Flying Pay Is Not a Travel Allowance: CAAP Employees Who Fly as Passengers Must Refund Disallowed Benefits

CAAP personnel who merely flew as passengers were ordered to refund flying risk pay, while good-faith approving officers escaped solidary liability. Government personnel cannot claim flying risk pay merely because their official duties require them to ride airplanes. The allowance belongs only to aviation personnel whose actual functions involve regular and frequent aerial operations, not […]

When Illegal Government Allowances Need Not Be Refunded

Supreme Court upheld COA’s COLA disallowance but excused refund due to finality, due process, lapse of time, and social justice under Madera. Government employees and local officials may still be spared from refunding disallowed benefits, even when the Commission on Audit correctly finds the payment illegal, if requiring repayment years later would be inequitable, prejudicial, […]

Government Employees Must Return Unauthorized Health Insurance Benefits After COA Disallowance

Government health insurance benefits paid without legal authority may be disallowed by COA, requiring approving officers and employee-recipients to refund them. Government employees who receive health insurance benefits paid from public funds may be ordered to return them when the benefit was not authorized by law, even if the employees merely received the benefit passively […]

When Public Benefits Are Disallowed, Finality Can Save Passive Employeesβ€”But Not Negligent Approving Officers

Passive employees may keep disallowed benefits if their absolution is final, but negligent approving and certifying officers remain liable for unauthorized public payments. Public employees who merely received disallowed benefits may avoid refunding them when their absolution has already become final, but approving and certifying officers remain exposed to solidary liability when they released public […]

Central Bank Reserves Survive the GOCC Dividend Rule: Why COA Cannot Freeze Future Tax and Audit Positions by Fiat

The Supreme Court held BSP is outside RA 7656’s GOCC dividend regime, limiting COA’s power to bind future audits and preserving BSP Charter reserve rules. Government auditors may resolve legal issues in the course of audit, but they cannot turn an unresolved future tax or dividend issue into binding precedent before the transaction even happens. […]

GOCC Directors Cannot Pay Themselves Bonuses When the Corporation Has No Net Income

GOCC directors may keep valid RATA, but bonuses and medical reimbursements paid without net income or legal authority must be refunded. Board approval is not enough to validate government corporate benefits: when a government-owned or controlled corporation has no net income, its directors cannot rely on internal by-laws or Monetary Board approval to pay themselves […]

When Government Benefits Are Disallowed, Employees May Still Avoid Refunds

The Supreme Court upheld COA’s COLA disallowance but excused officers and retired payees from refund due to good faith and undue prejudice. Government employees who receive disallowed benefits are not automatically protected by good faith, but the Supreme Court may still excuse repayment when refund would cause undue prejudice, especially where the payments were made […]

Government Employees Cannot Keep Unauthorized Allowances Merely Because They Were Long Paid

COA may disallow unauthorized GOCC benefits, while approving and certifying officers can be liable only for the net amount when gross negligence is shown. Public officers who approve or certify unauthorized employee benefits cannot rely on old agency practice, outdated board resolutions, or advisory letters when clear law and settled jurisprudence already prohibit the payment. […]

GOCC Board Allowances Are Not Automatically Double Compensation

GOCC board per diems and RATA are not automatically double compensation, but bonuses remain risky absent clear legal authority. Government officials who sit on the board of a government-owned or controlled corporation are not automatically required to return every allowance, per diem, or RATA they receive. The controlling question is more precise: whether the payment […]