You Cannot Pierce the Corporate Veil Before Serving the Right Company

Foreign affiliates cannot be held liable by veil-piercing unless properly served first; labor tribunals must acquire jurisdiction before deciding corporate liability. Employees and claimants cannot shortcut jurisdiction by arguing that related corporations are really one and the same. Before a Philippine labor tribunal may pierce the corporate veil and impose solidary liability on a parent […]

Tax Appeals Can Be Lost by Courier: Why Private Delivery Does Not Stop the Filing Deadline

Private courier delivery does not count as court filing until actual receipt, causing PNB’s late CTA appeal on a tax refund balance to be dismissed. A taxpayer can lose the right to challenge a tax refund ruling even before the appellate court reaches the merits if the petition is delivered through a private courier and […]

Corporate Settlements Can End Litigation Even After Submission for Decision

The Supreme Court allowed withdrawal after settlement and denied intervention by a former counsel with only a contingent corporate interest. Corporate litigants who have resolved their boardroom dispute may ask the court to end the case even after it has been submitted for resolution, and a former lawyer or corporate officer cannot keep the lawsuit […]

When an Accused Withdraws His Appeal, the Conviction Becomes Final

An accused may withdraw a criminal appeal before decision, making the conviction final, because appeal is a waivable statutory privilege subject to court discretion. An accused person who appeals a criminal conviction may still abandon that appeal before the case is submitted for decision, but the consequence is serious: the conviction and sentence become final […]

Corporate Officers Are Not Personally Liable for Backwages Without Bad Faith or Fraud

Corporate officers and affiliates are not personally liable for labor awards absent proof of bad faith, fraud, or a valid basis to pierce the corporate veil. Corporate officers, directors, and related companies cannot be made to pay an employer’s labor judgment merely because they managed the business, owned shares, or shared personnel with the employer. […]

Deemed Admissions in Property Cases: When Silence Defeats a Claim

Failure to answer requests for admission can conclusively defeat a property claim and justify summary judgment in Philippine title disputes. Deemed admissions in property cases can end a lawsuit before trial when a party ignores a request to admit facts that go to the heart of ownership. For property owners and litigants, the rule is […]

A Missed Service Copy Should Not Kill a Worker’s Labor Appeal

A worker’s NLRC appeal should not be dismissed for a non-prejudicial failure to serve a copy when substantial justice requires review on the merits. A labor appeal should not be dismissed on a purely technical defect when the worker timely filed the appeal, acted in good faith, and the missing copy to the employer did […]

Poor Litigants Can Appeal Without Paying for a Printed Record

Pauper litigants allowed to appeal need not file a printed record on appeal; procedural reforms may apply retroactively to protect appellate review. Litigants who are allowed to appeal as paupers are not required to shoulder the cost of preparing and filing a printed record on appeal. For taxpayers, property owners, and ordinary litigants who may […]

When Consent Is Legally Impossible: Rape, Mental Deficiency, and the Weight of Victim Testimony

A mentally deficient complainant’s incapacity to give legal consent sustained a rape conviction, even without force, while the Court recommended clemency. A conviction for rape may stand even without proof of physical force or active resistance when the complainant is mentally deficient and legally incapable of giving meaningful consent. For victims and families, the ruling […]