When Child Testimony Convicts but Death Penalty Fails: The Rule on Proof in Incestuous Rape Cases

Child testimony sustained a rape conviction, but the death penalty was reduced because minority was not proved with the certainty required in qualified rape. A rape conviction may rest on the clear and credible testimony of a child victim, but the harshest penalty cannot be imposed unless every qualifying circumstance, including minority and relationship, is […]

When Rape Testimony Fails the Credibility Test, Presumption of Innocence Controls

Rape testimony may convict only when credible under the full record. Eliarda reversed a conviction because reasonable doubt remained on force and consent. An accusation of rape, standing alone, does not overcome the constitutional presumption of innocence when the testimony offered to prove force, intimidation, or lack of consent becomes materially weak, improbable, or inconsistent […]

Judges Are Not Liable for Every Wrong Order: Supreme Court Reaffirms Good Faith Protection in Judicial Decisions

The Supreme Court held that judicial error alone is not misconduct; parties must use appeals or certiorari unless fraud, bad faith, or corruption is proven. A judgeโ€™s mistaken ruling is not automatically judicial misconduct. Parties who believe a court order is wrong must ordinarily challenge it through appeal, certiorari, or other judicial remediesโ€”not by turning […]

When a Victimโ€™s Testimony Can Convict: Credibility, Corroboration, and the Limits of the Death Penalty in Rape Cases

Victim testimony can sustain rape conviction, but death or qualified rape penalties require independent proof of qualifying facts like minority and relationship. A rape conviction may rest on the victimโ€™s clear, credible, and consistent testimony even when medical findings are not conclusive, the assault happened inside a crowded home, or the victim did not immediately […]

Sequestered Shares Do Not Give the Government Automatic Control of a Corporation

Sequestration preserves disputed shares but does not automatically let the PCGG vote them or control a corporation without proof of ill-gotten wealth and dissipation risk. Sequestration does not make the government the owner of private shares, and the PCGG cannot use seized stock to control a corporation unless it first shows both a prima facie […]

Tax Declarations Do Not Decide Which Court Hears an Expropriation Case

Assessed value in a tax declaration does not control jurisdiction in expropriation cases; RTCs hear eminent domain actions despite low declared property values. A landowner cannot defeat an expropriation case merely by pointing to the propertyโ€™s low assessed value in the tax declaration. In eminent domain proceedings, jurisdiction belongs to the Regional Trial Court because […]

RMC No. 22-2003: Lost Certificate Authorizing Registration Form Cancelled and Transactions Using CAR200100009927 Declared Invalid

RMC No. 22-2003 cancelled lost BIR Form No. 1954 CAR200100009927 and declared transactions using it invalid for official purposes. Businesses, taxpayers, transferors, transferees, accountants, and persons processing property or asset registrations must not accept or use BIR Form No. 1954, Certificate Authorizing Registration, with Serial Number CAR200100009927. RMC No. 22-2003 cancelled this specific unused original […]

RMO No. 13-2003: Provisional Use of BIR Printed Receipts and Invoices for Businesses Without Authorized Receipts, Invoices, CRM, or POS Permits

RMO No. 13-2003 allows provisional BIR Printed Receipts/Invoices for first-time receipt, invoice, CRM, or POS violations during TCVD. Businesses found during a Tax Compliance Verification Drive without duly authorized receipts, invoices, cash register machines, point-of-sale machines, or similar devices may be allowed to continue operating only on a provisional basis, through BIR Printed Receipts/Invoices. RMO […]

RMC No. 25-2003: Lost and Cancelled BIR Tax Verification Notices Under BIR Form No. 0421

RMC No. 25-2003 cancels four lost BIR Form No. 0421 Tax Verification Notices and invalidates transactions using their serial numbers. Businesses, accountants, and tax personnel should reject and treat as invalid any Tax Verification Notice under BIR Form No. 0421 bearing serial numbers TVN200100007628, TVN200100007630, TVN200100007632, or TVN200100007634. RMC No. 25-2003 cancels these four unused […]

Judges Cannot Use Administrative Referral Rules to Escape Criminal Cases

A judge cannot use administrative referral rules to avoid a criminal case. The Court fined a trial judge for gross ignorance of the law. Administrative referral rules for complaints against judges do not erase criminal jurisdiction. When a judge is charged in a criminal case, the trial court may proceed if the offense falls within […]