When a Labor Case Settles During Appeal, the Court Can Still Turn the Compromise Into a Binding Judgment

A labor appeal may be dismissed after lawful compromise, with the Court approving the settlement and requiring compliance without deciding liability. Parties in a labor dispute may end an appeal by settlement, but once the Supreme Court approves their compromise agreement, that settlement becomes more than a private bargain. It becomes a binding judicially recognized […]

Court Staff Can Be Disciplined for Rude Phone Conduct, Even When Dismissal Is Too Harsh

Court personnel may be reprimanded for discourteous phone conduct, but dismissal requires clearer proof of serious unfitness and a proportionate penalty. Discourtesy by court personnel can become an administrative offense even when it occurs in a brief telephone exchange, but dismissal from government service requires a clearer and more serious showing of unfitness than a […]

When a Labor Award Cannot Bind a Person Who Was Never Served Summons

A labor compensation award cannot bind or be executed against a person who was never properly served summons or shown to have appeared. A compensation award cannot be enforced against a person who was never properly brought under the tribunal’s jurisdiction. Even in socially protective proceedings such as workmen’s compensation claims, notice of a claim […]

When Job Stress Makes Illness Compensable: The Presumption That Protects Long-Serving Employees

Illness that appears during employment may be presumed compensable, shifting the burden to the employer to disprove work connection or aggravation. Employees who become ill while still in service do not always have to prove, with medical certainty, that their work alone caused the disease. Under the old Workmen’s Compensation regime applied in Flores, once […]

When a Permit Dispute Becomes Moot: Why Courts Will Not Decide Dead Regulatory Cases

Courts may dismiss certiorari petitions attacking provisional permit orders when later proceedings make the dispute moot and factual issues remain unresolved. Courts will not spend judicial time deciding a permit dispute that has already lost its practical effect. For businesses challenging government action, including regulated taxpayers and permit holders, the lesson is direct: a certiorari […]

When Illness Strikes at Work, the Employer Must Disprove Compensation

Illness arising during strenuous employment is presumed compensable unless the employer disproves work-connection and timely controverts the claim. Employees who fall ill while performing strenuous work may be entitled to compensation even when medical certainty is unavailable, because the law presumes compensability once the illness arises or worsens during employment. The burden is not on […]

When the Government Appeals a Land Registration Case, the Clock Runs From Notice to the Solicitor General

Service on a local fiscal did not start the Republic’s appeal period where the Solicitor General retained control, making the government’s land registration appeal timely. Government appeals in land registration cases are not lost simply because a local fiscal received the trial court decision earlier than the Solicitor General. When the Solicitor General has reserved […]

When Union Settlements Bind Workers: Labor Peace Can End Long-Running Pay Disputes

Union-approved labor settlements can bind dissenting workers when lawful, and attorney’s fee disputes cannot block compromises that restore industrial peace. Union members may be bound by a settlement approved by their legitimate union leadership, even when some members disagree, when the compromise ends a long-running labor dispute and is not illegal, immoral, or contrary to […]