When Illness Appears During Work, the Burden Shifts to the Employer

The Court reinforced presumed compensability for illnesses arising during employment and barred employers from belated defenses after non-controversion. Workers and their families do not lose compensation claims merely because an illness is difficult to trace with mathematical certainty. When sickness, disability, or death arises during covered employment, the law may presume compensability, and the employer […]

When a Tenant Withdraws an Appeal, Execution Does Not Rewind Time

A withdrawn appeal makes a judgment final only upon effective withdrawal and remand; a lessee may receive indemnity for improvements but cannot force a land sale. A party who appeals a judgment and later withdraws that appeal cannot treat the case as if the appeal never existed. The judgment becomes final only when the withdrawal […]

Judicial Bias Complaints Need Proof, Not Suspicion

Bias complaints against judges require proof. Lastimoso v. Judge Lambo cleared a judge but warned courts to avoid remarks that cast doubt on impartiality. Litigants who believe a judge is biased may file an administrative complaint, but suspicion alone is not enough: the complainant must be willing to prove the charge, and a judge may […]

Wrongful Attachment and Replevin Bonds: When a Surety Can Still Be Made to Pay Damages

A timely bond-damage claim preserves recovery for wrongful replevin or attachment, but the surety must receive notice and a summary hearing before liability. A party whose property is wrongfully seized under a provisional remedy is not limited to winning the main case. If the writ of attachment, injunction, replevin, or receivership caused damage, the injured […]

When a Notarized Will Is Hard to Defeat: The Probate Rule Every Heir Should Know

A notarized will supported by competent instrumental witnesses is difficult to defeat without clear, convincing proof of defective execution or incapacity. A notarized will supported by the testimony of its instrumental witnesses is not easily defeated by suspicion, family conflict, or minor inconsistencies. For heirs contesting a will, Gonzales v. Court of Appeals teaches a […]

Piece-Rate Workers May Still Be Employees: The Control Test in Philippine Labor Law

Piece-rate and pakyaw workers may still be employees when the business controls how work is done, affecting unfair labor practice and backwage claims. Workers paid by the piece, called only when work is available, or compensated under the familiar pakyaw arrangement may still be regular employees if the business retains the right to control how […]

Land Registration Courts Can Decide Heirship When Property Rights Depend on Inheritance

Land registration courts may resolve heirship when parties submit the issue, and title registration may still require estate or inheritance tax compliance. Heirs and land claimants cannot always force a separate probate case before ownership is settled. When all parties voluntarily submit their competing inheritance claims in a land registration case, the land registration court […]

A Defective Name-Change Petition Can Void the Entire Court Order

A name-change order is void if the petition and publication omit the new name sought, affecting tax, regulatory, and official identity records. A court-approved change of name is not secure if the petition and publication failed to tell the public the actual new name being requested. The doctrine is simple but consequential: in a change-of-name […]