Legal Insanity Can Acquit an Accused but Not Erase Civil Liability

Legal insanity may acquit an accused from parricide, but civil damages and court-ordered psychiatric confinement may still follow. An accused who proves legal insanity may be acquitted even after trial and appeal, but the acquittal does not automatically free the accused from paying damages to the victimโ€™s heirs. The ruling matters because it separates criminal […]

A Guilty Plea Does Not Automatically Justify the Death Penalty When the Information Fails to Allege Qualifying Circumstances

The Court affirmed rape convictions but reduced the death penalty because minority and relationship were not alleged in the informations. An accused may admit guilt, and the evidence may strongly show a grave offense, but a court cannot impose the highest possible penalty unless the facts that legally justify that penalty were clearly alleged in […]

When Rape Penalties Fail on Technical Pleading: Why Prosecutors Must Allege Every Qualifying Circumstance

Rape conviction affirmed, but penalty reduced because qualifying relationship was not specifically alleged and proven beyond reasonable doubt. A rape conviction may stand even when the victimโ€™s medical findings are disputed, but the harshest penalty cannot be imposed unless every aggravating or qualifying circumstance was both clearly alleged in the charge and proven beyond reasonable […]

Tax Deficiency Assessments Based on False Returns Can Survive Prescription Challenges

False or underdeclared tax returns may extend BIR assessment periods, and taxpayers must contest assessments in the proper forum before deadlines lapse. Taxpayers who underdeclare income in a way that makes their return false cannot rely on the ordinary prescriptive period to defeat a deficiency tax assessment. Basa v. Republic reinforces a practical rule in […]

Bare Constitutional Attacks Will Not Overturn a Conviction When the Evidence Is Sufficient

A criminal appeal failed where constitutional objections were foreclosed by precedent and multiple witnesses supported the trial courtโ€™s factual findings. A criminal appeal cannot succeed on constitutional slogans alone when the prosecution has proved the required acts through competent witnesses and the accused has chosen not to present contrary evidence. In Alejandrino, the Supreme Court […]

You Cannot Be Convicted of Murder When the Charge Only Says Homicide

An accused charged only with homicide cannot be convicted of murder unless the qualifying circumstance is alleged in the information. A person accused of homicide cannot be sentenced for murder unless the facts that legally make the killing murder are clearly alleged in the criminal information. The constitutional right to be informed of the nature […]

When a Tax Prescription Loss Becomes a Collectible Deficiency: The Sison Finality Rule

A taxpayer who loses a prescription defense may face enforceable tax collection when the final judgment sustains the assessment and fixes liability. Taxpayers who lose a prescription defense in a tax case may not automatically get a second opportunity to relitigate the merits of the assessment. Where the courtโ€™s prior judgment necessarily sustains the tax […]