RMC No. 25-2023: Student Fare Discount Tax Deduction Rules for Public Transportation Operators

RMC No. 25-2023 confirms tax treatment of the 20% student fare discount and documentation duties for public transport operators. Public transportation operators should treat student fare discounts as a tax-deductible, documentable business cost, not merely as a fare-table issue. RMC No. 25-2023 circularizes Republic Act No. 11314, the Student Fare Discount Act, and confirms for […]

Delegated Transport Police Power: Valid Fines for Road Safety

Transport fines may stand when delegated by law, tied to road safety, and not proven arbitrary, vague, oppressive, or unequal under Philippine law. Transport operators and drivers cannot defeat higher traffic fines merely by calling them oppressive, confiscatory, or revenue-generating. Under the Delegated Transport Police Power Doctrine, administrative agencies regulating land transportation may prescribe fines […]

Employer Income Certifications Can Prove Lost Earning Capacity Without Tax Returns

Employer income certifications may prove lost earning capacity even without tax returns when reliable, unchallenged, and sufficient for a fair damages estimate. Families claiming damages for wrongful death are not automatically defeated just because they cannot present income tax returns. When a deceased worker’s earnings are supported by a reliable employer certification, and the opposing […]

Carrier Courtesy Rule: Passenger Abuse Creates Airline Liability

Airlines may owe moral and exemplary damages when ticket breaches are aggravated by rude, humiliating treatment of passengers. Airline passengers may recover moral and exemplary damages when a carrier breaches the ticket terms and aggravates that breach through rude, humiliating, or abusive treatment by its employees. The Carrier Courtesy Rule matters because a passenger dispute […]

Tax Returns Can Make or Break Lost Income Claims After an Accident

Lost income after an accident must be proven with competent records. Tax returns, employer certifications, and withholding proof can decide actual damages claims. People claiming lost income in court cannot rely on memory, estimates, or sympathy alone. When an accident victim asks for compensation for missed earnings or impaired earning capacity, the claim must be […]

Government Corporations Can Be Sued When They Run Like Private Businesses

Government-owned transport corporations may be sued for negligence when acting commercially, and PNR was held liable for a fatal unsafe railroad crossing collision. Government-owned corporations cannot automatically hide behind State immunity when they operate commercial services. When the government enters the marketplace through a corporation, especially in transportation, courts may treat that corporation like any […]

When a Government Corporation Acts Like a Business, It Can Be Sued Like One

Government corporations may be sued when acting commercially. The Supreme Court allowed a damages case against PNR for alleged common carrier negligence. Government ownership does not automatically shield a corporation from lawsuits. When the State chooses to operate through a corporation engaged in commercial or proprietary activity, that entity may be treated like a private […]

When Government Corporations Can Be Sued Like Private Businesses

Government-owned corporations may be sued when acting in a business capacity, as PNR was held answerable for alleged passenger negligence. Victims may sue a government-owned corporation for damages when the corporation is operating in a proprietary or business capacity, such as transporting passengers for hire, because the State’s immunity from suit does not automatically shield […]

When a Jeepney Tire Blowout Is Not an Act of God: Passenger Rights Against Common Carriers

A jeepney tire blowout did not automatically excuse the carrier; speeding, overloading, and lack of precautions supported passenger damages. Passengers injured in a public utility vehicle cannot be defeated by the simple explanation that a tire suddenly exploded. A tire blowout may appear accidental, but a common carrier remains liable when the accident is traceable […]