Tax Withholding Does Not Automatically Make Someone an Employee

Tax withholding alone does not prove employment. The Court applied the control test and protected an agent with business interest from arbitrary revocation. Tax treatment can be powerful evidence in a labor or commercial dispute, but it does not end the inquiry: a person who receives commissions, operates through her own clientele, and bears business […]

Foreign Dividend Tax Refunds Require Proof of Actual Tax-Sparing Benefit

Philippine dividend tax refunds based on tax-sparing credits require proof that the foreign parent actually qualified for the foreign tax credit. Philippine subsidiaries claiming a refund or tax credit on dividends paid to a foreign parent must prove more than the existence of a treaty-like or statutory tax-sparing clause. They must show that the foreign […]

Tax Declarations Cannot Convert Mineral Land Into Private Agricultural Property

Tax declarations and possession cannot defeat perfected mining claims or convert mineral public land into private agricultural property under the Regalian doctrine. Tax declarations and long occupation may help prove possession, but they cannot convert mineral land of the public domain into private agricultural property when perfected mining claims and the State’s ownership of natural […]

Tax Declarations Do Not Prove Land Ownership When the Land Is Public Forest Land

Tax declarations and real property tax receipts may evidence a land claim, but they do not conclusively prove ownership or overcome public forest land classification. Tax declarations and real property tax receipts may support a claim of ownership, but they do not by themselves convert public land into private property. For landowners, developers, and buyers, […]