Assignees Beware: Taking Over a Lease Can Mean Taking Over Old Rental Debts

Assignees of commercial leases may inherit old rental arrears when the assignment broadly transfers all leasehold rights and obligations without clear exclusions. A business that takes over another person’s lease may inherit more than the right to occupy the premises. When the assignment says the assignee assumes all responsibilities and obligations under the lease, old […]

Statute of Frauds Ratification: Oral Land Deals Can Bind

Oral land transfers may be enforced when ratified by conduct, admissions, possession, improvements, and accepted benefits despite the Statute of Frauds. The Statute of Frauds Ratification Rule means that an oral agreement involving real property is not automatically worthless just because it was never reduced to writing. When the parties act on the agreement for […]

Carrier Courtesy Rule: Passenger Abuse Creates Airline Liability

Airlines may owe moral and exemplary damages when ticket breaches are aggravated by rude, humiliating treatment of passengers. Airline passengers may recover moral and exemplary damages when a carrier breaches the ticket terms and aggravates that breach through rude, humiliating, or abusive treatment by its employees. The Carrier Courtesy Rule matters because a passenger dispute […]

Effectual Contract Interpretation: When a Land Deal Is Only a Lease

Ambiguous land agreements must be read to preserve legality; the Court treated the disputed property arrangement as a lease, not a sale. Effectual Contract Interpretation protects parties from having an ambiguous property agreement converted into an illegal sale when the document, the parties’ conduct, and the law point instead to a lease. For property owners, […]

Courts Can Cut Unsupported Damage Awards Even When an Appeal Was Almost Lost on Technicalities

Property buyers may recover proven losses, but speculative construction costs cannot support compensatory damages in Philippine real estate fraud cases. Property buyers who are deceived in a land sale may recover what they actually paid and may receive moral or exemplary damages in proper cases, but courts will not award speculative construction losses simply because […]

Settlement Offers Cannot Become Court Judgments Without Acceptance

Failed settlement talks cannot become a court judgment; courts may not grant years of extra time under Article 1191 without just cause. A party cannot be forced into a settlement simply because negotiations once reached the courtroom. Roman v. Court of Appeals teaches a practical litigation rule with direct consequences for civil, property, and tax-related […]

Buying Land With an Occupant? Why Good Faith Matters in Warranty Against Eviction Claims

A land buyer who knew an occupant claimed part of the property could not recover as a good-faith vendee, but received limited compensation to prevent unjust enrichment. A buyer who knowingly purchases land despite an existing possession dispute cannot later demand warranty against eviction as if the risk were hidden from him. The ruling teaches […]

When a Life Story Becomes a Film: Privacy, Public Figures, and the Enforceability of Licensing Agreements

A film producer remained bound by a life-story licensing agreement despite privacy and free-speech defenses, with accounting and payment obligations enforced. A person who signs a licensing agreement for the commercial use of a public figure’s life story cannot later escape payment simply by arguing that the film violated privacy or free-speech principles, especially where […]