Foreclosed Property Can Still Be Redeemed by Filing Suit Within the Redemption Period

Mortgagors may preserve foreclosure redemption rights by filing suit within the redemption period, even without prior perfect tender when the amount is disputed. A mortgagor who files a court action within the one-year redemption period may effectively preserve the right to redeem foreclosed property, even without first making a perfect cash tender to the purchaser. […]

A Pending Appeal Does Not Disqualify a State Witness: What Mangubat Means for Sandiganbayan Prosecutions

A pending appeal from another conviction does not automatically disqualify a discharged accused from serving as state witness in Sandiganbayan cases. An accused person who has already testified for the prosecution as a discharged state witness cannot later be excluded merely because a prior conviction for another offense was still on appeal when the discharge […]

When a Contractor’s Worker Is Not Your Employee: The Supreme Court’s Payroll-and-Control Rule for Job Contracting Disputes

A contractor’s worker was not Petrophil’s employee because Gersher hired and paid him; transfer and demotion were upheld absent unfair labor practice. A company that receives services from a contractor is not automatically the worker’s employer simply because the work is performed inside its premises. Where the records show that the contractor hired the worker, […]

A Judge’s Public Apology Does Not End a Misconduct Case

A judge’s public apology and the complainant’s withdrawal did not end a misconduct case; the Supreme Court dismissed the judge to protect public trust. Public officials who misuse the authority and dignity of their office cannot make an administrative case disappear simply because the complainant later forgives them. In Arban v. Judge Borja, the Supreme […]

Missed Appeal Deadlines Can Kill a Tax Case: When Extensions Are Allowed and When They Are Not

Lacsamana explains when appeal extensions are allowed, warning taxpayers that the wrong appellate remedy or late filing can defeat even strong tax defenses. Taxpayers who lose before a court or quasi-judicial body cannot assume that asking for more time will preserve their appeal. Lacsamana clarified a hard procedural dividing line: some appeals allow extensions, but […]

When a Judge Misuses Prisoners, Criminal Conviction Can End His Public Career

A judge convicted of misusing detainees as personal laborers was dismissed, lost benefits, and barred from government service for conduct showing unfitness for office. A judge who turns detainees into personal laborers does not merely commit a private abuse of power; he destroys the public trust required for judicial office. In Balayon v. Araneta, the […]

Bad-Faith Builders Cannot Charge the Owner for Improvements They Had No Right to Make

Bad-faith possessors cannot recover or remove useful improvements made on another’s property, protecting owners from reimbursement claims after wrongful construction. A person or public entity that builds on another’s property in bad faith cannot force the lawful owner to pay for the improvements. Even if the structures are useful, costly, or operationally important, the builder […]

A Forced First Marriage Still Blocks a Second Marriage Until It Is Annulled

A forced or defective first marriage remains legally effective until annulled, making a later marriage void if contracted while the first marriage subsists. A person who believes a prior marriage was forced or defective cannot simply treat that marriage as non-existent and enter into a second marriage. Until a competent court annuls or declares the […]

A Defective Summons Abroad May Still Stand When Due Process Was Actually Served

Actual receipt of summons abroad may satisfy due process in Philippine property cases when the defendant is given a fair chance to respond. Filipinos living abroad cannot assume that a Philippine property case will stop simply because summons was not served in the most technically perfect way. When the action involves property in the Philippines […]

When a Confession Becomes Evidence: Why Conspiracy Can Defeat Alibi and Fear Defenses in Criminal Cases

The Court affirmed robbery with homicide, holding that voluntary confessions, coordinated acts, and weak alibi can prove conspiracy beyond reasonable doubt. People accused of a serious crime cannot defeat conviction by simply saying their confession was forced, that they were only afraid of a co-accused, or that they were somewhere nearby. The Petenia ruling reinforces […]