Unauthorized BIR Audits Can Defeat Tax Collection and Criminal Tax Charges

A void BIR audit can invalidate deficiency tax assessments, defeating collection and civil liability despite arguments that the FAN became final. Taxpayers facing criminal tax cases or collection efforts should closely examine whether the BIR officers who conducted the audit were properly authorized, because a void examination can invalidate the resulting deficiency tax assessment and […]

Minority Stockholders Can Recover Damages When Corporate Books Are Hidden and Company Assets Are Diverted

Minority stockholders denied corporate records may recover damages for fraud, but mismanagement alone does not trigger appraisal rights. A minority stockholder who is shut out of corporate records, denied transparency, and defrauded through related-company dealings may recover damages even when the exact amount of loss cannot be proven with mathematical certainty. The ruling is a […]

Minority Stockholders Can Recover Damages When Corporate Books Are Hidden and Assets Are Diverted

Minority stockholders denied corporate records may recover damages when fraud and asset diversion are proven, but appraisal rights remain limited. Minority stockholders who are denied access to corporate records are not limited to asking for inspection alone. When the refusal exposes deeper fraud, asset diversion, and misuse of related corporations, courts may pierce the corporate […]

Business Successors Cannot Use a New Entity to Escape Employee Claims

The Court held a successor printing business and its officer liable for illegal dismissal after using a new entity to evade employee claims. Employers cannot avoid labor liability by closing a sole proprietorship, continuing the same business through a new entity, and treating an injured worker as if he had simply disappeared. When the successor […]

Inherited Shares Are Not Automatically Corporate Shares: Why Estate Settlement Comes First

Heirs do not automatically become stockholders over inherited shares; estate settlement and stock transfer book registration must come first. Heirs who inherit shares in a family corporation do not automatically become stockholders with enforceable corporate rights. Before a disputed transfer of inherited shares can be treated as an intra-corporate controversy, the estate must first be […]

Local Business Tax Dispute: Makati Denial of Takenaka Branch Protest

The CTA upheld Makati City’s LBT assessment for Takenaka Corporation, confirming procedural and documentation requirements. Prior payments and protest arguments were insufficient to void the NOA. Businesses operating in multiple jurisdictions must carefully allocate their tax obligations to avoid double taxation, as highlighted by the recent Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) decision affecting Takenaka Corporation […]

BIR Tax Assessments Void Without LOA: Lessons for Businesses

CTA En Banc affirms that BIR assessments issued without a valid LOA are void ab initio, emphasizing due process and procedural compliance for businesses. Businesses in the Philippines must now take special care when responding to tax assessments, as the Court of Tax Appeals (CTA) En Banc has reaffirmed that deficiency tax assessments issued without […]

Shareholder Derivative Suits Can Be Dismissed When Investors Skip Internal Corporate Remedies

Minority shareholders must plead specific exhausted corporate remedies before filing a derivative suit; letters and meetings alone may not be enough. Minority stockholders cannot use a derivative suit as a first resort when they have not pleaded, with particularity, the internal corporate remedies they tried and failed to exhaust. For business owners, directors, corporate secretaries, […]

Petron Denied Partial Excise Tax Refund on Diesel Sales to Exempt Entity

Petron’s partial excise tax refund claim for diesel sales to a tax-exempt entity was denied due to lack of verifiable proof of payment to the BIR, emphasizing strict substantiation requirements. Businesses dealing in petroleum products must ensure proper substantiation of excise tax payments when claiming refunds. Petron Corporation’s partial refund request for excise taxes paid […]

Unauthorized Tax Audit Renders Assessment Void: Key Lessons for Businesses

CTA voids a P143M tax assessment due to audits conducted without valid LOA, underscoring the necessity of proper authorization and due process for taxpayers. Businesses and taxpayers must ensure that any tax audit conducted by the Bureau of Internal Revenue is authorized under a valid Letter of Authority (LOA). A recent Court of Tax Appeals […]