Lost Stock Certificates Are Not Ordinary Civil Claims: Why Stockholders Must Bring Replacement Disputes to the Corporate Forum

A stockholder’s claim for replacement of a missing stock certificate is an intra-corporate controversy, and damages do not move it to ordinary courts. Stockholders who are refused a replacement stock certificate cannot automatically turn that dispute into an ordinary damages case in the regular courts. When the controversy is fundamentally between a stockholder and the […]

Leased Public Mineral Land Can Become Taxable Even When the Government Still Owns It

A mining lessee avoided tax under the old ownership rule but became liable after the 1974 Code taxed real property by actual beneficial use. A company using public mineral land cannot assume that government ownership alone shields the property from real property tax. Under the Nueva Ecija ruling, the decisive question after the 1974 Real […]

Tax Amnesty Does Not Erase Smuggling Charges Already Discovered by the Government

Tax amnesty for undisclosed income did not stop a smuggling trial; the Court held that pending customs prosecutions remain outside the decree’s protection. Tax amnesty protects only what the amnesty law actually covers. A person accused of smuggling cannot stop a criminal trial merely by paying an amnesty tax meant for undisclosed income or wealth, […]

Mandatory Title Notice Rule: SC Voids Defective Reconstitution

Land title reconstitution is void when affected owners lack notice; courts must protect Torrens titles from doubtful overlapping claims. Property owners facing a land reconstitution case are not bound by a title proceeding that hides or omits them from notice. The Mandatory Title Notice Rule protects Torrens title holders and neighboring landowners from losing registered […]