When Co-Owners Sell Family Property, the BIR Cannot Automatically Tax Them as a Partnership

Co-owners who sell family property are not automatically taxable as an unregistered partnership. Intent and business purpose determine BIR tax exposure. Co-owners who merely buy, hold, and later sell property are not automatically a taxable partnership just because they shared the proceeds. For families, heirs, and siblings who temporarily hold land together, the Obillos ruling […]

Judges and Court Employees Can Still Face Anti-Graft Prosecution Before the Sandiganbayan

Court personnel remain subject to Sandiganbayan anti-graft prosecution despite limits on administrative investigations by the Tanodbayan. Public officers cannot avoid anti-graft prosecution merely because they work in the courts. The key doctrine is jurisdictional separation: administrative supervision over judges and court personnel belongs to the Supreme Court, but criminal prosecution for offenses cognizable by the […]

When a Deed of Sale Is Really a Mortgage: Why Courts Look Beyond the Paper Title

A deed labeled as a sale may be treated as an equitable mortgage when facts show it secured a loan, affecting title, buyer rights, and tax analysis. A property owner who signs a document called a deed of sale is not always treated as having permanently sold the property. When the surrounding facts show that […]

Witness Confusion Does Not Defeat a Criminal Case When Identification Is Positive

Positive eyewitness identification can prevail despite name confusion, aliases, blotter issues, or alibi when the accused is credibly linked to the crime. Criminal liability does not disappear simply because frightened witnesses initially gave an alias, hesitated, or confused the accusedโ€™s name. When witnesses positively identify the person who committed the crime, Philippine courts may sustain […]

When a Landlord Padlocks a Business: Lessees May Sue for Damages and Injunction Beyond Ejectment

A tenant locked out of business premises may sue for damages and injunction when the landlord disrupts peaceful enjoyment, not merely possession. A business tenant locked out of its leased premises is not limited to an ejectment-style possession case. When the real injury is the disruption of peaceful enjoyment and the resulting business damage, the […]