RMC No. 115-2023: Government Franchise and License Costs for Public Utilities Are Administrative Costs for OSD Computation

RMC No. 115-2023 treats public utility franchise, concession, license, and operating-right costs as administrative costs for OSD computation. Public service and public utility operators using the Optional Standard Deduction must immediately review how they classify concession fees, franchise costs, license fees, rights payments, operations agreement costs, and similar government-granted operating rights. RMC No. 115-2023 changes […]

A Cooperative Branch Cannot Sue Like a Separate Company

A cooperative branch with no juridical personality cannot sue or defeat a regulator-approved franchise transfer through an internal compromise agreement. A branch office, operating unit, or internal division cannot claim corporate powers merely because it has its own name, accounts, or operational control. In this ruling, the Court treated that distinction as decisive: MAGELCO-PALMA was […]

Water Districts Are GOCCs: Why Local Water Utilities Cannot Claim Private-Corporation Tax Treatment

Water districts formed under PD 198 are GOCCs with special charters, not private corporations, limiting tax exemption claims and barring relitigation. Local water districts cannot avoid government tax rules by calling themselves private corporations. When a water district is created under Presidential Decree No. 198, it is treated as a government-owned or controlled corporation with […]

Water Districts Cannot Block Competitors by Invoking Exclusive Service Rights

Water districts cannot use exclusive franchise rights to block qualified competitors because public utility authorizations cannot be exclusive under the Constitution. Public utility operators cannot rely on an exclusive franchise to keep competitors out when the Constitution itself prohibits exclusive public utility authorizations. For water districts, this means that service areas are not automatic monopolies: […]

Water Districts Are Government Corporations: Why CSC and COA Oversight Applies

Local water districts formed under PD 198 are GOCCs with original charters, placing employees under CSC rules and funds under COA audit jurisdiction. Local water districts are not ordinary private utilities merely because they serve paying customers; when created under Presidential Decree No. 198, they are government-owned or controlled corporations with original charters, placing their […]

When Public Utility Disputes Belong in Court, Not the SEC

Water consumers may sue in regular courts to compel statutory dissolution of a local water district; the dispute is not an SEC intra-corporate case. Consumers challenging the dissolution or alleged mismanagement of a local water district are not automatically confined to corporate remedies before the Securities and Exchange Commission. When the dispute concerns a quasi-public […]