Government Corporations Can Be Sued When They Run Like Private Businesses

Government-owned transport corporations may be sued for negligence when acting commercially, and PNR was held liable for a fatal unsafe railroad crossing collision. Government-owned corporations cannot automatically hide behind State immunity when they operate commercial services. When the government enters the marketplace through a corporation, especially in transportation, courts may treat that corporation like any […]

When a Government Corporation Acts Like a Business, It Can Be Sued Like One

Government corporations may be sued when acting commercially. The Supreme Court allowed a damages case against PNR for alleged common carrier negligence. Government ownership does not automatically shield a corporation from lawsuits. When the State chooses to operate through a corporation engaged in commercial or proprietary activity, that entity may be treated like a private […]

When Illness Strikes at Work, Employers Must Overcome the Presumption of Compensability

The Court reinstated disability compensation after holding that illness during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer rebuts it with substantial evidence. Employees who become ill or disabled while still in government service do not begin from zero: under the old Workmen’s Compensation Act, the law presumed the illness compensable unless the employer produced substantial […]

When a Government Worker’s Final Compensation Award Cannot Be Reversed Later

A final workmen’s compensation award for a government gardener with tuberculosis could not be reversed after the review period expired. A final compensation award in favor of an injured or sick worker cannot be undone by a tribunal that has already lost jurisdiction over the case. For employees, especially those serving in government offices, the […]

When Employers Miss the Deadline, Work Injury Claims Become Much Harder to Defeat

Illness arising during employment is presumed work-related, and an employer that fails to timely controvert may waive defenses to compensation. An employee who becomes ill while still in service does not always have to prove, from scratch, that the job caused the illness. Under the workmen’s compensation presumption applied in Ferrer, an illness that supervened […]

A Wrong Respondent Did Not Defeat a Widow’s Workmen’s Compensation Claim

A widow’s compensation claim survived despite naming the wrong public office because substantial justice prevails over technical errors in workmen’s compensation cases. Workmen’s compensation claims should not be lost merely because the worker’s family named the wrong government office, when the record shows a compensable death, the true employer can be identified, and the proper […]