When a New Lawful Lease Makes an Old Possession Case Moot

A later lawful lease from the property owner made an earlier possession order moot, but damages and indemnity for destroyed improvements remained payable. A party who later obtains lawful possession from the real owner of the property cannot be forced to surrender that same property merely because of an earlier possessory judgment. The practical doctrine […]

When One Judge Is Not Enough: Why Reconsideration Must Be Decided by the Proper Tribunal

A single judge cannot deny reconsideration when the law requires en banc action. The ruling warns taxpayers and businesses to verify proper tribunal authority. A motion for reconsideration is not a mere formality when the law requires a collegial body to act. If a court or administrative tribunal must decide en banc, a ruling issued […]

One-Day Appeal Delay Should Not Defeat Substantial Justice

A one-day appeal delay may be excused when there is substantial compliance, good faith, no prejudice, and dismissal would sacrifice justice to technicality. A one-day delay in filing an appeal record should not automatically destroy a party’s right to appellate review when the appellant substantially complied with the rules, acted in good faith, caused no […]

When Silence Can Convict: Admission by Silence, Conspiracy, and Attempted Murder in Philippine Criminal Cases

Silence during a direct criminal accusation may be treated as admission, while injury severity can reduce frustrated murder to attempted murder. An accused person who stays silent when directly identified in his presence may face a powerful evidentiary consequence: silence can be treated as an implied admission when an innocent person would naturally deny the […]

Returning to Jail Does Not Waive Your Criminal Appeal

A detained accused who returns to jail after conviction does not automatically waive appeal when a timely notice of appeal is filed within the Rules of Court period. An accused person who is taken back to jail after conviction does not automatically lose the right to appeal. Flores v. Judge Dalisay protects a basic but […]

When a Court-Approved Compromise Ends the Case: Why Settlement Compliance Is a Separate Fight

Court-approved compromise may close litigation even if compliance is disputed, making timely enforcement of settlement terms critical for businesses. A court-approved compromise can end litigation even when questions remain about whether every settlement obligation has already been performed. For businesses, license holders, and parties settling regulatory disputes, the lesson is direct: once a judicial compromise […]