When Illness Appears During Employment, the Employer Must Disprove Work Connection

Illness arising during employment is presumed compensable, and employers must timely controvert claims or risk waiving defenses under compensation law. Workers who become disabled while still employed are not required to prove every medical link between their job and their illness before compensation may be awarded; once the illness supervenes during employment, the law presumes […]

When Land Title Corrections Must Wait for the Main Ownership Case

Title corrections may be consolidated with pending cancellation cases when the same land and parties are involved, preventing conflicting rulings on property rights. A land-title correction cannot be treated as a shortcut when the same certificates of title are already under attack in a pending civil case between the same parties. Where the proposed technical […]

When a Tax or Regulatory Case Becomes Moot, the Court May Refuse to Decide It

Courts may dismiss tax or regulatory challenges when later events remove the live controversy, even if the original petition questioned jurisdiction. A court case can disappear as a live controversy when the facts that made judicial relief necessary no longer exist. For taxpayers, regulated businesses, unions, employers, and officers facing government or court orders, the […]

When a Court Hearing Becomes Void: Why Notice to Counsel Is Essential Due Process

The Supreme Court voided an ex parte hearing where counsel lacked meaningful notice of the correct venue, reaffirming due process in litigation. A party can lose a case not because the facts are weak, but because the court proceeds without giving its lawyer meaningful notice of when and where the hearing will occur. In Insular […]

Tax Declarations Cannot Cure a Forged Land Sale

Tax declarations may support a land claim, but they cannot cure a forged deed or suspicious sale. The Court affirmed ownership despite later tax records. Tax declarations may support possession, valuation, or assessment history, but they cannot convert a doubtful transaction into ownership. For property owners, heirs, and buyers, the lesson is direct: paying real […]

When a Sale Is Taxable Where the Order Is Booked, Not Where the Goods Are Used

A city may tax sales booked and paid within its territory even if goods are shipped elsewhere, but good-faith tax enforcement does not create personal liability. A business cannot avoid a local sales tax merely by shipping goods to customers outside the city if the sale itself was completed, booked, and paid for inside the […]

Penalty Hikes Cannot Reach Back: Why Older Fraud Cases Stay Under the Law in Force When the Act Was Done

Penalty increases cannot be applied retroactively to older fraud cases; jurisdiction depends on the penalty in force when the alleged act occurred. Criminal penalty increases do not automatically make older conduct more serious in court. When an alleged fraud or bouncing-check offense was committed before a harsher penalty law took effect, prosecutors and judges must […]