FTAA Contract Jurisdiction Rule: Why Forum Matters in Mining Disputes

FTAA cancellations are contractual administrative acts, not Rule 43 judgments; parties must use the proper court remedy to challenge mining contract validity. Government resource contracts cannot be attacked, appealed, or defended as if every executive action were a court judgment. The FTAA Contract Jurisdiction Rule teaches a practical lesson for companies dealing with mining rights, […]

Non-Impairment Doctrine: Supreme Court Affirms PICOP Timber Rights

Supreme Court affirms PICOP’s timber rights under Presidential Warranty, establishing that licenses are protected and cannot be impaired by later government actions. The Supreme Court has clarified that timber licenses granted under a Presidential Warranty are not contracts and cannot be impaired by later government actions, protecting existing rights of concessionaires over forest lands even […]

Foreign Mining Control Can Void Resource Contracts: What La Bugal Means for Investors, Communities, and the State

La Bugal voided mining provisions and an FTAA for giving foreign contractors control beyond constitutional limits on Philippine natural resources. Large-scale mining contracts with foreign corporations may be struck down when they cross the constitutional line from technical or financial assistance into foreign control of Philippine natural resources. For mining investors, indigenous communities, landowners, and […]

Recorded Mining Claims: When Land Registration Still Prevails

Recorded mining claims do not defeat land registration unless the claimant first proves actual annual work and continued compliance under mining law. A recorded mining claim is not a land title. The Mining Claim Possession Doctrine clarified in Atok Big-Wedge Mining teaches that a mining locator may have possessory rights against later mining claimants, but […]

Tax Declarations Cannot Convert Mineral Land Into Private Agricultural Property

Tax declarations and possession cannot defeat perfected mining claims or convert mineral public land into private agricultural property under the Regalian doctrine. Tax declarations and long occupation may help prove possession, but they cannot convert mineral land of the public domain into private agricultural property when perfected mining claims and the State’s ownership of natural […]