Legal Insanity Can Acquit an Accused but Not Erase Civil Liability

Legal insanity may acquit an accused from parricide, but civil damages and court-ordered psychiatric confinement may still follow. An accused who proves legal insanity may be acquitted even after trial and appeal, but the acquittal does not automatically free the accused from paying damages to the victim’s heirs. The ruling matters because it separates criminal […]

Late Reconsideration Keeps Customs Criminal Case Dismissed Without Prejudice

Customs criminal case stayed dismissed after prosecutors filed a late reconsideration motion, underscoring strict deadlines and document sufficiency in CTA proceedings. Customs enforcement cases can fail before trial when the prosecution misses court deadlines or fails to submit the documents needed to support probable cause, even where the alleged violation involves serious importation offenses. For […]

Customs Smuggling Case Dismissed After Prosecution Failed to Submit Complete Evidence

A customs criminal case was dismissed without prejudice after the prosecution failed to submit complete supporting documents to establish probable cause. Importers and customs brokers facing criminal customs charges should closely examine whether the prosecution actually submitted the records needed to establish probable cause, because a serious allegation of misdeclaration or undervaluation will not by […]

Tax Evasion Charges Can Be Dismissed When the Accused Was Never Properly Notified

Tax crime case for alleged VAT non-payment dismissed without prejudice after defective subpoena service denied the accused due process in preliminary investigation. Businesses and corporate officers facing criminal tax charges must be given a genuine opportunity to participate in the preliminary investigation before they are brought to trial. In this Resolution, the Court of Tax […]

Acquitted Corporate Check Signatories Are Not Automatically Liable for Company Debt

Corporate check signatories acquitted in BP 22 cases are not automatically personally liable for company debts; creditors must sue the proper debtor. A corporate employee who signs a company check is not automatically required to personally pay the company debt when a bouncing-check case ends in acquittal. The Supreme Court clarified that, in prosecutions involving […]

Corporate Check Signatories Are Not Automatically Personally Liable After a BP 22 Acquittal

Corporate check signatories acquitted of BP 22 are not automatically personally liable for the check value; creditors must sue the proper debtor. A company officer or authorized signatory who signs a corporate check is not automatically personally liable for the check’s value after being acquitted of a BP 22 charge. If the criminal case fails, […]

Corporate Fiduciary Breach Is Not Automatically a Crime: When Bank Directors Face Civil, Not Penal, Liability

Corporate fiduciary breach under Section 31 creates civil liability, not automatic criminal prosecution; UCPB’s claim also prescribed after four years. Corporate officers and directors accused of bad faith, gross negligence, or conflicts of interest do not automatically face criminal prosecution under the old Corporation Code merely because their conduct caused financial damage to the company. […]

When Police Skip the Drug Evidence Safeguards, Conviction Cannot Stand

The Supreme Court acquitted an accused in a drug case because police failed to justify serious chain-of-custody lapses under RA 9165. Drug convictions cannot rest on police testimony alone when the prosecution fails to account for the seized drugs through the safeguards required by law. The ruling reinforces a doctrine that matters far beyond narcotics […]

Corporate Fiduciary Breaches Are Not Automatically Crimes

The Supreme Court held that director disloyalty under Sections 31 and 34 creates civil liability, not automatic criminal liability under Section 144. Corporate directors and officers may face serious civil liability for disloyalty, bad faith, or corporate opportunity violations, but they cannot be criminally prosecuted unless Congress clearly made the act a crime. The ruling […]