When Illness Strikes at Work, Employers Must Prove It Is Not Work-Related

Illness arising during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer proves otherwise, shifting the burden in workplace compensation disputes. An employee who becomes ill while still employed does not always carry the full burden of proving exactly how work caused the illness. Under the compensability presumption applied in Tambasen, once the illness supervenes during employment, […]

Influence Fees Are Not Enforceable Business Expenses: When Commissions for Government Favor Become Void

A commission tied to political influence over government dollar allocations was void, warning businesses against treating influence fees as enforceable expenses. Businesses cannot enforce a commission agreement when the real bargain is payment for political influence over government action. Even if the payment is described as a sales commission, consultancy fee, facilitation fee, or business […]

A Dollar Payment Clause May Be Illegal, But the Debt Itself Can Still Be Collected in Pesos

A dollar-payment clause may be void, but a real debt can still be collected in pesos. Ponce clarifies recovery of foreign-currency-linked obligations. Creditors are not automatically left unpaid just because a loan arrangement involved payment in U.S. dollars. The controlling rule is practical and equitable: an illegal foreign-currency payment clause may be void, but the […]

Union-Requested Dismissals Still Require Due Process: Employers Cannot Fire Workers Blindly

Employers cannot automatically dismiss workers on a union’s request; due process remains required, with reinstatement and backwages for bad-faith termination. Employers cannot hide behind a union request or a maintenance-of-membership clause to dismiss workers without first giving them a fair chance to be heard. When management acts hastily, ignores the circumstances behind a union expulsion, […]

When Lost Earnings Are Computed from Net Income, Not Gross Salary

Lost earning capacity in wrongful death cases is based on net income, not gross salary, after deducting living expenses. Families claiming damages for the wrongful death of a breadwinner cannot simply multiply the victim’s full salary by the remaining years of expected life. The recoverable amount for loss of earning capacity is based on net […]

Jailed for Contempt Without a Lawyer? Flores Says Habeas Corpus Can Set You Free

A contempt order that jails a person without counsel may be attacked by habeas corpus, especially where property possession facts remain unclear. A person jailed for indirect contempt may be released through habeas corpus when the contempt proceeding violated the constitutional right to counsel. Flores v. Judge Ruiz teaches that contempt may look like a […]

Estate Creditors Cannot Expand Heirs’ Personal Liability Beyond What They Expressly Assumed

Heirs are personally liable only for estate debts they clearly assumed; unfiled probate claims remain barred against the estate. Creditors dealing with an estate cannot bypass probate deadlines by suing heirs personally unless the heirs clearly and expressly assumed the particular debt. The practical lesson is sharp: payment of estate taxes and approval of partition […]

When a Public Officer Is Already Dismissed, a Later Administrative Complaint May Become Moot

A later administrative complaint may be dismissed as moot when the officer was already removed from service with forfeiture of benefits in an earlier case. A second administrative complaint against a public officer may be dismissed as moot when the same respondent has already been found guilty in an earlier administrative case and removed from […]

Tax Declarations Can Help Expose Fake Sales and Simulated Property Transfers

Tax declarations, possession, and unpaid rent or interest helped prove a deed of sale and mortgage were simulated, void, and ineffective to transfer land ownership. Property owners and heirs can defeat a written deed of sale or mortgage when the surrounding facts show that the document was only a paper device, not a real transfer. […]