Sheriffs Cannot Improvise Enforcement Outside Their Territory

A sheriff who enforced a writ outside his territory by deputizing police was fined for abuse of authority, reinforcing strict rules on lawful writ execution. Court sheriffs may not shortcut the enforcement of writs by deputizing police officers or acting outside their assigned territory without following the required procedure. For litigants, creditors, property owners, and […]

Stock Buyers Cannot Vote Until the Stock Certificate Is Properly Endorsed and Delivered

Share transferees cannot vote or challenge corporate elections without proper endorsement, delivery, and recording of stock transfers in corporate books. A person who buys or receives shares in a Philippine corporation does not automatically acquire the right to vote, attend stockholdersโ€™ meetings, or challenge corporate elections unless the transfer complies with the formal requirements for […]

RR No. 13-2001: Rules on BIR Abatement or Cancellation of Tax Liabilities, Surcharges, Interest, and Compromise Penalties

RR No. 13-2001 sets when the BIR may abate or cancel tax liabilities, surcharges, interest, and compromise penalties for meritorious taxpayers. Taxpayers facing BIR assessments, surcharges, interest, or compromise penalties may have a formal basis to request abatement or cancellation when the assessment is unjust, excessive, or uneconomical for the government to collect. RR No. […]

When Courts Will Not Undo a Religious Corporationโ€™s Expulsion of Members

Religious corporation expulsions are generally beyond civil court review when based on doctrine, but courts may intervene for fraud, bad faith, or civil rights. Members of a religious corporation cannot usually ask civil courts to reverse their expulsion merely because they disagree with church discipline, especially when the controversy turns on faith, doctrine, membership, and […]

When a Lawyer Loses Track of a Case, the Client Does Not Lose the Right to Accountability

Clients may hold lawyers accountable for neglecting a case, failing to give updates, and losing track of litigation, including return of fees. A lawyer who accepts a case must carry it to its conclusion, keep the client informed, and cannot escape discipline by saying that he forgot, became busy, or relied on the client to […]

When a Lawyer Uses Cases as Revenge: The Rule Against Vindictive Litigation

A lawyer may be suspended for filing multiple complaints as retaliation, because vindictive litigation reflects unfitness to practice law. Lawyers may be disciplined not only for courtroom misconduct, but also for using the legal system itself as a weapon of harassment. The doctrine from the Saburnido ruling is simple but powerful: a lawyer who files […]

Judges Who Miss the 90-Day Decision Deadline Can Still Be Fined After Retirement

Judges who fail to decide submitted cases within the 90-day period may be fined for gross inefficiency, even after retirement. Courts do not treat delayed decisions as a mere internal scheduling problem: a judge who fails to decide submitted cases within the constitutional period may be held administratively liable and fined, even when the audit […]

Court Employees Can Be Suspended for Abusive Conduct Inside the Courthouse

Court personnel may be suspended for abusive or violent courthouse conduct that undermines public trust, even when the incident begins as an office dispute. People who deal with the courts are entitled to more than correct orders and timely hearings; they are entitled to be treated with dignity by every court employee, from the judge […]

Drinking on Duty Can Cost Court Employees Six Monthsโ€™ Pay โ€” But Judges Cannot Suspend Staff on Their Own

Court employees may face six-month suspension for drinking on duty and defying discipline, but judges must refer preventive suspension to the Supreme Court. Court employees who drink during office hours, sleep at work, or openly defy lawful workplace discipline may be suspended even for a first offense; but a judge who wants to preventively suspend […]