When Labor Picketing Spills Over to a Neighboring Business, the RTC May Step In

A non-employer affected by strike activity may seek RTC relief when no labor dispute or employment relationship is shown with the union. A business that is not proven to be the employer of striking workers may ask the regular courts for relief when picketing or strike activity affects its premises. The key practical lesson is […]

No Second Bite at Certiorari: Final Supreme Court Rulings Bind Parties Who Already Had Their Day in Court

The Court dismissed a repeat certiorari petition because the same administrative decision had already been reviewed, reinforcing finality in tax and labor disputes. A party cannot keep relitigating the same administrative decision by changing procedural posture or filing a new petition after the Supreme Court has already passed upon the issue. For taxpayers, employers, unions, […]

Ignoring a Court Order Is Not Cured by Partial Payment or Good Intentions

Partial compliance and good faith did not purge contempt where a lawyer failed to fully obey a court order to account for disputed labor-case proceeds. A party held in contempt cannot escape punishment by making partial payment, offering explanations, or invoking good faith after failing to fully obey a clear court directive. The practical lesson […]

When the BIR Waits Too Long: Tax Collection Cases Can Still Prescribe Even After an Assessment

A BIR assessment does not allow indefinite collection. The Supreme Court dismissed a tax case filed beyond the five-year prescriptive period. A tax assessment does not give the government unlimited time to sue. When the Bureau of Internal Revenue assesses a taxpayer but files its collection case beyond the statutory period, the case may be […]

BIR Collection Cases Can Die on Prescription When the Government Cannot Prove Notice

The Supreme Court barred a BIR collection suit where the government filed beyond five years and failed to prove receipt of the later deficiency assessment. A taxpayer may defeat a BIR collection suit when the government files too late and cannot prove that a later deficiency assessment was actually received. In Republic of the Philippines […]

Buying Land at Auction? Tax Declarations and Clean Titles Can Decide Who Keeps the Property

Clean Torrens titles protected auction buyers from prior unregistered lot buyers; tax declarations did not prove notice of hidden claims. A buyer at a foreclosure or public auction may rely on a clean Torrens title unless the title itself shows a defect or encumbrance that would reasonably warn the buyer of another person’s claim. Prior […]

Military Trial After Martial Law? The Supreme Court Says Civil Courts Take Over

Civilians cannot remain before a military tribunal after martial law when no valid arraignment gave it jurisdiction; prosecution must move to civil courts. When martial law ends, civilians cannot be kept indefinitely before military tribunals merely because a case began there. If the military body never validly acquired jurisdiction before its authority ended, the case […]

When a Strike Is Illegal, Workers Still May Not Be Automatically Fired

Illegal strike participation does not automatically justify dismissal; the Court ordered reinstatement and back wages where termination was excessive and anti-union. An illegal strike does not automatically give an employer a free hand to dismiss every worker who joined it. Even where a work stoppage is found unlawful, dismissal must still be measured against the […]