Senior Citizen Discounts Are a Police Power Burden, Not a Tax Refund Right

Businesses must honor senior citizen discounts; the Supreme Court upheld tax deduction treatment as police power, not a compensable taking. Businesses required to give the 20% senior citizen discount cannot demand peso-for-peso reimbursement from the government merely because the discount reduces revenue. The Supreme Court treated the mandatory discount and its tax deduction treatment as […]

Senior Citizen Discounts Can Be Full Tax Credits for Older Tax Years

Senior citizen discounts under the original RA 7432 may be claimed as full tax credits if proven, not merely as acquisition-cost deductions. Businesses that were required to give statutory senior citizen discounts under the original Senior Citizens Act may recover the full amount of the proven discount as a tax credit, not merely the acquisition […]

When Pass-Through Hotel Payments Are Not Taxable Gross Receipts of a Travel Agency

Travel agencies are not taxed on hotel room payments held in trust for hotels; only their own fees or compensation form taxable gross receipts. Travel agencies and service businesses are not automatically taxed on every peso that briefly passes through their hands. When a business merely receives money in trust for another party and has […]

When Store Security Goes Too Far: False Shoplifting Accusations Can Create Civil Liability

A supermarket may investigate suspected shoplifting, but public humiliation and false accusation can trigger moral damages when the facts show innocent mistake. Retailers may protect their goods, but they cannot turn loss prevention into public humiliation. A customer wrongly accused of shoplifting may recover damages when store personnel detain, interrogate, shame, or penalize him without […]

Penalty Hikes Cannot Reach Back: Why Older Fraud Cases Stay Under the Law in Force When the Act Was Done

Penalty increases cannot be applied retroactively to older fraud cases; jurisdiction depends on the penalty in force when the alleged act occurred. Criminal penalty increases do not automatically make older conduct more serious in court. When an alleged fraud or bouncing-check offense was committed before a harsher penalty law took effect, prosecutors and judges must […]

Crushed Stone Is Not a Mineral Product for Sales Tax Exemption

Crushed rocks used for construction are not exempt mineral products, so quarry operators may owe sales tax and must observe strict refund appeal deadlines. Quarry operators cannot claim a sales tax exemption for crushed rocks merely by calling them mineral products. Where the stone is used for road foundation, cement aggregate, building, or construction purposes, […]

Marriage Does Not Let Partners Collapse a Limited Partnership for Tax Purposes

A valid limited partnership remains a separate taxable entity despite marriage of the partners; the BIR cannot treat genuine partnership income as spousal income. A limited partnership remains a separate taxable entity even when its only remaining partners become husband and wife. For taxpayers, the practical consequence is direct: marriage does not automatically dissolve a […]