When a Two-Sided Attack Becomes Murder: Why Superior Strength Can Replace Treachery in a Killing Case

A murder conviction was affirmed where coordinated attackers used superior strength, proving conspiracy despite claims that only one accused delivered fatal wounds. A person who helps surround and overpower a victim may be convicted for murder even if he claims he did not deliver the fatal blow. In criminal cases, coordinated action, the victimโ€™s wounds, […]

When Habeas Corpus Fails: Why a Defective Arrest Order Will Not Free a Detainee Facing Valid Court Charges

A defective arrest order will not free a detainee if separate valid court warrants independently justify custody. Dacuyan clarifies habeas corpus limits. A detainee cannot secure release through habeas corpus merely by attacking one defective arrest order if there are other valid court-issued warrants or pending criminal charges independently supporting the detention. The practical lesson […]

Sick Workers Do Not Lose Compensation Just Because They Try to Earn Money for Medicine

A sick worker who drives occasionally to buy medicine does not lose compensation when work conditions caused or aggravated pulmonary tuberculosis. A worker who becomes ill from conditions linked to his job does not automatically lose compensation merely because he later tries to earn money while sick. Where illness appears during employment and the employer […]

When Illness Appears at Work, Compensation Cannot Be Denied by Speculation

Illness during employment may be presumed compensable once a work link appears, shifting the burden to the employer to disprove work connection. An employee who becomes ill during the period of employment does not have to prove the full medical mechanics of how the job caused the disease before compensation may be awarded. Once a […]

When Illness Strikes at Work: Employees Can Recover Compensation Even After Returning to the Job

Employees may recover temporary disability compensation for illness during employment, even after returning to work, if the employer fails to rebut compensability. An employee who becomes ill during employment may still recover workmenโ€™s compensation even if she later gets well enough to return to work. The decisive point is not whether the employee permanently lost […]

When Local Courts May Still Investigate Libel Complaints Despite Special Venue Rules

Venue rules for libel complaints do not automatically remove a trial courtโ€™s authority to conduct preliminary investigation and determine probable cause. A person accused of libel cannot automatically stop a preliminary investigation merely because the complaint was filed in a Court of First Instance rather than before a city fiscal or local prosecutor. For lawyers, […]