Seafarers Injured During Onboard Recreation May Recover Disability Benefits

Seafarers injured during sanctioned onboard recreation may recover disability benefits if employers fail to issue and furnish a valid medical assessment. Seafarers injured while joining an onboard recreational activity may still be treated as injured in the course of employment when the activity is sanctioned, customary, or connected to shipboard life. The Supreme Court confirmed […]

Taxpayers May Challenge Void BIR Assessments Even After Property Levy and Forfeiture

Taxpayers and heirs may challenge BIR levy and forfeiture when the underlying assessment and collection proceedings are void for lack of due process. Taxpayers and heirs facing BIR collection measures against real property should not assume that a levy, tax lien, forfeiture, or transfer of title ends the dispute. When the taxpayerโ€™s real complaint is […]

Forthwith Does Not Always Mean Right Now: Supreme Court Limits Mandamus Against the Senate in Impeachment Proceedings

The Court dismissed a bid to compel an impeachment trial, holding that mandamus cannot control Senate discretion and โ€œforthwithโ€ allows reasonable preparation. A citizen may ask the courts to review whether the Senate has gravely abused its constitutional power in an impeachment proceeding, but cannot ordinarily use mandamus to force the Senate to convene and […]

Silent Dysfunction Can Void a Marriage: Supreme Court Clarifies Psychological Incapacity in Annulment Cases

Supreme Court affirms nullity where silent dysfunction and enduring psychological incapacity made genuine married life impossible from the start. A marriage may be declared void even without violence, infidelity, or dramatic abuse when the evidence shows a deep, enduring psychological incapacity that made genuine married life impossible from the start. The Supreme Courtโ€™s ruling in […]

A Mistaken Death Certificate Does Not Stop a Living Property Owner From Filing Ejectment

A mistaken death certificate does not bar a living owner from filing ejectment when courts can provisionally decide capacity and possession. A person wrongly recorded as dead in the civil registry may still sue to recover possession of property if the court is satisfied, for purposes of the ejectment case, that he is alive and […]

When Corporate Factions Fight, Courts May Still Enforce Ejectment Rights

Corporate factions do not automatically stop ejectment when a court-recognized board withdraws an occupantโ€™s authority and proves unlawful detainer. A corporation that owns property may still recover possession through unlawful detainer even while rival factions contest control, so long as the group acting for the corporation is the one courts presently recognize as authorized to […]

Court Employees Can Be Fined for Smoking or Vaping Inside Court Premises

Court personnel may be fined for smoking or vaping inside court premises, while unsupported misconduct claims still require substantial evidence. Smoking or vaping inside court premises is not a minor workplace lapse for judiciary personnel: it is an administrative offense that can lead to a substantial fine, even if the act involved a vape device […]

When Similar Trademarks Can Coexist: Why Hotels Cannot Automatically Block Appliance Brands

The Supreme Court held that similar dominant trademarks may coexist when goods and services are not related enough to cause source confusion. Trademark owners cannot stop every later business from using a similar word merely because they registered it first. A prior mark, even one built around a distinctive or arbitrary word, blocks a later […]

Bigamy Charges Can Fail When the First Marriage Was Void From the Start

An accused in a bigamy case may challenge a void first marriage directly in the criminal case. Missing marriage-license proof led to acquittal. A person accused of bigamy may directly challenge the validity of the supposed first marriage in the criminal case itself, and a separate annulment or nullity case is not always required. Where […]

Resignation Defeats Constructive Dismissal Claims When Workplace Bullying Is Not Proven Against the Employer

Resignation may defeat a constructive dismissal claim when the employee fails to prove employer knowledge, inaction, coercion, or fraud in the quitclaim. Employees who resign because of alleged workplace bullying must still prove that the employer knew of the misconduct and refused to act; without that evidence, a resignation letter, final pay, and a valid […]