Manila Local Business Tax Refund Increased After Presumptive Assessment Was Rejected

Taxpayer wins higher Manila local business tax refund after the Court rejected an unsupported presumptive income assessment and applied the preferential rate. Businesses assessed by local treasurers using presumptive income figures should not accept a bare billing statement as final when the city fails to disclose the ordinance-based factors, computation, or income levels used. In […]

ROHQ VAT Refunds Can Fail Without Complete NRFC Proof and Clean Invoices

A Manila ROHQ sought a P12.6M VAT refund but recovered only P12,691.99 after substantiation, NRFC proof, and invoicing defects reduced the claim. Regional operating headquarters and service exporters claiming VAT refunds must be prepared to prove every peso of zero-rated sales and input tax with complete client documentation, BSP-compliant foreign currency payments, and invoices or […]

Paying a Disputed BIR Surcharge Can End the Fight Over Abatement

Payment of a disputed BIR surcharge led the tax court to treat the abatement dispute as moot, leaving no live controversy to resolve. Taxpayers challenging a BIR surcharge should be careful before paying the disputed amount, because payment may be treated as acquiescence to the assessment and may leave the Court of Tax Appeals with […]

Tax Acquittal Stands When the Prosecution Fails to Prove Both the Crime and the Tax Due

A corporate officer’s tax acquittal stood after prosecutors failed to prove both the criminal charge and the alleged civil tax liability with competent evidence. Corporate officers facing criminal tax cases may avoid both conviction and a civil tax payment order when the prosecution fails to present competent documentary evidence proving the alleged deficiency tax, not […]

Missed FDDA Protest Deadlines Can End a Tax Assessment Case Before the Merits Are Heard

A late motion for reconsideration of an FDDA made the BIR assessment final, leaving the tax court without jurisdiction to hear the taxpayer’s appeal. Taxpayers who receive a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment must act within the 30-day period fixed by the tax rules, because a late administrative reconsideration can make the assessment final and […]

Withdrawing a Tax Assessment Appeal Can Make the BIR Assessment Final

Taxpayers who withdraw a tax assessment appeal to seek compromise may close the case, but the challenged BIR issuances become final and executory despite settlement talks. Taxpayers who ask to withdraw a tax assessment appeal because they want to pursue an administrative compromise must understand the trade-off: the court case may be closed, but the […]

Late Motions for Reconsideration Can End BIR Assessment Appeals Before the Merits Are Reopened

A late BIR motion for reconsideration was denied, reinforcing strict CTA deadlines, OSG receipt rules, and proper filing modes in tax assessment cases. Taxpayers facing BIR assessment litigation should pay close attention not only to the substance of a tax appeal, but also to the filing mechanics after judgment. A motion for reconsideration filed beyond […]

BIR Assessments Can Be Voided When Taxpayer Protests Are Not Meaningfully Addressed

The tax court cancelled a Php158.4M BIR assessment after finding that the taxpayer’s protest arguments were not meaningfully addressed. Taxpayers facing BIR deficiency assessments should not treat the protest process as a mere formality: when the BIR rejects explanations and documents submitted in response to a PAN, FAN, or FDDA, it must state why. A […]

Criminal Tax Cases for Nonpayment Can Be Dismissed When the Government Files Too Late

Criminal tax charges for failure to pay were dismissed after the Information was filed beyond the five-year NIRC prescriptive period. Taxpayers facing criminal charges for alleged failure to pay assessed taxes should examine prescription immediately, because even a final and demandable tax assessment will not indefinitely keep a criminal tax case alive. In this Resolution, […]

Tax Appeals Can Be Lost on Filing Compliance, Not Just Assessment Merits

Late email transmittal of a tax appeal motion led the court to deem it not filed, reinforcing strict filing compliance in BIR assessment disputes. Taxpayers challenging BIR assessments before the Court of Tax Appeals must treat electronic transmittal requirements as jurisdiction-sensitive litigation deadlines: a motion for reconsideration filed in hard copy may still be treated […]