When Employers Stay Silent, Workers’ Compensation Claims Can Become Practically Unanswerable

Employers that fail to timely contest work injury claims may waive defenses, allowing death benefits when compensability is presumed. Employers who fail to timely contest a work injury or death claim may lose more than a procedural deadline: they may forfeit the right to dispute compensability itself. In Caleb, the Court treated the employer’s silence […]

When an Employee Falls Ill at Work, Technical Defaults Cannot Defeat Compensation Claims

Employee illness during work is presumed compensable when the employer fails to timely controvert, but benefits depend on the specific claim filed. Employees and their families may still recover workmen’s compensation even when a claim has procedural defects, especially where the employer knew of the illness, failed to timely controvert the claim, and the record […]

When an Employer Fails to Contest a Compensation Claim on Time, It May Lose the Right to Fight It

Failure to timely contest a worker’s compensation claim can waive employer defenses and support disability and death benefits for the worker’s heirs. Employers that ignore or delay contesting a workmen’s compensation claim may lose the right to dispute it altogether, including the right to argue that the illness or death was not work-related. For employees […]

When a Work Injury Award Becomes Final, the Agency Cannot Reopen Liability

A teacher’s work injury award was reinstated after the Commission wrongly reopened compensability when only the amount of disability benefits was under review. When a compensation award has become final on the issue of compensability, the reviewing body cannot later erase the claim by deciding an issue the parties no longer raised. For injured workers […]

When a Court Cannot Add Interest After Judgment: The Void Execution Rule

A writ of execution cannot add legal interest when the final judgment did not award it; such excess enforcement is void and not cured by estoppel. A losing party cannot be forced to pay interest through execution if the final judgment itself did not award interest. The rule is simple but powerful: execution must follow […]

Judges May Protect Tax Interests in Land Title Cases, But Must Keep Courtroom Conduct Professional

A judge may protect government tax interests in land title execution, but courtroom authority does not excuse insulting or offensive conduct toward lawyers. Courts handling land title disputes may take protective steps to preserve the government’s tax interests, including requiring a bond before execution of a judgment affecting property, but judges remain bound by the […]

When a Criminal Case Can Be Revived Without a New Information

A provisional criminal dismissal with the accused’s consent may be revived without a new information if the order clearly lacks finality. A criminal case provisionally dismissed with the accused’s express consent may still be revived without filing a new information, so long as the dismissal order itself makes clear that it is not final and […]

When a Property Injunction Becomes Moot: Why Courts Will Not Decide a Possession Dispute That No Longer Exists

A certiorari petition attacking a possession injunction was dismissed as moot after respondents disclaimed possession and allowed cultivation pending trial. A party cannot keep a certiorari case alive after the opposing side formally abandons the very act being challenged. When the controversy disappears, the court will not spend judicial time deciding an interlocutory fight that […]

When Sharp Pleadings Become Contempt: What Tax Litigants Should Know About Courtroom Advocacy

A lawyer may challenge an unfair order, but insulting language can be contempt. The Supreme Court lifted an excessive suspension and restored rebuttal evidence. Lawyers and litigants may challenge a judge’s ruling, even forcefully, but the challenge must remain within the bounds of respect for the court. Calo v. Judge Tapucar draws the line between […]

A Renewed CBA Cannot Block a Certification Election When It Was Signed Too Early

A prematurely renewed CBA cannot block a certification election when it frustrates employees’ right to choose their bargaining representative. Rank-and-file employees cannot be locked into a bargaining representative by a collective bargaining agreement rushed into existence before the law’s certification-election window. When management and an incumbent union renew a CBA ahead of the prescribed freedom […]