Silent Dysfunction Can Void a Marriage: Supreme Court Clarifies Psychological Incapacity in Annulment Cases

Supreme Court affirms nullity where silent dysfunction and enduring psychological incapacity made genuine married life impossible from the start. A marriage may be declared void even without violence, infidelity, or dramatic abuse when the evidence shows a deep, enduring psychological incapacity that made genuine married life impossible from the start. The Supreme Court’s ruling in […]

Bigamy Charges Can Fail When the First Marriage Was Void From the Start

An accused in a bigamy case may challenge a void first marriage directly in the criminal case. Missing marriage-license proof led to acquittal. A person accused of bigamy may directly challenge the validity of the supposed first marriage in the criminal case itself, and a separate annulment or nullity case is not always required. Where […]

Forgery Claims Cannot Erase a Marriage Certificate Without Clear and Convincing Proof

A marriage certificate cannot be cancelled by denial alone; alleged forgery must be proven by clear and convincing evidence in a proper adversarial proceeding. A person who discovers an unexpected marriage record cannot erase that record by denial alone: because a marriage certificate is a public document, a claim that the signature was forged must […]

When Can a Marriage Without a License Still Be Valid in the Philippines?

A spouse who signed a notarized cohabitation affidavit failed to void the marriage or prove psychological incapacity under Philippine family law. A spouse who signed a notarized affidavit of five-year cohabitation cannot later defeat the marriage by simply saying the affidavit was false, unread, or misunderstood. The ruling reinforces a practical doctrine for annulment and […]

Private Custody Is Not a Shortcut to Adoption: Why DSWD Clearance Still Matters

Private custody does not bypass adoption safeguards. The Court held that a surrendered child may need DSWD certification before adoption can proceed. A parent who personally turns over a child to a prospective adopter cannot bypass child-protection safeguards by calling the arrangement private custody. When a child is voluntarily surrendered to another person, the adoption […]

A Nullity Case Will Not Pause a Bigamy Trial in the Philippines

A pending nullity case will not suspend a bigamy prosecution; the accused must prove a void-marriage defense in the criminal trial itself. A spouse accused of bigamy cannot stop the criminal case merely by filing a separate petition to declare an earlier marriage void. If the accused believes the first marriage never legally existed, that […]

Bigamy Charges Fail When the First Marriage Was Not Proven Valid

Bigamy conviction reversed after the prosecution failed to prove a valid first marriage and the accused’s identity beyond reasonable doubt. A person accused of bigamy may defeat the charge by showing reasonable doubt as to the validity of the alleged first marriage or even as to whether he was the person who contracted it. In […]

Seafarer Death Benefits Rule: Who Gets Paid After Bigamy

POEA seafarer death benefits go to the legal spouse and children, not a void bigamous spouse, with shares fixed by succession law in the Philippines. Seafarer death benefits are not automatically estate property, and a named or practical spouse in a void bigamous marriage may still lose the money to the legal spouse and children. […]

DNA Evidence Can Open the Door to Correcting a Child’s Birth Certificate and Proving True Paternity

DNA evidence may support a Rule 108 petition to prove true paternity and correct birth records despite the presumption of legitimacy. A biological father is not automatically barred from proving paternity simply because the child was born while the mother was still legally married to another man. Where the child’s recorded legitimacy conflicts with scientific […]