local business tax. In this decision, the taxpayer failed to […]

Local Business Tax Assessments Can Be Voided When Billing Statements Fail Due Process

Local business tax billing statements may be void if they fail to state the nature, amount, and legal basis of the assessment under Section 195. Businesses facing local business tax assessments should not treat a billing statement as automatically valid if it fails to explain the nature of the tax, the amount of deficiency, and […]

Local Business Tax Refund Claims Cannot Be Dismissed as Late Protests When No Deficiency Assessment Was Issued

A taxpayer’s local business tax refund claim may proceed when no deficiency assessment was issued and Section 196’s two-year period was met. Businesses seeking refunds of excessive local business taxes should not be forced into the shorter protest route for deficiency assessments when the city merely issued a statement of account for permit renewal. For […]

Tollway Operators May Face Real Property Tax on Government-Owned Roads They Operate for Profit

A tollway operator remained liable for real property tax because it had beneficial use, control, and toll revenue rights over government-owned infrastructure. Private operators of government infrastructure cannot assume real property tax exemption merely because the underlying asset is owned by the Republic or used by the commuting public. Where a tollway operator has possession, […]

Local Business Tax Refund Claims Survive When Payment Orders Are Not Deficiency Assessments

Tax Orders of Payment were not treated as local tax assessments, allowing the taxpayer’s refund claim under Section 196 to proceed to trial. Businesses challenging local business tax payments should not automatically treat every tax order of payment as a deficiency assessment that triggers the protest procedure under Section 195 of the Local Government Code. […]