Courts May Relax Filing Deadlines When Strict Procedure Would Defeat Substantial Justice

Courts may relax missed filing deadlines when the delay is justified, non-prejudicial, and strict procedure would defeat substantial justice. Litigants who miss a procedural deadline are not always automatically out of court. When no substantial prejudice is shown and the delay results from circumstances that make strict compliance inequitable, courts may use their inherent power […]

When a Court-Approved Settlement Becomes a Judgment: Why Compromise Agreements Must Be Taken Seriously

Court-approved compromise agreements become binding judgments. Parties must carefully review settlement terms before asking the court to approve them. A compromise agreement approved by a court is not merely a private promise to settle; it becomes a judgment that binds the parties according to its exact terms. For litigants, business owners, property holders, and taxpayers […]

When a Land Dispute Is Really a Boundary Case, Consent Cannot Create Court Jurisdiction

Consent cannot give a court jurisdiction. A judge was exonerated for dismissing a forcible entry case that was actually a boundary dispute. Parties cannot cure a courtโ€™s lack of jurisdiction by agreeing on how their dispute should be decided. In land possession cases, especially those involving alleged encroachment, the decisive question is not merely what […]

When New Procedural Rules Overtake a Pending Criminal Challenge

A procedural attack on preliminary investigation may fail when later legal changes validate the challenged prosecutor authority and procedure. People challenging a prosecutorโ€™s authority in a pending criminal matter can lose the case when the very procedure they attack is later adopted as part of controlling law. In Litton v. Castillo, the Supreme Court treated […]