When Leaving Work Becomes Abandonment: Why Reinstatement Is Not a Safety Net After a Failed Job Search

A worker who left after a disapproved indefinite leave could not demand reinstatement; labor protection does not excuse abandonment of work. Employees who abandon work to look for another job cannot later use reinstatement as a fallback remedy when the search fails. Sandoval Shipyards teaches a practical but often overlooked labor-law point: social justice protects […]

Self-Defense Does Not Require Perfect Proportionality When the Threat Is Immediate

The Court acquitted an accused who used a gun against an armed attacker, holding that self-defense does not require exact weapon proportionality. A person who reacts to an imminent armed attack is not judged by the calm arithmetic of hindsight. In Lacson, the Court recognized a practical self-defense rule: when danger is sudden, real, and […]

A Cash Appeal Bond Filed on Time Should Not Be Defeated by Court Inaction

Timely filing of a cash appeal bond perfects an appeal; court delay in approving the bond should not defeat a litigant’s right to review. An appeal should not be lost merely because the trial court failed to approve a cash appeal bond within the reglementary period. When the appellant files the notice of appeal, record […]

Holding the Victim Can Make You Liable as a Principal in Homicide

Holding a victim during a fatal attack can make a person liable as a principal in homicide when the act enables the killing and shows common criminal purpose. Someone who does not personally deliver the fatal blow may still be convicted as a principal in homicide when his act directly enables the killing. The key […]

Court Employees Can Be Dismissed for Concealing a Criminal Conviction and Trying to Influence Cases

Court personnel may be dismissed for concealing a conviction, interfering in pending cases, and making false sworn statements about their record. Public officers and court employees can lose their government career not only for mishandling records or violating office rules, but also for lying about their criminal history and using their position to interfere with […]

Buying Land With an Occupant? Why Good Faith Matters in Warranty Against Eviction Claims

A land buyer who knew an occupant claimed part of the property could not recover as a good-faith vendee, but received limited compensation to prevent unjust enrichment. A buyer who knowingly purchases land despite an existing possession dispute cannot later demand warranty against eviction as if the risk were hidden from him. The ruling teaches […]

When a Bank Becomes Liable for a Security Guard’s Work Injury Compensation

A bank hiring agency guards was liable as statutory employer for death benefits, but the security agency had to reimburse it under their contract. A business that hires agency personnel may still be treated as the worker’s statutory employer for workmen’s compensation, even if the service contract says the worker belongs exclusively to the agency. […]

When a Teacher’s Illness Becomes Compensable: Work-Related Disease, Presumptions, and Government Liability

A teacher’s illness during employment was presumed compensable, with the employer’s failure to timely controvert treated as waiver of defenses. Employees who become seriously ill while in public service may still recover compensation even when the disease was not caused by a single workplace accident, because Philippine compensation law treats illness during employment as presumptively […]

Foreclosed Property Can Still Be Redeemed When Registration Starts the Clock

Foreclosure redemption runs from registration of the sheriff’s certificate, affecting adverse claims, title transfers, and tax-sensitive real estate deals. Property buyers, banks, and taxpayers dealing with foreclosed real estate should not assume that the redemption period begins on the auction date. For extrajudicial foreclosure, the Supreme Court treated registration of the sheriff’s certificate of sale […]