Expired Distribution Agreements Cannot Be Used to Foreclose Old Collateral

A mortgage tied to an expired distributorship agreement cannot secure later debts absent proof of renewal, making the foreclosure void. A creditor cannot foreclose real property merely because a debtor still owes money if the mortgage secured only obligations under an expired, unproven, or unrenewed contract. For businesses, distributors, landowners, and third-party mortgagors, the ruling […]

When a Judge Gets the Law Wrong: Why Judicial Error Is Not Automatically Misconduct

The Supreme Court held that a judge’s erroneous or inconsistent order is not misconduct absent gross ignorance, bad faith, dishonesty, fraud, or corruption. Judges may commit reversible error without being administratively punished, so long as the mistake is not a blatant disregard of basic law and is not attended by bad faith, dishonesty, fraud, corruption, […]

Well-Known Brands Can Block Copycat Trademarks Even in Unrelated Products

The Supreme Court held that a well-known registered trademark may block use on unrelated goods when it suggests connection and causes dilution. Businesses cannot safely adopt a famous brand name merely by placing it on a different product line. When a trademark is well-known and registered in the Philippines, a later applicant may be refused […]

Foreign Investment Questions Must Go Through the SEC Before Reaching Court

The Supreme Court ruled that companies cannot seek court pre-clearance for vague foreign investment plans without a ripe controversy and prior SEC process. Companies cannot ask courts to pre-clear a possible foreign investment based only on a vague future transaction. When a business wants to know whether foreign ownership limits apply, it must first present […]

Corporate Check Signatories Are Not Automatically Personally Liable After a BP 22 Acquittal

Corporate check signatories acquitted of BP 22 are not automatically personally liable for the check value; creditors must sue the proper debtor. A company officer or authorized signatory who signs a corporate check is not automatically personally liable for the check’s value after being acquitted of a BP 22 charge. If the criminal case fails, […]

Foreign Suppliers Using Local Indentors Can Still Sue in Philippine Courts

Foreign suppliers using independent Philippine indentors are not automatically doing business locally and may sue to collect unpaid cross-border sales. Foreign companies that sell goods to Philippine buyers through a bona fide local indentor do not automatically become unlicensed foreign corporations barred from suing in Philippine courts. The controlling lesson is practical: a local buyer, […]

Payment Extensions Do Not Automatically Erase Trust Receipt Criminal Liability

A payment extension did not novate trust receipt obligations; officers may still face estafa for failing to remit sale proceeds or return goods. Corporate officers who sign trust receipts cannot assume that a later payment schedule, restructuring, or partial settlement will automatically convert the transaction into an ordinary loan and eliminate exposure to estafa. When […]

More Specialized Trial Courts Mean Faster Access for Commercial, Cybercrime, and Competition Cases

Additional RTC branches were designated as specialized courts, giving businesses and litigants broader access to commercial, cybercrime, and competition forums. Businesses, intellectual property owners, distressed companies, online fraud victims, and parties in competition-law disputes gained a wider network of specialized Regional Trial Courts where their cases may be filed and heard. The practical doctrine is […]