Labor Disputes Cannot Be Repackaged as Civil Damage Cases

Civil courts cannot hear damages suits or issue injunctions when the dispute is rooted in unfair labor practice, union activity, or picketing. Employers cannot avoid the labor forum by filing a civil damages case when the dispute is rooted in alleged unfair labor practices, union activity, or picketing. When the acts complained of are intertwined […]

COA Audits Are Advisory, Not a Veto Over Public Utility Rate Increases

COA valuations may assist but do not control utility rate cases. The Court upheld a 55% electric rate increase despite a pending government audit. Regulated utilities may obtain rate increases even before a Commission on Audit valuation is completed, if the rate-setting body has enough evidence to determine that the increase is fair, reasonable, and […]

Court Personnel Misconduct Can Be Sanctioned Even When the Complainant Backs Out

A complainantโ€™s desistance does not bar discipline of court personnel when independent records prove misconduct affecting judicial integrity. A complainantโ€™s withdrawal does not automatically end an administrative case against court personnel. When the record itself shows conduct that undermines the dignity of the courts, the Supreme Court may still impose discipline, even if the original […]

When a False Name Cannot Defeat a Murder Conviction

A murder conviction was affirmed despite alias issues because witnesses identified the accused, while treachery and conspiracy were inferred from the coordinated shooting. A criminal conviction does not fall simply because the accused claims he was charged under the wrong name, where witnesses positively identify him as the offender and the record shows that the […]

When Violence Enters the Home: Why Temporary Shelter Can Still Make a Crime More Serious

Temporary shelter in a family home may still trigger dwelling as an aggravating circumstance, while treachery requires clear proof of deliberate attack method. A person who attacks a victim inside a home cannot escape the aggravating circumstance of dwelling merely because the victim was only temporarily staying there. The ruling matters because Philippine criminal law […]

When the First Court Gets the Case: Jurisdiction Lessons for Tax and Regulatory Prosecutions

A court that first validly acquires jurisdiction over a criminal case keeps it, even when co-accused face different penalties. A criminal prosecution should not be split between courts merely because different accused persons may face different penalties. When one court first validly acquires jurisdiction over the offense, that court proceeds with the case and excludes […]

When Government Corporations Can Be Sued Like Private Businesses

Government-owned corporations may be sued when acting in a business capacity, as PNR was held answerable for alleged passenger negligence. Victims may sue a government-owned corporation for damages when the corporation is operating in a proprietary or business capacity, such as transporting passengers for hire, because the Stateโ€™s immunity from suit does not automatically shield […]

A Pending Appeal Does Not Automatically Stop Execution of Judgment

Pending appeals do not automatically stop execution. Sheriffs must enforce judgments absent a valid restraining order or face administrative liability. A judgment creditor does not have to wait indefinitely simply because the losing party keeps filing appeals, petitions, or last-minute motions. Unless a court issues a valid restraining order, a sheriff tasked with enforcing a […]

When Work-Related Illness Is Presumed: The Burden Employers Must Carry in Compensation Claims

Illness or death during employment may be presumed compensable, shifting the burden to the employer to rebut work connection with substantial evidence. Employees and their families can win compensation even without direct medical proof that the job caused the illness, when the law creates a presumption that an ailment arising during employment is work-connected and […]