When Neighborhood Noise Becomes a Lawsuit: The Supreme Court Sets a Higher Bar for Private Nuisance Claims

The Supreme Court held that school noise is not automatically a nuisance; residents must prove unreasonable interference affecting ordinary people. Noise from a lawful business, school, or institution does not automatically become a compensable nuisance simply because nearby residents find it disturbing. A claimant must prove that the sound unreasonably interferes with the health or […]

When an Unlisted Witness Cannot Save the Prosecutionโ€™s Case

The Supreme Court acquitted an accused after excluding an unlisted substitute eyewitness, stressing that pre-trial orders bind criminal trials. Criminal defendants can now rely more firmly on a practical trial safeguard: if the prosecution fails to list a witness during pre-trial, that witness may be excluded unless the State gives a specific, legally sufficient reason […]

RMC No. 107-2025: BIR Suspends Field Audits, LOA Issuances, and Verification Operations Until Further Order

RMC No. 107-2025 suspends most BIR field audits and LOA-related operations, with key exceptions for prescription, transfers, refunds, and criminal probes. Taxpayers with ongoing BIR field audits should immediately check whether their examination, verification, Letter of Authority, Mission Order, or related field operation is now suspended. RMC No. 107-2025 orders the suspension of all ongoing […]

RMC No. 018-2026: Businesses Must Verify Transactions Involving Damaged Used BIR Accountable Forms After Typhoon Kristine

RMC No. 018-2026 alerts businesses to verify transactions involving specific damaged BIR accountable forms used for import release and taxpayer records. Businesses, importers, accountants, and tax personnel dealing with previously issued BIR accountable forms should verify any official transaction involving the identified forms before relying on them. RMC No. 018-2026 gives notice that specific used […]

Mining Permits Cannot Be Revived by the Wrong Appeal: Supreme Court Clarifies When DENR Orders May Be Challenged in Court

The Supreme Court held that DENRโ€™s implementation of a final FTAA revocation was administrative, not quasi-judicial, defeating a Rule 43 appeal. Companies dealing with mineral agreements and government permits cannot assume that every adverse DENR action may be appealed directly to the Court of Appeals. When the DENR merely implements a final administrative ruling or […]

Angry Gestures Are Not Always Grave Threats: When Fear Is Not Enough for a Criminal Conviction

Supreme Court acquits accused in grave threats case, ruling that threatening gestures may qualify but require proof of intent and persistence. A person cannot be convicted of grave threats merely because another person felt afraid after seeing an angry gesture. The prosecution must still prove, beyond reasonable doubt, that the accused deliberately intended the gesture […]

Drug Case Plea Bargaining Cannot Be Denied Just Because Two Charges Came From One Arrest

The Supreme Court held that two drug charges from one arrest do not automatically disqualify an accused from plea bargaining under the drug case framework. Accused persons in drug cases may not be denied plea bargaining simply because they face both sale and possession charges from the same police operation, when the Supreme Courtโ€™s own […]

Insurance Proceeds Can Be Forced Into Arbitration When They Are Vital to Corporate Rehabilitation

Rehabilitation courts may compel arbitration of insurance claims when proceeds are built into the rehabilitation plan and affect creditor repayment. A distressed company in court-supervised rehabilitation may use the rehabilitation case itself to push a disputed insurance recovery into arbitration when the proceeds are part of the approved plan to revive the business and repay […]

Heirs Cannot Freeze Partnership Land Titles Based on an Expected Inheritance

Heirs of a deceased partner cannot annotate an adverse claim on partnership land; their possible remedy is against the partnerโ€™s residual share after liquidation. Heirs who expect to inherit from a deceased partner cannot automatically place an adverse claim on land registered in the name of the partnership. Their possible inheritance is not the land […]