Forthwith Does Not Always Mean Right Now: Supreme Court Limits Mandamus Against the Senate in Impeachment Proceedings

The Court dismissed a bid to compel an impeachment trial, holding that mandamus cannot control Senate discretion and “forthwith” allows reasonable preparation. A citizen may ask the courts to review whether the Senate has gravely abused its constitutional power in an impeachment proceeding, but cannot ordinarily use mandamus to force the Senate to convene and […]

Shari’ah High Court Moves Toward Operationalization: What the Supreme Court’s Budget Order Means for Bangsamoro Justice

Supreme Court orders budget and staffing preparation for the Shari’ah High Court, moving Bangsamoro Shari’ah appeals closer to full operation. Muslim litigants in the Bangsamoro are now one concrete administrative step closer to a functioning Shari’ah High Court, after the Supreme Court ordered its own administrative and budget offices to prepare the funding and staffing […]

COMELEC Cannot Cancel a Candidacy Through Generalized Nuisance-Candidate Labels

COMELEC must give specific factual and legal reasons before cancelling a candidacy as nuisance; generalized labels violate due process. Candidates who are branded as nuisance candidates must be told exactly what they did, what evidence proves it, and why those facts legally justify cancellation of their certificate of candidacy. The ruling in Diaz makes clear […]

When a Drug Charge Fails on Chain of Custody, But the Search Still Survives

Chain-of-custody defects defeated the drug-sale charge, but hidden sachets found during a lawful arrest sustained a separate possession conviction. A broken chain of custody can defeat a drug-sale conviction even when the police prove that a buy-bust transaction occurred; but evidence found during a lawful arrest may still support a separate possession conviction even if […]

COMELEC Cannot Let Election Overspending Cases Sleep for Six Years

COMELEC cannot delay election overspending investigations for six years; failure to file a counter-affidavit does not suspend speedy disposition rights. Election-offense investigations cannot be left unresolved for years simply because the respondent failed to file a counter-affidavit. When the COMELEC sits on a campaign overspending complaint far beyond its own procedural deadlines, and offers no […]

When a Criminal Trial Takes Too Long, the Case Can Be Dismissed

The Supreme Court acquitted accused persons after a nearly 17-year homicide trial violated their constitutional right to speedy trial. Accused persons may be acquitted when the State allows a criminal case to drag on for years through repeated postponements, absent witnesses, unavailable prosecutors, missing records, and poor case management. The right to a speedy trial […]

Hierarchy of Courts Rule: Why Direct Supreme Court Petitions Fail

Associations must prove member authority and direct injury before challenging regulations; fact-heavy cases cannot bypass lower courts. The hierarchy of courts rule can defeat even a high-profile constitutional challenge when the case depends on disputed facts and the petitioners cannot prove standing. For associations, the lesson is direct and practical: it is not enough to […]

Suffrage Due Process Rule: When Election Delays Become Unconstitutional

Election postponements must satisfy substantive due process; RA 11935 fell because it arbitrarily burdened Filipinos’ constitutional right of suffrage. Election postponements in the Philippines are no longer merely political scheduling decisions. Under the Suffrage Due Process Rule, Congress may generally legislate on election dates, including barangay election postponements, but it cannot delay elections in a […]

Expropriation Necessity First: SC Limits Writs of Possession

A writ of possession in expropriation cannot issue before courts hear timely challenges to authority, necessity, and statutory compliance. Expropriation Necessity First is the rule that a landowner cannot be forced out of property merely because an expropriating entity filed a complaint and deposited money, when the very authority and necessity for the taking are […]

Just Compensation Interest: Delayed Expropriation Payments Cost More

Delayed expropriation payment earns legal interest on unpaid just compensation despite provisional deposits, protecting landowners from underpayment. Landowners whose property is taken for public infrastructure are entitled not only to the judicially determined value of the land, but also to legal interest on the unpaid balance when full payment is delayed. This is the just […]