Customs Brokers Are Not Automatically Criminally Liable for Misdeclared Imports

Customs broker acquitted in a CMTA misdeclaration case after prosecutors failed to prove intent, knowledge, or willful participation in customs fraud. A customs broker charged over a misdeclared importation may avoid criminal liability when the prosecution cannot prove that the broker knew of the false declaration, personally participated in the fraud, or willfully conspired with […]

Customs Smuggling Charges Can Be Dismissed When Commissioner Approval Is Missing

Customs smuggling charges were dismissed after required Commissioner approval was not shown and agency findings confirmed valid importation and duty payment. Importers, vessel operators, customs brokers, and traders facing smuggling-related criminal charges may challenge the case at the outset when the government cannot show the required authority to institute the prosecution. In a criminal customs […]

Acquittal Upheld: Drivers Not Liable for Excise Tax on Untaxed Cigarettes

CTA upholds acquittal of driver Victor Gaw Sy; individuals not owners or importers cannot be held liable for excise taxes on untaxed cigarettes. Taxpayers and logistics operators can take note: individuals who are merely drivers or custodians of goods cannot automatically be held liable for excise taxes unless they are proven to be owners or […]

Court Denies BIR Reconsideration in GB BEM Cigarette Tax Case

The CTA denied the BIR’s Motion for Reconsideration, affirming the acquittal of GB BEM Cigarette Co. and officers due to double jeopardy and unlawful seizure. Taxpayers and corporate officers must recognize that a judgment of acquittal in a criminal tax case is final and cannot be challenged through a motion for reconsideration. In a recent […]

Tax Case Dismissed for Lack of Due Process in Smallville IT Enterprise Matter

The CTA dismissed the tax case against Smallville IT and its officers due to failure to properly serve subpoenas, emphasizing the right to due process in preliminary investigations. Taxpayers and corporate officers must now exercise vigilance in ensuring that all preliminary investigation procedures are strictly observed. Failure by the prosecuting authority to properly serve subpoenas […]

BIR Criminal Case Dismissed Due to Prescription Against Taxpayer

The CTA En Banc dismissed a criminal VAT case against a taxpayer due to prescription and improper BIR filing, affirming strict timelines and the Solicitor General’s role in appellate tax cases. Taxpayers and corporate practitioners should note that the Court of Tax Appeals En Banc has affirmed the dismissal of a criminal case against a […]

Failure to Protest Tax Assessment Leads to Dismissal of Criminal Case

The CTA dismissed the criminal case against Bernadette L. Pardo for violation of the NIRC due to expiration of the five-year prescriptive period; timely protests are crucial. Taxpayers and proprietors must be aware that failing to respond timely to a Final Letter of Demand (FLD) can result in criminal liability claims being barred by prescription. […]

Criminal Tax Case Dismissed Due to Expired Prescriptive Period

The CTA denied the government’s motion for reconsideration, confirming the criminal tax case against W2 Electro Mechanical and its president was dismissed due to prescription. Taxpayers and corporate officers should note that criminal actions for violations of the National Internal Revenue Code (NIRC) are strictly bound by prescriptive periods. In a recent resolution, the Court […]

Tax Case Dismissal Highlights Importance of Valid Final Assessment Notices

The CTA dismissed the criminal tax case against Lilibeth Ramos Aragon, ruling that failure to properly serve a valid FAN/FLD negates willful failure to pay VAT liability. Taxpayers who receive deficiency assessments must be aware that a valid Final Assessment Notice (FAN) and Formal Letter of Demand (FLD) are indispensable before any criminal liability for […]

Prescriptive Period Limits Criminal Tax Prosecution for Importer in Quezon City

The CTA denied a Motion for Reconsideration in a criminal tax case, ruling that filing before the DOJ does not toll the five-year prescriptive period; timely court filing is required. Taxpayers and importers are reminded that the prescriptive period is strictly enforced in criminal tax cases, and filing a complaint with the Department of Justice […]