When Utilities Cut Water Without Notice, Homeowners Can Recover Damages

Utilities and contractors may be liable for damages when they cut or transfer water lines without notice, even during authorized rehabilitation works. Homeowners and associations are not helpless when a utility provider or contractor interrupts essential services without warning. Even when a company has authority to improve, rehabilitate, or maintain a water system, that authority […]

Non-Stock Associations Cannot Expel Members or Transfer Community Property Without Due Process and Corporate Purpose

The Supreme Court voided improper association expulsions and land transfers, protecting membersโ€™ due process, inspection rights, and corporate property. Members of a non-stock association are not powerless when officers remove them without notice or transfer association property to insiders. The Supreme Court confirmed that membership cannot be terminated by shortcut, and corporate property cannot be […]

Dissolved Corporations Cannot Sue After the Three-Year Winding-Up Period

A revoked corporation cannot file a new lawsuit after the three-year winding-up period, even if it claims to be protecting or liquidating assets. A corporation whose registration has been revoked cannot simply return to court years later and file a new case in its own name. Once the three-year statutory winding-up period has expired, the […]

Judges Cannot Turn Private Property Disputes Into Self-Help Remedies

A judge avoided misconduct liability for a private fishpond dispute, but was admonished to use lawful remedies instead of self-help in asserting property rights. A judge who is personally involved in a land, fishpond, or permit dispute cannot automatically be disciplined for misconduct merely because the quarrel is private; the act complained of must generally […]

Tax Returns Are Not Always Required to Prove Lost Income Damages

Tax returns do not automatically control lost income claims. The Court allowed plantation damages proven by inspection and valuation despite absent tax returns. A defendant cannot defeat a lost income or business interruption claim simply by demanding income tax returns when the injury concerns only a specific portion of property or operations. The practical rule […]

Attorney-Client Privilege Cannot Hide Sale Proceeds From Co-Owners and Heirs

Privilege does not let a lawyer conceal sale proceeds from heirs or co-owners entitled to an accounting, and ignoring court orders may lead to discipline. Lawyers cannot use attorney-client privilege as a shield to conceal basic financial information from persons who have a legal right to know it. When co-owners, heirs, or estate administrators ask […]

When Judges Take Sides in Private Property Disputes, Judicial Ethics Steps In

Judges may be disciplined for acting as private administrators or representatives in property disputes, even without proof of anti-graft liability. Judges may not step into private property disputes as administrators, representatives, or informal legal defenders of one side, because even well-intentioned involvement can place the judgeโ€™s impartiality and public trust in the courts at risk. […]

Judges Can Be Reprimanded for the Appearance of Bias Even Without Proof of Abuse

The Supreme Court rejected an unproven grave abuse charge but reprimanded a judge for failing to avoid the appearance of impropriety in a family-linked case. A party who accuses a judge of abuse must prove the charge with substantial evidence, but a judge may still be disciplined when his conduct creates an appearance of impropriety, […]